aaronm
2923
Customary use...
Custom="the name on the knife is the maker (ground, fitted, polished, etc..." with other participants usually named (engraver, smith, HT) or at least acknowledged (I buy my sheaths, etc). Usually this has everything made unique for that knife(excluding screws and the like), rather than telling a CNC to mill 100 scales, but that is less of a hard line. Perhaps an apprentice in the shop, but not often and they are often listed.
Production=Anything else, from Chris Reeve, who runs a small company with perhaps a dozen makers to Benchmade, Spyderco and Kershaw with factories on more than one continent.
At the very top of production are brands like Chris Reeve and Randall, they are production pieces but made entirely by hand and held to very high standards, and some so-called semi-customs, where a talented maker has pieces waterjet or laser cut and only does the final finish work inhouse. Not unlike the old ebauche system.
As an unusual side note, in many cases people value the "sole ownership" (1 guy doing everything from a pile of raw steel and other stuff) pieces a bit higher than shared work, but at the very highest end, shared pieces, where a specialist in each field does only the work he does best, are quite valuable.
I could go on....
A
My first response...
By: tee530 : March 25th, 2010-18:36
....was to spend ten minutes googling the Kershaw Zing knife. If my time here has taught me anything, it is that honestly held passion is worth listening to, if only for a brief time, even if I fully believe I have absolutely no interest in the subject at...
another perspective
By: Chromatic Fugue : March 25th, 2010-20:21
We normally speak in positive terms about collectors who have a "passion" for whatever it is they collect. Hobbyist websites like this one tend to bring together people who reinforce one another's need to believe that there is something noble about spendi...
A Tightrope Walk
By: Heinrich : March 26th, 2010-12:54
Thanks a lot for this thought provoking post. I appreciate that someone has the standing to touch such a topic in this forum. Your reference to the world of Tolkien’s novels made me recognize the tightrope walk between a passion for beautiful things...
Interesting...
By: aaronm : March 26th, 2010-14:27
That the bulk of his collection is production knives. As someone for whom knife collecting came first, i'd say it is a very different, but compatible hobby. When I first started collecting watches I was constantly annoyed at the lack of transparency (ok, ...
This could be interesting.
By: ThomasM : March 27th, 2010-12:25
Hi Aaron. Please define Production piece vs custom. Please share what the practical differences are (besides consistency of fit and finish) Is there a middle ground, say, "tuned" production pieces that gives one 98% of custom at 1/3 the price (using a ben...
Customary use...
By: aaronm : March 27th, 2010-17:27
Custom="the name on the knife is the maker (ground, fitted, polished, etc..." with other participants usually named (engraver, smith, HT) or at least acknowledged (I buy my sheaths, etc). Usually this has everything made unique for that knife(excluding sc...