Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 Brushed Finish

CaptainCrunch · 2017-01-22T03:45:42Z

Collector asks if Patek Philippe service can apply a more pronounced brushed finish to his Nautilus 5711. Community debates risks and aesthetic impact.

CaptainCrunch

WPS member · Patek Philippe forum

23 replies6800 views5 photos

CaptainCrunch initiates a discussion comparing the brushed finish on different Patek Philippe Nautilus models, specifically noting a more pronounced finish on a white gold version compared to his own 5711. He questions whether Patek Philippe's service center could apply a more obvious brushed finish to his 5711 to enhance its aesthetic.

23 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

I was comparing the level of brushed finish of two nautiluses and noticed the more pronounced brushed finish on the white gold model.

Do you guys think it is a good idea, if the Service center can do it, to do a more obvious brushed finish on the 5711? I think it looks better. I searched online and notice that not all 5711 are brush polished the same degree. Some are very pronounced which IMO looks nicer than the half gassed job.

This I think is the perfect bezel brushed finish

Very soft brushing on this one

So is on mine.

About the Patek Philippe Complications Ref. 5711

The Patek Philippe Complications reference 5711/1A is a specific configuration within the Complications model line. This particular reference is identified by its serial number 5914840, with a movement number 6084863.

The watch is presented in a stainless steel case, indicated by the "/1A" suffix. No specific details regarding the crystal material or movement architecture are provided.

This reference appeals to collectors seeking a Patek Philippe Complications model in stainless steel. Its specific serial and movement numbers are documented for identification purposes.

Specifications

Caliber: 26-330 S C

Case: Stainless steel

Diameter: 40mm

Dial: Blue, White

Water Resist.: 120m

Crystal: Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Modifying the brushed finish on a Nautilus is risky, as it can remove material and impact the edges. Patek Philippe is unlikely to perform such a customization.
The 5711 is an iconic and perfect watch, and any modifications are strongly discouraged to preserve its original design and value.
Heavy brushing is more suited for Royal Oaks, and an overly aggressive finish on a Nautilus can make it appear as if serviced by a 'cobbler' rather than a skilled watchmaker.
The perceived difference in brushing might be an effect of the material, as rose gold Royal Oaks show brushing more distinctly than stainless steel versions. Online variations in 5711 brushing could be due to photo filters.
Any modification carries the risk of making the watch worse, and it's important to consider the potential negative impact on resale value.

The Discussion

dr.kol

Jan 22, 2017

I would not change the factory finishing. But that's just me. [nt]

CaptainCrunch

Jan 22, 2017

It will just be a more obvious brush finish Kari. No deal? [nt]

dr.kol

Jan 22, 2017

Sometimes there are things which could be improved.

But because life is not predictable, I would not destroy the resale value of a relatively expensive watch. As simple as that. Best, Kari

geross