whit
558
Buying a watch is so personal that it would be hard to
advise one way or the other. I have never had an uncomfortable Patek. Certainly, some are thicker, larger, thinner, etc. but when fitted correctly, comfort has never been an issue for me. So, it boils down to what Nicholas said, the key factors are your lifestyle and day to day activities..
Once you take the plunge into the Patek water, you will develop a better understanding of the brand and where to go from there with respect to other models and future purchases.
Given the two choices you are considering, I would personally choose a gold Calatrva before the Aquanaut. I could rattle off a list of reasons for my choice but there are others who could do the same for the Aquanaut. The Calatrava is far more classic in its appearance versus the more up to date appearance of the Aquanaut.
Either is a good choice.
From what I've tried
By: radone : February 5th, 2013-07:03
I find 5711 to be a comfy everyday watch, haven't had any problems with the bracelet myself. The weight it nice, watch vs. bracelet ratio is very balanced. Not like in the 5980 where the the mass of the watch itself makes it a bit uncomfortable. I did not...
My votes will go to ..
By: Hamster07 : February 5th, 2013-08:20
5110 for a WT, and 3940 for a perpetual. They are the most wearable Pateks IMO because they are super comfortable (esp with the deployant buckle) and they are not easy to get scratches because of the thinness of the case (and they are not brushed either, ...
Aquanaut
By: watch-er : February 6th, 2013-09:05
The Aquanaut to me is the most comfortable because of the rubber strap. You do not know you have it on. 5196G is to me a far better choice, classic PP but you need a bigger wrist for it as it appears big due to its thinness, despite its 37mm
5167a
By: ors : February 6th, 2013-11:54
I have been wearing my 5167A for almost 3 months now, after wearing different watches, and lately (before the PP) a Panerai Luminor. Wearing the Aquanaut is like not wearing a watch at all, it is so light, so comfortable, that you actually do not feel the...
I find
By: dr.kol : February 6th, 2013-14:41
5712A a fantastic pair with Aquanaut. I have a 3712 and it must be the 2nd most comfortable steel watch I have been wearing. I would say that all Patek watches I have tried are potentially very comfortable. Their watches are never overly big and always ma...
Why not...
By: dr.kol : February 7th, 2013-23:13
If your watch is equipped with a folding clasp, you probably want to place that to the center of your wrist. Because i.e the folding clasp of PP is bended, you need to find the place on your wrist where the clasp feels good. In my case the clasp is very c...
I have both
By: surfer : February 7th, 2013-14:17
a 3520 Calatrava and the Aquanaut 5065. Both are incredibly comfortable,I actually use the 3520 as an every day watch simply because it s so thin you hardly know it is there. The only issue i have is with the once beautiful brown strap that is now nearly ...