image

Jaeger-Lecoultre SIHH 2015: First pictures and impressions on the Master Grande Tradition

amanico
Avatar
none

An interesting offer from this year certainly is this Master Grande Tradition Minute Repeater.

Interesting, because this watch has, undisputably, some nice aesthetical virtues, and because it houses a new generation of minute repeaters movement.

1/ The aesthetics:

Jaeger Lecoultre gave to this watch a new case, or more precisely, a new size... 39 mm, and 12, 1 mm high.

Which is, in my opinion, a daring but smart move.

Daring, because some may think that 39 mm is a tad small. Smart, because in this diameter, I find that the proportions of the case are very elegant. I always wanted to see a thinner MGT case, it is now done, and I am quite happy with the visual outcome, even if I think that The Grande Maison could do it slimmer, one or two millimeters slimmer.

none

This watch is a blend of polished and brushed parts. Polished, the lugs and the concave bezel, while the side of the case is brushed. Another pleasant detail to the eye. You certainly noticed that the Master Grande Tradition Line saw its case reworked, for more elegance. The Master Grande Tradition Grande Complication, despite its bigger dimension, received these changes.

The 2015 Master Grande Tradition Grande Complication:

none

At the contrary of what you can think when you see the pictures, the minute repeater is not activated through a conventional trigger, but through a pusher, shaped as a trigger.

none

That solution offers two advantages:

- It is more pleasant to use than the trigger.

- It is a safer way to activate the minute repeater. Once the minute repeater is working, you cannot start it again through the pusher. You have no other choice than waiting for the minute repeater, as it is not possible to re initiate it.

The dial is silver grained, and its hour markers are applied, in gold. The shape of these hours markers first appeared as a " Jubilé " signature in the Master Ultra Thin 39 Jubilé, or in the Master Grande Tradition Tourbillon Cylindrique Perpetual Calendar Jubilé.

none

The Dauphine hands receive a special treatment: They are facetted. One side is polished, the other is brushed.

The big Small Seconds subdial contributes to the balance of the dial. I am not sure the big gold circle surrounding it was necessary, though.

none

So, aestheticaly speaking, this Master Grande Tradition is very classic, yes, but it is elegant, understated, and has a lot of charm.

Well done, in my opinion. With one reserve...I really don't like the " plaque " located between 23 and 29 minutes. But I guess it is due to the fact that the gongs, welded to the sapphire, are located here.

Therefore, you will keep in mind that the Watch, took in picture, was a prototype, and that the plaque was not bearing any wording.

As you can see on the first picture of this article, there is now a wording " sonnerie ".

none

2/ The movement:

The Cal 942 is not really a new movement, as we first saw it in the very recent Rendez Vous Ivy Minute Repeater, unveiled in Hong Kong, during the Watches and Wonders Fair, in September 2014.

So, the Master Grande Tradition Minute Repeater is the second Watch to house it.

The Cal 942 is a 26 mm big, 7, 17 m thick movement, made of 437 parts, beating at 28 800 alternances per hour, and offering a power reserve of 40 hours.

While the full gold rotor is nicely designed and decorated, I feel that the movement decoration is not a the same level than the rest of the watch, and I regret we don't have something more special, in terms of finishings.

none

none

Therefore, the choice of an automatic movement for this Master Grande Tradition, for the Rendez Vous Ivy Minute Repeater, and for the Hybris Mechanica 11 raises a question: Is this the beginning of the automatic movements reign?

The Rendez Vous Ivy Minute Repeater:

none

none

The Hybris Mechanica 11:

none

Anyway, the minute repeater mechanism / system is well known and experienced:

You will find the Trebuchet hammers which were inaugurated with the Hybris Mechanica à Grande Sonnerie, in 2009, the Crystal gongs with a square section, welded to the sapphire used since 2005 in the Master Minute Repeater.

The Hybris Mechanica à Grande Sonnerie:

none

The Master Minute Repeater:

none

One information I didn't have, but which is important, is that the regulator operates at 20 Db, which is impressively silent, and important for a minute repeater. Those of us who heard minute repeaters are well aware that the noise of the regulator can ruin the quality of the sound. Good point there, then.

I heard this Minute Repeater as a prototype, so I will not give a definitive judgement. I will just say that, for now, the sound is loud enough, but I find it a bit too agressive. I discussed that point with the watchmakers in charge of this Master Grande Tradition, and they told me that they were still working on the settings. Definitive judgements on the sound with the definitive watch, then.

So, to conclude, I would say that I am very pleased with the aesthetics of this new Master Grande Tradition, I have no doubt that it will sound nicely, but I regret the choice of an automatic movement.

Looking forward to reading your comments and thoughts,

Best.

Nicolas This message has been edited by amanico on 2015-03-16 00:01:51 This message has been edited by amanico on 2015-03-20 23:31:41

Comments:
Avatar
dr.kol March 16th, 2015-01:36
Interesting, thank you for the review. If I compare this watch to i.e. Patek 5078P or the relatively new VC Minute Repeater, it is quite far away. Everything depends of course on the price. A minute Repeater is such a great and rare complication that one would expect plain perfection when the ... 
Avatar
amanico March 16th, 2015-10:46
I like the case a lot, as well as the dial, I am more reserved on the movement. Not mechanically, but aesthetically. Best, Nicolas
Avatar
Mark in Paris March 16th, 2015-03:02
A nice complete presentation Nicolas I must say I like the overall look of this MGT, especially the markings, the hands and the very nice white dial finish we already saw on other JLCs. There are just 3 things I would have liked to be different: . The "plaque" which looks a little too big. Y... 
Avatar
amanico March 16th, 2015-10:49
Agreed on the plaque and the pusher. Smaller would have been better in both cases. I am not sure about the movement. For me, a Minute Repeater is magic, and the movement should match with that magic spirit. The HM 11 has an interesting and nice movement. This one doesn't reach that level of finish. Not because it is automatic, just beca... 
jmpTT March 16th, 2015-10:44
Very nice write-up! Will it be "affordable"? The combination of clean aesthetics and frosted dial is very appealing. The base movement looks like it shares quite a bit in common with the accessible pieces in the Master series. Given JLC's capabilities, there's no doubt the movement could be finished... 
Avatar
amanico March 16th, 2015-10:50
I will soon know more about the price. That is a good question.  
Avatar
jml_watches March 16th, 2015-13:34
A couple of reservations Hi I think I'm in agreement with other comments made earlier. The dial is wonderful, though agree about the gold ring around the small seconds. The texture of the dial adds real depth and I really like the restraint of the markers. I also agree with you w... 
Avatar
amanico March 16th, 2015-15:05
We are in agreement, here. Thanks for your input.  
Avatar
blomman Mr Blue March 16th, 2015-15:14
Interesting move.... I get a Geophysic vibe from this one! :) The case, the dial..... But it is not a perfect match, just resembling details... I prefer the trigger before the pusher for sure. Too bad they put the gold plate at 5... Really like what I see, looking forward to ... 
Avatar
amanico March 16th, 2015-15:54
Two interesting things to discuss, IMO... The size, which is great, and the finish of the automatic problem, which is more discutable. A conversation piece... ;) Best, Blomman, and thanks for your feedback. Nicolas
0-10-10

Load More Comments




 Next Article
image
blomman Mr Blue
Avatar

1961 – 2012 Three Generations of Accuracy

blomman Mr Blue
Avatar
Friends, We often talk about the complicated or the sports... But I would like to put a light on some of the core criterions of a modern wrist watch: Time, Date, Automatic, Water resistant, Shock resistant and Accuracy. This is what a big part of the watch buying customers wants. Yes, is this order, at least if you look at most of the big Manufactures and their main part of watch production each year.


Go to top.

About US | Contact

© 2017 - WatchProZine