Complications
David_S's detailed review of his Patek Philippe Ref. 5236P offers an invaluable early look at a significant modern complication. His insights into the watch's aesthetic nuances and technical execution provide a foundational understanding for collectors considering this reference. This article synthesizes community perspectives, enhancing David_S's initial assessment with broader expert commentary.
Friends, as promised in a previous post, please find attached a short review and a few photos of my 5236P.
Positives:
I think that the 5236 is the perfect combination of understatement and complication. The dial, with the inline calendar, is very simple, very legible (minus a caveat below) and incredibly pretty. The rest of my collection tends to have fairly busy dials (traditional QPs, chronos or skeletons) and it is refreshing to have a simple, elegant dial. The 5236 can almost work as a formal watch.
The color is a bit hard to describe as it is truly chameleonic in the way its hues shift with the light. It can go from a very dark navy blue to a lighter, almost jeans-like, color (especially in the center given the shading of towards black towards the outside of the dial).
The seconds counter/moon phase is also slightly lighter than the rest.
In short, esthetically, I cannot find a single flaw. It is just gorgeous.
The case is large at 41.3mm by 11.07mm, but it is very wearable and comfortable. The weight is significant given the platinum, but I like the feel of a substantial watch.
The movement is pure bliss.
The architecture is extremely elegant and the setup of the three lower bridges, each a bit longer than the next, is a fantastic design element.
The platinum winding mass also does feel special as, to my knowledge, this is only the second time Patek has used a platinum mass (the first time was for the 5208T for Only Watch, a unique piece). Please correct me here if I am wrong?
Functionally, I have had no issue so far and after some 30+ hours, it seems that the accuracy is worthy of the Patek seal.
Negatives:
Truly, I see only two (small) drawbacks. First, I would have preferred instantaneously jumping calendar indications (the date cycle takes around an hour and a half), as seen for example in this year’s Lange 1 QP. Second, given the placement of the calendar window, it is hard if not impossible to tell the date at around noon and midnight.
Conclusion:
I am massively enamored with the watch. I think it perfectly reflects what Patek is all about: high horology (advanced R&D, complexity level, finish level) in an understated presentation. A watch that will be instantaneously recognized by aficionados and properly ignored by everyone else. The perfect match of form and function, in a timeless package.
A few more photos:
The Complications reference 5236P-001, introduced in 2021, is notable for its in-line perpetual calendar display. This configuration presents all calendar indications – day, date, month, and leap year – in a single, elongated aperture below 12 o'clock. This design choice offers a distinct aesthetic and legibility compared to traditional perpetual calendars with multiple subdials or apertures. The reference was a significant addition to Patek Philippe's Complications collection, showcasing a novel approach to a classic grand complication. Its platinum case and blue dial further underscore its position within the brand's high-end offerings.
The watch is housed in a platinum case measuring 41.3mm in diameter, with a thickness of 11.07mm. It is powered by the self-winding caliber 31-260 PS QL, a movement specifically developed for this in-line perpetual calendar display. This movement incorporates several technical advancements to achieve its unique calendar presentation and offers a power reserve of 38 to 48 hours. The watch features a sapphire crystal on both the front and the case back, allowing for a view of the meticulously finished movement.
As a relatively recent introduction that was subsequently discontinued, the 5236P-001 holds particular interest for collectors who appreciate innovative calendar displays and limited production periods. Its technical sophistication and unique aesthetic appeal to those seeking a distinct perpetual calendar from Patek Philippe. The discontinuation of a model introduced in 2021, while not uncommon for certain high-end references, adds to its potential collectibility, distinguishing it from longer-running production pieces.
...I too am kind of bothered by the fact that Patek couldn't (wouldn't?) figure out instant indicator change. It looks from the photo that the date is the same color as the day and month...true? If so, it would have been nice to make the date a different color...blue? Red? Just a thought. The movement bridges are very nice and the rotor does look special...
I’m glad to see this piece is being so well received by connoisseurs and lovers of fine horology — perpetual calendars are not most popular models these days, so it’s great Patek has been able to offer something new in this area, which is both technically impressive and very much consistent with its unique style👍 I’ve yet to see it in the metal (if all goes well, they’ll show me everything on May 21), but I’m totally looking forward to having this beauty on my wrist!😉🥂
Nice reviews and it’s great you mentioned about not able to read the date at noon 👏🏻 That is the best part about owners’ review, bravo and congrats again!
And thanks a lot for the review, very interesting. I like the watch and would love to see it in the flesh soon. Enjoy it in the best health!
I, too, agree with your conclusions of this piece. It’s an almost perfect watch. I wish it had instant change and hacking seconds. I don’t think the lack of these features would keep me from getting this watch if I had a chance though. It’s a beauty. Wear it in good health!
The complexity of the watch is known only to its owner and its watchmaker. And to us as well. May you enjoy it for many February 29s to come.
This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 48 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →
