Horological Meandering

Hi Everyone,

No message body

No message body

Which one?

No message body

Honestly, I don't like the idea of the single watch for any occasion.



But in your selection, I would choose the Rolex without any doubt: it is the most "all-around" of the selection IMHO.

Fx

. . . or mementos, there's one watch that I could wear every day . . .

. . . in any situation, and never tire of.  Seeing as how these Karrees are discontinued, and given your parameters, there's a new contender from Omega . . .

[photo credit: Magnus / Oliver]

. . . that you might find interesting.  I don't own one, but can say with the benefit of extended hands-on experience that this current generation of Omega movements offers exceptional levels of performance. 

No message body

...even though the Rolex would be the obvious choice, just because the VC is less common out in the real world. But I guess you could say that about your other choices, too.

All occasions? You fool!  It does not exist.

...and that's those that do wear watches  ,the Rolex among those choices seems the clearer choice for me, but not for the brand perception, but for the adaptive styling that works with jeans, shorts or suit. It's why they sell so doggone many of these every year. This message has been edited by mrsnak on 2012-07-13 17:57:56

I totally understand the idea of only one watch. But what a terribly difficult decision. Given your existing five choices I would definitely go with the Rolex GMT. However, I can't imagine how painful it was to get down to the last five. 

..at least with choices like these

...the VC OS, as I feel as if it is a watch that can be worn over a long period of time without wondering at some point "what did I find attractive about that piece in the first place?"  The limitation as a GMT watch is the single hand on the second time zone dial vs. 2 hands.  Full disclosure: I have an OS on bracelet as my primary daily wear watch for business and casual occasions.

The GO is also very nice in my view but might be a bit too sport/bulky as a single watch for all occasions.  And, while I'm sure that the Rolex and PPs are fine watches, none of them are to my personal taste.

Have you considered the JLC Reverso Grande GMT?  I have just bought a pre-owned example on bracelet as a regular-wear watch, and think it will be just splendid (as well as showing two time zones).  If you don't favor rectangular watches it will not be for you, but it does (to me) bridge the gap between dress and casual extremely well and could be a "single watch" for folks who find it attractive.

Best,

Gary G

Or wear a suit.

No message body

No message body

There are more than one watch, at GP, which could be an " only one watch ". Depending on your lifestyle...

Best,

Nicolas

I know that if I ever had the finances and opportunity to do so, the PP Nautilus 3711 would be the one. For you, more difficult. With the GMT function out of your choices I would rank 1) VC Overseas Dualtime and then 2) Rolex GMT Master II. Nothing against the Rolex, I am just more fond of the bracelet and case of the Overseas. As with all of these this or that posts, I think the reply is more about the responder than the original poster. Good luck with your quest!

Thanks for the input!

All of the watches you describe are wonderful watches and would serve you well for a lifetime.  So, as you say, it's really all about personal preference.  In addition, though, some people (few probably) will form opinions of you based on your watch.  Many people recognize Rolexes and will generally think: "There is a guy with a fancy watch."  The other watches will be more anonymous.  Some people will recognize the Patek and think: "There is a guy with a really fancy watch."  People will look at the VC and think: "That's a nice-looking watch; I haven't seen one of those before."

Your email summarizes the roller coaster journey I've been on.  Yes, the VC and the Rolex are ahead of the others for me.  Some days the VC is clearly ahead.  Other days, it's the Rolex.

with a personal testimonal regarding the VC Overseas...I'm very enthusiastic about their ruggedness and slim profile and have always had one or two in the quiver.  Back in 2008 I wore one to the summit of a 22,800 ft. peak in South America.  The current model is even more attractive with the optional rubber strap.

Looks like Aconcagua to me -- well done!

Best,

Gary

I am actually a psychiatrist (still in training), but there's little reason to quibble.

What's not to like about these? 

Well, my guess is that some folks (including my wife, by the way) find the YG version of the OS DT a bit too, shall we say, blingy -- and maybe the Deep Stream SS/Ti color combo is not exactly to your taste -- but these are two of the most pleasurable wearing watches that I have ever owned, and there are days on which I wish I had the "Bling Special" back with me!

Best,

Gary G

I have considered this ‘single watch’ question a lot, and it is Rolex that comes closest for me. I don’t have a GMT, but this 5513 is extremely comfortable, rugged and versatile and you would find the same with a GMT, I am certain.

I agree with the recommendations of the Reverso Grand GMT and Girard-Perregaux ww.tc as they would provide the additional time zones you seek, but both may be too dressy – although that is a state of mind and attitude!

Enjoy the decision process, as that is often the best part of this hobby.

Andrew

No message body

I will seriously struggle to do that but if I had to, I'd go with a GMT but with black dial as I think that will be better for slightly more formal occasions.