Independent Watch Movement Finishing Scores
Independents

Independent Watch Movement Finishing Scores

By scwjm · Apr 29, 2022 · 23 replies
scwjm
WPS member · Independents forum
23 replies5039 views1 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

In a quest for deeper horological understanding, WatchProSite member scwjm challenges the community to articulate the nuances of movement finishing among independent watchmakers. His inquiry seeks to move beyond subjective appreciation, aiming to quantify and compare the finishing quality of brands like Laurent Ferrier, Moritz Grossmann, Voutilainen, F.P. Journe, and CZAPEK. This article synthesizes expert opinions to illuminate the intricate details that define exceptional movement finishing.

23 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
I've been in the independent watch world for a while and am thinking about my next watch. But I have never really understood movement finishing. In other words, when two top watches are in front of me, I am not sure which one has a good finishing and why it is good. If taking Philippe Dufour and Greubel Forsey finishing as 10 (not sure if they are the same level of finishing), I would like to know what you think about other brands.

Options for my next watch (favorites in order): Laurent Ferrier mirco rotor, Moritz Grossmann hamatic, Voutilainen (25% deposit and 5+ years waitlist), F.P.Journe Souverain/Elegante, CZAPEK (haven't touched it in person)


 






Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
MA
matto1
Apr 29, 2022

in person, but my deposit has been put down with Kari. I believe his are among the best finished watches being made.

WA
Watchonthewrist
Apr 29, 2022

But all options are amazing and beautiful in there own way imho

AU
AuHavrePro
Apr 29, 2022

I simply don't inherently care as much for the exact level of movement finishing as I do for my holistic opinion and feeling for the watch. The movement finish can be by far the best one of a certain selection of pieces, and I will still go with the watch which speaks most to my heart. I am thus precluded from making such 'coldly calculated' choices when it comes to timepieces . Cheers, Filip

SC
scwjm
Apr 29, 2022

Currently, I don't have enough funds to buy another watch after depositing it, and it's a long waiting time.

GE
Gelato Monster
Apr 29, 2022

Those LF are also stunning. Thank you Nico

SC
scwjm
Apr 29, 2022

I started to buy watches in 2017 and began to appreciate independent watchmaking in 2019. I chose my pieces based on my own experience and taste. That's why I have only a minimal knowledge of finishing, even though I've tried most of them. If buying the third one followed by my taste, I'd go for a micro rotor or a journe cause the others are too big. They're probably more like a clock on my wrist. I would like to jump out of the circle and look at watches from a new perspective (maybe finishing

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Independents forum with 23 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →