Patek Philippe 5164A vs. 5170G White Dial
Discussion

Patek Philippe 5164A vs. 5170G White Dial

By damianp · Jun 7, 2017 · 24 replies
damianp
WPS member · Patek Philippe forum
24 replies8323 views1 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

I've had a 5164a for quite a while now. At the beginning, I loved that watch. I still like it and I still wear it, but the burning love has disappeared. It's not in my Top 5 of watches I own anymore and much cheaper watches are now higher in my ranking. So I started asking myself, if I should keep a

24 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
I've had a 5164a for quite a while now. At the beginning, I loved that watch. I still like it and I still wear it, but the burning love has disappeared. It's not in my Top 5 of watches I own anymore and much cheaper watches are now higher in my ranking. So I started asking myself, if I should keep a watch that I like, but that has a much lower personal value to me compared to its actual value. I wouldn't have expected this. I thought, that I would be less willing to resell such an expensive watch, than reselling a cheaper one, because of the substantial money I spend for it. It's the other way around now. Because of the high price, I've got much higher expectations now, which the watch does not fulfill at the moment. And I don't know, whether the love will come back.

Cut. 

I'm thinking about buying a 5170 for 2 years now. The interest in that watch did not disappear. I prefered the white and red gold versions with the white dials. The red gold doesn't fit into my collection, though, because it's too close to another watch I own. I was waiting for the release of the 5170p aswell. Now, that I have seen it, I can say, that I like it, but that it is not the right watch for me. So I do know now, that if I ever get a 5170, it'll be a 5170g with the white dial.

Having both watches is no option, so the question is now: should I sell the 5164a (loosing some money) to buy a (used) 5170g? Will the 5170g afterwards suffer the same perceived fate, as the 5164, because it's even more expensive?






About the Patek Philippe Aquanaut Ref. 5164

The Patek Philippe Aquanaut reference 5164 is a travel time model within the Aquanaut collection. This specific reference is identified as 5164A-001, indicating a steel case.

The 5164A-001 features a rubber strap. No further details regarding the case material, crystal, or movement are provided.

This reference appeals to collectors seeking a Patek Philippe Aquanaut with a travel time complication and a rubber strap, suitable for various climates.

Specifications

Caliber
324 S C FUS
Case
Stainless steel
Diameter
40.8 mm
Dial
Black embossed
Water Resist.
120 meters
Crystal
Sapphire
Advertisement
The Discussion
BR
brandon1
Jun 7, 2017
Yes.

A nice predicament you're in! If it were me, I'd take steps to get the 5170G. I think the dial is very seductive and has more depth than often comes across in photos thanks to the Breguet numerals. Also, that movement! A lot of technical advancements that give it a special place in the pantheon of Patek chronos, and the reset action in particular is second-to-none. I'd hate to speculate on resale value. Good luck with your choice! Regards, Brandon

DA
damianp
Jun 7, 2017
The movement of the 5170 is definitly imho not just one class above the one of the 5164, but two or three classes above. No doubt I'll like it more, also on the long term. [nt]

BR
Bruno.M1
Jun 7, 2017
in a splitsecond

and probably even faster But I confess I do not like the aquanaut

DA
damianp
Jun 7, 2017
Haha, that's a clear opinion [nt]

CH
charcoal6666collector
Jun 7, 2017
I love both, but please dont sell the 5164 for any reason, unless you are crazy about 5170g [nt]

DA
damianp
Jun 7, 2017
I'm not sure at the moment, whether being crazy about a watch is a good thing on the long term. [nt]

Available on the marketplace

2,850 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1721 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 24 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →