Robert65
989
Appreciate that De Bethune is cutting edge independent, however IMO the 5170R wins
Entirely personal decision since the DB is gorgeous and a technical one-pusher marvel, and I also appreciate the 3D-like numerals on the DB dial... but the Patek dress chrono sings to me.
Best,
Robert
Well put... I think it will be interesting to see how this test runs out
(Nice LF in your profile thumbnail)
Me too...
There's always been something special with a "dress-up Day" Chrono, at least for me
DeBethune
The golden dial is classy. Itās a chronograph which do not scream itās a chronograph. Other DeBethune watches are very good designs, so this brand do a good job for me. Colleague Voutilainen the same.
Both get my nods ! The DB dial is very clean and elegant and the 5170 is simply ...
classy ! Since this is a Patek forum and I am the co-moderator, the 5170 gets a bigger nod ! š
I think the comparo is interesting...
R vs R Opaline vs Radial Guilloche'd Rose Gold Dial Applied Breguet vs Blue Printed (but 3d somehow) Arabics Manual (better winding feel) vs Manual In house 4hz Patek chrono vs THA monopusher movement from a few wannabes (Journe / V Halter / Flaggiolet) B...
Thanks for a really good analysis! In the end my vote is for the Patek for a number of details I like better (the dial, in house, applied indices and a generally higher level of sophistication, etc...)
However, itās a great looking DB that I wasnāt even familiar with in this declination (unique piece?), so this is a totally legitimate competition...It might be interesting to see if the feedback you receive will be any different on the Independent Forumš...
Thank you, sir.... 4-2 in favor of the Patek at present
(though sounds like some may simply not be as familiar with the DB) ...
No contest! :-)
The De Bethune for sure. The Patek 5170G would have given the De Bethune a closer fight with its pulsometer scale but the 5170R is quite plain by comparison. And I am a Patek fan by the way but this is one of the nicest looking De Bethunes I have laid my ...
De Bethune, easily
The hand guilloche on the dial itself makes it no contest. If it's the re-release of the DB8 then the movement is no contest either.
Its the original with the THA movement by Journe Flaggiolet & Halter (Wish it wasn't a closed caseback)
And just like that - tie ball game at 6-6
Appreciate that De Bethune is cutting edge independent, however IMO the 5170R wins
Entirely personal decision since the DB is gorgeous and a technical one-pusher marvel, and I also appreciate the 3D-like numerals on the DB dial... but the Patek dress chrono sings to me. Best, Robert
I will break it (for now). The 5170 for me.
The Patek has more oomph movement wise, and the DBT is rather more quirky. Iāll go classic this time. Cheers, John
5170
I went G with black dial, which really is a super utilitarian watch that works well with evening wear as well as jeans. BR M
I would agree
The black dialed breguetās is iconic. Had I not had another black dialed chrono Iād have likely gone that direction. But I basically never wear black shoes, and while I like the tan strap, black dial combo - a lot... the opaline dial works a lot better wi...
That
While the 5170 is classy and impeccably made, to me it is not one of the strongest PP manual chronos. Iād take both the 5070 and 5172 over the 5170. The DB has equally strong design and excellent execution but in addition thereās the originality of a piec...