I respectfully disagree

A watch is meant to run continuously unlike a car because time does not stop for anyone.

The issue is simple. Is the watch built to last continuous running for a lifetime ( of course with servicing etc). If yes, then it is robustly built. If not and it cannot withstand the simple rigour of a watch winder, then it is a disappointing work product IMHO. The choice of using or not using a watch winder should be left to user and not a limitation of the watch itself.

I have had my IWC Perp etual and AP annual calendars and GO navigators running on watchwinders without any problem whatsoever.

I purchased the FPJ simply because of the style and the original workmanship, but I must say I am taken aback by the fact that this watch cannot be put on a watch winder.

Regds

chintu

💰587 Marketplace Listings for IWC›

Octa Calendrier - Conflicting Instructions

By: chintu : April 5th, 2010-06:20

Hi I have purchased an Octa Calendrier RG. The instruction manual states exactly as follows; "For the whole Octa Collection. The use of a rotating watchbox could severely damage your watch. Please read the following guidelines; 276 turns in 24 hours to th...

You Don't Need a Winder

By: Douglas : April 5th, 2010-07:19

Journe has been quite vocal about winders: Most over-wind. The Calendrier winds uni-directional, and it requires only a few turns to wind completely. I do not use a winder on mine. People whom I know who use winders will place the watch on the winder for ...

Interesting....

By: MiniCooper : April 5th, 2010-07:27

however winders are useful for perpetual calenders.... cheers

Overwind, Overrun

By: bs22fly : April 5th, 2010-19:01

I've know of few instances where someone has left their Octa in a winder all day and every day. They ultimately experienced problems and had to send the watch into service. I think the instructions could be more clear but do take heed of the warning. On a...

Winding boxes

By: GE : April 5th, 2010-22:44

If you have more than a few watches you NEED a winding solution. Preferably one that uses AC and not battery so you can switch the winder to always on and use power control adaptor plugs to switch the winder on and off very precisely. So far battery opera...

Thanks - But FPJ prohibition of watchwinder is a bit overdone

By: chintu : April 6th, 2010-00:14

Hi I agree with your explanation that the overwinding situation can occur even with simply having a wearer being very active. The very purpose of the safety mechanisims is to prevent any damage to the watch movement and I am surprised why no other marquee...

Watch winders

By: pierrelacharlotte : April 6th, 2010-06:13

as Mr. Journe always states: do you keep your car running all the time? Wtach winders may be usefull for watches that need a lot of (re)setting. But none of Mr. Journe's watches are difficult to set (including the OP- perpetual Calendar), if they were, he...