Tudor Black Bay 54 Reference Guide
Reference Guide

Tudor Black Bay 54 Reference Guide

By Subexplorer · Dec 30, 2023 · 58 replies
Subexplorer
WPS member · Rolex forum
58 replies27680 views10 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 ✉ 🔗

Subexplorer, a seasoned collector, shares his latest acquisition, the Tudor Black Bay 54, offering a detailed comparison with its predecessors and a vintage Rolex Submariner 5508. His insightful review delves into the nuances of its 37mm case and 11.24mm thickness, highlighting its vintage appeal. This article explores Subexplorer's 'almost perfect' assessment, examining his proposed modifications that would, in his view, elevate the BB54 to horological perfection.

58 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
Hello dear friends.

I wish to share this new addition to my collection which arrived last Thursday 27th but by some reasons I could unpack it just today Saturday.

The new Tudor Black Bay 54 was introduced earlier this year and I felt the new case size of 37 mm would make for a more vintage looking version of the entire BB line.

Truth is that the smaller brother of the BB collection looks like a real vintage specially when you compare it with its previous models in the metal. Specially interesting is the thickness of just 11,24 mm and profile of the new BB54 which adds to its beauty I feel.

I tried to make a few shots with the other watches but I feel they don’t show in pictures the real difference. The difference really shows when you wear them.

In my personal opinion this is the “almost” perfect Black Bay if you like the looks of vintage Submariners from Tudor and Rolex from the early 1950’s.

I say “almost” because for my personal taste I would ask a few changes to Tudor if they offered a customization service. 
Those changes would make it really perfect and they are:

1) the winding crown a bit larger. The new crown has a nicer shape than those in previous models. But if a bit larger it would look much better yet resembling a “Big Crown” model.

2) Adoption of the Tudor Rose emblem on the dial. The Rose was present in the first edition of the BB 41mm.

3) Adoption of the “smile” inscription at six. Also a feature of the first BB edition.

4) Mercedes or Pencil handset and a lollipop seconds hand instead of “snowflake” hour hand.

These four changes would make this superb little watch truly perfect for my taste.

Anyway I’m very happy with this watch as is and I feel it will became my favorite among my BB collection which includes 
The 43 mm Bronzo, the 41 mm original red bezel BB and the 39 mm BB 58.

I am sharing some comparison shots of these watches including my beloved Rolex 5508 from 1958.

I hope you like them!

Best cordial regards and good wishes for a great New Year 2024 for all our friends here and their families. Be it with much Peace and Good Health!!

Abel














BB 58 39 mm at left and BB54 37 mm




Original BB 41 mm 1st series (see Rose emblem and “smiley” inscriptions at 6)




Submariner 5508 at left and new BB 54




Left to right: 43 mm, 41 mm, 39 mm and 37 mm




Thickness of four BB models.




Thickness of Submariner 5508 above and BB 54 below (11,24 mm Tudor)


About the Rolex Submariner Ref. 5508

The Rolex Submariner reference 5508 represents the No Date series within the Submariner model range. Produced from 1958 to 1962, this reference is distinguished by its black dial that has developed spider patina over time.

The 5508 features a 37mm stainless steel case fitted with an acrylic crystal and rotating bezel. Water resistance is rated to 200 meters. The automatic Cal. 1530 movement provides 42-48 hours of power reserve. The watch is paired with a steel bracelet.

This reference appeals to collectors focused on vintage Submariner variants from the late 1950s and early 1960s production period. The spider patina dial condition represents a specific aging characteristic that develops over decades. Within the No Date Submariner lineup, the 5508 occupies the position of a four-year production run reference with the Cal. 1530 movement.

Specifications

Caliber
Cal. 1530
Case
Stainless steel
Diameter
37 mm
Dial
Black with spider patina
Water Resist.
200m
Crystal
Acrylic

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
CO
COUNT DE MONET
Dec 30, 2023

First things first: I like your last addition alot! As you said, the size is very attractive and suits this BB, gives it a convincing feel. Congrats to this smart choice!

KC
KCLQMULKU
Dec 30, 2023

Big congrats on this Tudor!! The size against your wrist is flawless, and can definitely see the difference against its older cousins! Wishing you and your family and very happy and successful New Year to come!

MT
MTR
Dec 30, 2023

In the beginning I wasn’t sure if 37mm would perhaps be to small but I must confess it looks PERFECT on your wrist. I can follow your suggestions and share them, on the other hand this would be a completely different watch (and brand). LOLLL The very best to you too for 2024, good luck, satisfaction, fulfillment and, above all, health. Thomas

MI
MichaelC
Dec 30, 2023

Congratulations, my Friend. Wishing you all the best in 2024!

RE
Reuven Malter
Dec 30, 2023

A friend of mine has it and its a great piece for anyone, no matter if you are a beginner or if its the last piece in your collection.

SU
Subexplorer
Dec 30, 2023

Wishing you a wonderful New Year 2024 for you and your beloved ones my dear friend. Abel

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Rolex forum with 58 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →