IWC Portofino Ref. 5251 Closed vs. Display Back
Collection

IWC Portofino Ref. 5251 Closed vs. Display Back

By shing · Aug 12, 2013 · 9 replies
shing
WPS member · Horological Meandering forum
9 replies2446 views0 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

Shing presents a fascinating comparison of two IWC Portofino Ref. 5251 watches, acquired during an 'unusually full' moon week. This post delves into the subtle yet significant differences between a closed and display case back version of this highly sought-after reference, offering a rare side-by-side examination for collectors.

been a while since I acquired my ref 5251, in the same month as my platinum 5001-04,

 photo 5001-045251newCatalog22Jun121.jpg

 photo 52514Jun122.jpg

 photo 5001-045251newCatalog22Jun127.jpg

...and it so happened this week that I spotted and swooped upon a 'similar 5251' to add to my collection. but I have always longed for an opportunity to compare both in the quiet of my own home, and at the price point which I acquired it, it seemed a great opportunity.

what am I talking about ? the pics and bottom writeup should explain this. enjoy.

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-00_zps9782e4d2.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-01_zpsa058aca7.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-11_zpsf3b6f7b4.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-12_zps4564ae7d.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux6-24_zps6ba2bc14.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-13_zpsb16d5a2c.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-14_zps40dbc8dd.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-15_zps812020b9.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-16_zpsca5f517e.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-18_zps6037e122.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux6-27_zps72e16821.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux6-29_zpsbd1d0f49.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux6-31_zps02893fbd.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux6-33_zps3384725b.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-22_zpsdaa11955.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux6-43_zps44ce1882.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-25_zpsb7c62ebe.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-27_zps1bb57d56.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux5-29_zpsa564a53e.jpg

 photo IWC5251displayclosedbackcomparison26Jun13Dlux6-52_zpsd11d818e.jpg

the ref 5251 otherwise known as the 'fried egg' or 'spiegelei' in German, or the 'original Portofino', although some creative licence applies to the last. Key differences between the two versions: a larger/more sunken & more perceptible seconds counter; greater thickness due to the crystal display-back; slight weight difference due to the solid gold caseback.

Housing the pocket watch Cal 95 movement, the ref 5251 was conceived by Kurt Klaus and IWC designer Hanno Burtcher (over a beer, or in a bar, or in a disco: I have heard all three situations smile, who decided to re-launch the 5250 pocket watch as a big wristwatch by adding lugs and strap.

Clocking in at 46mm, and the two different heights you can see in the pics, there are two (established*) versions of ref 5251 - all in yellow gold, and one with a solid gold back, and the other a display back. Production first began in 1980 of the (rarer) closed back version, and ceased (I believe) around 1998. The ref 5251 is today an iconic part of IWC's history, and to me, reflective of the 'big watch' thinking that is very much part of its DNA.

For further reading and even greater pictures, please look at:
(Attention: No links, please. Thanks! Oliver)

*I have recounted to me by a watch buddy who insists he saw a white gold version of the ref 5251 showed to him by a private collector.

thanks for reading !

 photo L1050648.jpg This message has been edited by small-luxury-world on 2013-08-13 00:56:44

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
AR
Ares501 - Mr Green
Aug 13, 2013

Lovely pictures Thank you for sharing Enviously yours Damjan

SP
Spellbound
Aug 13, 2013

Hey Shing, every time I see this watch it takes my breath away. Wondering what a new moon looks like. Is it true that the moon phase was created by the famous Murano glass makers in Venice? Dean

SH
shing
Aug 13, 2013

...at least that's what officially stated. Let me ask Kurt Klaus next chance I get :) his answer can sometimes be surprising ! :)

FL
flamenco
Aug 13, 2013

Once upon a time ... almost settled on an FA Jones. But ! Every time I see this ... One is great, but two is totally insane! Never knew they came in open case back. Thanks for the superb write up and education.

FO
foversta
Aug 16, 2013

The "new" Portofino Moonphase is far from having the charm and the beauty of this duet... Fx

HO
Hororgasm
Aug 18, 2013

Great to see this. Haven't worn mine for some time. A friend once said ..."it's the Mercedes SL of the watch world" Thanks for sharing them. Best, Horo

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 9 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →