When a nice watc comes with the box and the papers, ok, I will not cry... But if the same very nice Watch comes without, I will not pass on it.
An example?
This 6542, which came with its papers. Not the box, but while I am at it, why not trying to hunt the box, and the correct booklet?


I can tell you that it would have come without its papers, I would have jumped on it. At the beginning, though, I didn't even know it came with its papers.
The seller didn't give me this precision.
This is when I started to harass him, and after a while, that he told me that it came with its papers...
Another example, my 1675 Mini Dial: I didn't really care that it didn't come with the box and the papers, I just fell in love with its dial:
Now, on some references like the 1680 Red, for example, I would take it with the papers, just to be sure.
Just to be sure of what, by the way???
Send it for a service at Rolex, and if you don't specify it, they remove the hands and may even change the dial.
A " smart " ( please understand A... H e, here ) could take a white 1680 and change the dial for a red one, and welcome to the gang of the deceived!
So, I agree with you, box and papers most of the time bring nothing to a Watch, except maybe a better value when you re sell it ( but you will pay the premium, too when you buy, so... ), but that it is the thing which interests us, isn't it?
Best,
Nicolas.