Panerai Luminor vs. Radiomir: Size and Comfort
Review

Panerai Luminor vs. Radiomir: Size and Comfort

By Subexplorer · Apr 28, 2018 · 22 replies
Subexplorer
WPS member · Officine Panerai forum
22 replies4828 views1 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 ✉ 🔗

Subexplorer initiates a detailed comparison of Panerai Luminor and Radiomir models, specifically focusing on the PAM 587, PAM 662, PAM 673, and PAM 372. His post delves into the subtle differences in case and lug shapes, and how these impact wrist comfort, particularly for a 47mm watch on a thinner wrist. This exploration provides valuable insights for collectors considering these iconic large-cased Panerai references.

Along the recent post of our colleague Raymond sharing his beautiful Pam 587 Mamma Mia, the question about the possible difference in sizes and comfort of Model 587/662 Radiomir with lugs and Luminor cases.

Also Nicolas wondered if the cases of 587 MM and brown dial 662 were different sizes or not.

I already shared pictures of those two non bridge cases and they are the same. Thickness of all models mentioned in present post is the same: 16mm though measured with a rather primitive caliper.

Now: these are my observations and comments regarding these models:

There is a slight difference between the 587/662  and the 673/372 Lugs shapes. This may influence the way they seat on wrist.

I would say that cases are identical, but they seat on the wrist slightly different. There is a subtle difference in how it feels each watch on the wrist, but arguing which is most comfortable is something I don´t know if we can discuss as the perception will vary from person to person.

I doubt that this will be visible in my photographs either.

This is a very personal feeling which should be evaluated by each owner because as I said before, the shape of wrist is very important here, and also how each person feels about a big watch attached to his wrist. 

We should always remember we are talking of really big watches at 47 mm case.
I personally feel comfortable with "normal" watches of say 36/40 mm case of Rolex DJ and Submariners, with maximun 42 mm.for some other brands.

My only exception of my personal rule are the Panerais, because size is part of their DNA and I love these watches, and another exception is my IWC Big Pilot which I adore.

By the way my wrist is rather thin at 17,5 cm roughly 7,2 inches. It is rather “flat” on top which allows to accomodate a big 47 mm Pam anyway. The wrist bone protudes a bit so I need to strap my watch a bit above it.

Pictures will follow...

Cheers! Abel




About the Omega Planet Ocean Ref. 662

The Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean reference 662 is a notable example within the broader Planet Ocean collection, distinguished by its specific configuration and materials. This reference represents a particular iteration that balances robust functionality with refined aesthetics, appealing to collectors who appreciate a substantial yet wearable timepiece. It is part of a series that emphasizes durability and precision, consistent with Omega's heritage in professional-grade instruments. The 662 offers a distinct presence on the wrist, reflecting its design intent for both daily wear and more demanding environments.

This particular reference features a stainless steel case, providing a resilient and classic foundation. It is equipped with an automatic movement, ensuring reliable timekeeping and convenience for the wearer. The watch typically incorporates a sapphire crystal, known for its scratch resistance, protecting the dial. While specific dimensions can vary across the Planet Ocean line, the 662 maintains a balanced proportion that contributes to its wearability despite its robust construction.

For collectors, the reference 662 holds interest as a specific variant within the extensive Planet Ocean family. Its appeal lies in its combination of established design elements and technical specifications. It caters to those seeking a well-engineered timepiece with a strong identity, without venturing into more specialized or limited editions. The 662 stands as a solid representation of the Planet Ocean's core attributes, offering a blend of performance and enduring style.

Specifications

Caliber
Omega 8500
Case
Stainless steel
Diameter
42mm
Dial
Black
Water Resist.
600m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
SU
Subexplorer
Apr 28, 2018

If I’m asked ehich is more comfortable I would say that there is a slight feeling on MY wrist that the Luminor models seat a bit better. May be it is the feeling due to the presence of the bridge which makes it look and feel this way. But repeat: difference is very very small for my personal perception. I guess every potential buyer should check the desired watch on his own wrist. I hope these comments and picture are helpful! Cheers! Hagwe! Abel

SE
sergio
Apr 28, 2018

Master Measurer Abel. This confirms that, as I wrote since the beginning, the heft/chunky perception is nothing but a...personal...feeling. Grazie

SU
Subexplorer
Apr 28, 2018

... Enjoy it so much my friend!! Cheers! Abel

SU
Subexplorer
Apr 28, 2018

... Ciao and all the best my caro Sergio! Abel

SU
Subexplorer
Apr 28, 2018

... and the wereabouts of its hunting and purchase just a few moments before departing my flight back home after so long searching for it during my vacation trip. Also I was accompanied by my daughter which enhanced the charm of the ceremony of purchase. Now, even without considering all these personal values to me, I consider this model is one of the best modern offerings of Panerai, inlcuding the MM dial which is always a big point of interest for all Panerai lovers. Enjoy yours so much my fri

JO
JohnFM
Apr 28, 2018

We've put you to work with our curiosity and questions and you've delivered with some great pictures. Based on your comments and pictures (especially of the wrist shots from the side), it looks like the lugs of 1950 Luminor case (372 and 673) seat beautifully on your wrist, sort of bending down and touching (grazing) the sides of your wrist. In contrast (and, yes, this is nitpicking in the extreme) the lugs of the 1940 Radiomir case (662 and 587) don't quite come down and touch your wrist -- a h

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Officine Panerai forum with 22 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →