Passionata_george
3411
i love the R
not only since I own the R but my preference was (right after the enamel dial ) the colour of the case material, i m a sucker for rose gold . The differences you ve mentined are noticable under high magnification and these dials are ALL magnificent as soon are hit by the light especially by the Sun .
Worshipper of PP WTs
Hi All, This post explains why, if I had to choose, I would prefer the enamel map of 5131G over the 5131R.
In an earlier post I mentioned my preference. www.watchprosite.com Other than the geographical depiction on the map, I like an enamel dial that strikes a balance of 1) as many colors as possible, 2) bright colors where appropriate to make the dial...
i love the R
not only since I own the R but my preference was (right after the enamel dial ) the colour of the case material, i m a sucker for rose gold . The differences you ve mentined are noticable under high magnification and these dials are ALL magnificent as soo...
Always great to see cloisonné dials.
Not sure I follow the differentiation you are making since there are such drastic differences between the dials R to R and G to G due to the process. I would say the G in your photos seems to have a lot of air bubbles in the enamel which is unusual? Not s...
Hi Russell, IMO they are big differences in terms of gradations :-)
I asked Patek about the bubbles and Geneva confirmed that they are within the tolerence of quality control.
Well Gordon, we will have to agree to disagree.
I don't see the anything in the many photos I have seen that suggests there are smoother transitions in the G compared to the R except to agree that some R's have a hard brown area at about 10 - others do not. I will dig out some high res photos.
It is fine to agree to disagree Russell
For the record, you are disagreeing with me and Henry 🤣
5131r and dial variance
I have a very early example of a 5131r and mine has no snow. I don’t know how to post photos
Hi ! Are you using your computer or mobile
device to post photos ? Simply use the button at the end of the post to update photos from your mobile ablums. Look forward to seeing yours !
Dear Gordon, I agree that G has more variation of colours and the transition between colours is more gradual, therefore looks more sophisticated.
On the other hand, R has more vivid and high contrast colours, especially the initial version like Russell's one. However, the colours transition of R is more abrupt. Personally I like G a bit more than R, as the grass next door is usually greener.
Hi Henry, thank you for understanding my points ! The grass is no longer greener because you are now offically ...
poisoned and need to get a G !!! Right ?
Thanks Gordon for the nice comparisons...I'm also not sure whether this difference in gradation depends on the reference or the models considered, but both are obviously fascinating pieces.
My slight preference is for the R though, mainly because of the case color (as I already have the P in white). Thanks for some great pics! ;-)
Hi Fab, you are most welcome ! Since you prefer the R, you now MUST...
get the R then ! Let me know if you want me to help you get one.
Thanks my friend, any gift is always welcome ;-)) Seriously, I might (possibly) ask/apply for a 5231R, but having the 5131P (favorite case and metal) doesn't motivate me as much...
All WTs are of course great pieces, but I would't mind another "special" rare handcraft at the moment... let's see what the future brings at retail! ;-)
Amazing photo's. Very educational regarding the difference is enamelling choices between the G and R. You definitely must know what you are looking for to spot it.
Also interesting that there are different teams that work on the G+P than R+J.
Hi Nicetomeetyou, thank you and glad that you found it educational ! :-) Actually given each is hand made, each is ...
truly unique ! Please read my earlier post and others' comments with my replies to understand more www.watchprosite.com
Both are Amazing piece
So which team is responsible for R and J? I thought all done by Anita P.
Hi Next, Anita and her team is responsible for G and P perhaps with another team
The original J makers were a mother and son team, and perhaps they also made Rs
Incredible comparisons Gordon
Given that the enamels are done by hand by different teams, I wonder if you can comment on other aspects such as the accuracy of shapes and shades
Hi JTCL, glad you liked my post ! Here is a link to an...
earlier post by me and my exchanges with Patekova that explain the differences. Let me know if you have other comments and/or questions.
Thanks JTCL for your kind words ! I am NOT an enamel connoisseur but an...
enamel ADDICT/SLAVE 😇
Awesome details
This really shows how seriously & knowledgeably you are with your time pieces
That’s some serious macro action!
Honestly I think they’re all lovely...clearly my connoisseurship has some way to go! Congrats to Gordon our resident cloisonné expert, this kind of detailed examination and knowledge (and the conversation around it) is superb and the kind of content that ...
Hi E, thanks for your kind comments ! These "serious" macro shots were created from...
iPhone and a cheap macro lense !