Rolex Watch: Buyer's Opinion Guide

penfriend · 2022-04-30T14:14:51Z

Debating Rolex Oyster Perpetual 36mm vs 41mm? Penfriend's dilemma sparks a WatchProSite discussion on wrist presence, proportions, and style. Get collector insights.

In a captivating thread, WatchProSite member penfriend shares a spontaneous Authorized Dealer call that led to his wife acquiring a vibrant pink Rolex Oyster Perpetual. Now, penfriend seeks community guidance on his own choice between a 36mm or 41mm green Oyster Perpetual, prompting a lively discussion on wrist presence, proportions, and personal style. This article distills the collective wisdom of the forum, offering valuable perspectives for anyone contemplating a similar decision.

AD called and surprised us with two colors. I never thought about these watches at all up to today so we went to take a look. My wife bought herself immediately the pink candy and I am pondering whether to take the green in 36 or 41. 41 seems to fit better for my 7.25 wrist but the 36 has better proportions as a watch. What would you recommend? Thanks in advance!!

Wife:

me in 36 green:

me in 41 green:

Key Points from the Discussion

The 41mm green Oyster Perpetual is a strong personal preference for larger wrists, as demonstrated by a collector who owns both the 41mm green and a 34mm black version for his girlfriend.
The perceived size of a 36mm watch can be influenced by its bezel; a smooth bezel, as on the Oyster Perpetual, may make it appear smaller than a fluted white gold bezel on a Datejust of the same diameter.
The choice between a 41mm and 36mm Oyster Perpetual depends on whether one prefers a sporty or classic aesthetic, and should consider existing collection pieces and intended use.
A larger 41mm watch is often preferred for casual settings like the beach or pool, where bare arms can accommodate a more prominent timepiece.
While the 41mm offers a sporty look, the 36mm provides a more understated presence, which can be a deciding factor for those who prefer less 'in-your-face' color.
Some collectors express a preference for a 39mm size, considering it ideal, especially when comparing to a 40mm daily wear Submariner.

The Discussion

@lberti

Apr 30, 2022

Hers is perfect in 36mm. Congrats

penfriend

Apr 30, 2022

candy is with my wife already ;-)

Arronax

Apr 30, 2022

All depends if you want to go for a sporty vibe (41) or a classic size, I would consider what else is in your collection and in what setting you plan to use the OP.

FabR

Apr 30, 2022

I do have the 41 green (and my girlfriend went for the 34 black), and personally I would have no doubt between the 41 and 36mm for myself ;-) Here's a few random recent shots on my (and her) wrist: Her (small, Korean) wrists with both

penfriend

Apr 30, 2022

thxs for your pictures, Fab!

penfriend

Apr 30, 2022

so yes, 41 is sporty but 36 is not so much in the face. I also saw 41 in yellow but this was too much color for me

Key Points from the Discussion

Continue the conversation

More from this Forum