Bexei vs. Voutilainen: A Collector's Guide to Independent Horology

Cozmopak · 2020-12-28T21:05:49Z

Explore the debate between Bexei and Voutilainen watches for your next luxury acquisition. Collectors discuss customization, resale, and unique artistry.

Cozmopak

WPS member · Independents forum

43 replies10815 views0 photos

Cozmopak's exploration of Bexei and Voutilainen timepieces offers a fascinating look into the world of independent watchmaking. His thoughtful comparison, weighing the unique artistry of a single-man operation against the established excellence of a small atelier, provides a valuable framework for collectors considering high-horology acquisitions. This discussion highlights the nuanced factors beyond aesthetics that influence such significant decisions.

43 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

I’m fairly certain that I’ve narrowed it down between these two for my next large acquisition. Although it won’t happen for many months, maybe a year from now, it’s fun to think about. There is obviously no right answer. I love both of these makers and I’m curious what others think.

Voutilainen’s watches are breathtaking. They ooze quality. Although his production numbers aren’t high, he does make around 50 per year, I believe. And so his watch would feel more like a product of a brand to me. Also, there is a striking resemblance between Voutilainen and Jurgensen. They aren’t necessarily the most unique looking of watches.

Bexei is essentially a one man show. He does employ a few helpers but his production numbers are in the single digits per year (I believe 5 or 6). His watches do have a more unique look to them, at least to my eyes. They are beautifully made, although slightly thick at 14mm.

Either would fit well into my growing collection.

Key Points from the Discussion

Bexei offers a highly personalized experience, with the artisan Aaron P. Becsei and his team being genuinely lovely and open to client input, making the acquisition process a joy.
The Bexei appeals to collectors seeking individualization, the prestige of a 'one-man show,' and a flamboyant aesthetic, while Voutilainen offers advantages in resale value, perceived reliability, and versatile wearability.
When considering independents, factors like customization, style, and the artisan's story are paramount, but market-substantiated value and proven reliability, as seen with Voutilainen, also play a significant role.
Bexei's 'gothic-cathedral' aesthetic with floral engravings is highly distinctive, though potential concerns include wrist wearability and a specific movement slogan. Voutilainen's Vingt-8 offers superior finishing on components like the crown and ratchet wheels, and more black polish.
The choice between independents often comes down to personal preference and patronizing an artisan, especially in an era where social media amplifies their reach, making it a unique opportunity for collectors.
For those considering alternatives to Bexei and Voutilainen, independent watchmakers like Klings, known for their rustic, handmade appeal, or even Jean Daniel Nicolas for extremely high-end pieces, might be worth exploring.

The Discussion

jleno

Dec 28, 2020

I'm not as familiar with Bexei, but I love that gothic-cathedral look that some of the ones with floral engravings on the dial have. Make sure to avoid having that "where unique solutions are born" slogan written on the movement though. Finishing quality looks similar between the two. The Vingt-8 looks like it has some better finishing on the crown and ratchet wheels, and more black polish. But Bexei has some very nice anglage, and if there's a good amount of hand engraving on the dial that coun

mdg

Dec 28, 2020

..I know that doesn't make sense. Besides, for me, a dress watch (and they are dress watches) should be thinner. If you don't mind me throwing a name into the mix, have you considered Klings? He makes watches that really appeal to me...they are hand-made and look it. I really love the rustic nature of his watches. If you have really big money (really big) maybe Jean Daniel Nicolas... My .02.

Cozmopak

Dec 28, 2020

I love Klings, but I’m not sure whether he is making watches anymore? JDN is amazing, but way over budget for me.

ant

Dec 29, 2020

belongs to me. I have found Aaron and Eszter a joy to deal with. First, they are genuine lovely people. Communications are quick and clear. Aaron is modest, too modest considering his skills. He is open to all opinions and discussions. When I visited them in Budapest I received a warm and friendly welcome. Here are some pics that you might enjoy. Sorry about their low quality but I hope that they show how special Aaron's watches are. I have a medium size wrist and found the watch comfortable, no

Watchonthewrist

Dec 29, 2020

Two amazing masterpieces and both so different . If it was my choice (i hope to get one or both too in the near future) i would go for the Bexei first , more unique and absolute stunning . If your budget is healthy again after you purchased it you maybe can get a KV on the secondary market, they pop up sometimes where the Bexei is impossible to get because of its limited numbers. Just my thoughts 🤷🏻‍♂️

Watchonthewrist

Dec 29, 2020

Your very lucky to have this gorgeous watch in your collection imho. Excellent choice

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Independents forum with 43 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →

Bexei vs. Voutilainen: A Collector's Guide to Independent Horology

Key Points from the Discussion

Continue the conversation

More from this Forum