Andrew
9
lange calendar would be my choice
Lange all the way. and this may be controversial, but owning 3 lange's and one journe, i believe the langes are better made and more reliable. i've had almost zero mechanical problems with the langes other than doing stupid things like dropping them. and i have had a bit of adjustment issues in terms of getting magnetized, etc. but nothing intrinsic to the movement. the journe has had several bouts (it's a jour et nuit, ruthenium le) of funky dates (such as 32, etc.) and other issues. i understand journe had a number of problems early in the brand and i'm told they are doing better lately and more organized on the service side. indeed my last repair went much easier (last month) than several years ago.
i certainly do not mean to cast aspersions upon Journe. i actually love Journe and there are several models i'm looking at and am contemplating trying again with one of the latest models. but i would mentally categorize it in advance as a riskier choice and would allot/expect a certain amount of repair work as par for the course. aesthetically, i would also say that the chronometre is perfectly pretty and i've been tempted but doesn't blow me away. i think the Lange is a really nice rendention of annual calendar, clean interesting and useful in a complication that i'd previously thought Patek owned hands down.
My take..
By: mpiz : July 3rd, 2010-20:47
To me both look elegant and classy. I would prefer the annual calendar because of 1 simple reason. It's a clean symmetrical dial. It also has a moonphase to boost which is a plus.
Appreciate the responses .....
By: mac : July 4th, 2010-06:55
I realize it's an odd comparison, but I think that is more true in life than not. I also didn't wanted to gather various points of view before saying too much. Why don't I wear the FPJ CS more often? - In part because of the more casual summer months comb...
Good question.
By: foversta : July 4th, 2010-13:23
Can anyone clarify why the Lange is thought to be more robust? I don't have services figures and I'm not able to tell you that % of the FPJ or of the Lange watches need to be serviced. But what I can tell you is that Journe has an objective in his collect...
fpj all the way
By: pejp : July 6th, 2010-09:44
They are very different and therefore hard to compare, but the FPJ is just stunning. I'm biased as it's my grail watch, but the FPJ CS is the one of the most beautiful watches I have ever had the pleasure of wearing. I like Lange (particularly the datogra...
lange
By: Hororgasm : July 6th, 2010-16:51
i will leave the looks and asthetics to you, personally i like the Lange look more. beyond tht, your question raises "robustness" as a consideration. while i have no idea wht QC FPJ has, but i think not many will disagree Lange prob score higher on tht fr...