After the first few posts it looked like a runaway victory for the right and then andrew & chris come along with a late brace of lefty's!!...ohhhh no, looked so unaminous upto that point
First thought for me straight away were the right, cleaner looking dial, think the left is a bit 'fussy' but then when I zoomed the size up, the left one started to look more attractive, more going on, the right one starts to look a bit 'bare' in comparison
So nothing else for it you need one of each!....
I am still hanging to the right in summary, but only very very marginally...let us know which one you plump for, there really isnt a wrong choice here