Rolex Submariner: Ultimate Buyer's Guide

Ted O · 2023-10-07T13:06:32Z

Discover the best Rolex Submariner for the money. Ted O and WatchProSite community discuss classic references, market value, and wrist presence for new collectors.

Ted O

WPS member · Rolex forum

26 replies6632 views1 photos

Ted O, a seasoned Rolex collector, initiates a crucial discussion for enthusiasts navigating the current market: identifying the 'best' Rolex Submariner for the money. His inquiry focuses on models that offer significant wrist presence and classic aesthetics, rather than purely investment potential or vintage rarity. This article synthesizes community insights to guide collectors through the diverse Submariner references available today.

26 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

Given the Rolex Submariner’s classic, timeless design — for someone who has never owned one (but has other Rolex, including Deepsea) — and under current market conditions — what’s the best Sub for the money right now?

Again, given it’s classic and consistent look, it does not need to be vintage or new — but I do like to feel my watch in terms of weight/presence, if possible — but not the main focus here.

As mentioned, goal here is best for money (NOT AS AN INVESTMENT) right now given releases over the years to choose from, which I feel is a good thing for someone looking.

Please advise as to which and why, and send pics if possible — thanks!

About the Rolex Sea-Dweller 4000 Ref. 116600

The Sea-Dweller reference 116600 marked the return of the 40mm case size for the model, a dimension that had been absent from the Sea-Dweller lineup for some time. This reference reintroduced several classic Sea-Dweller design elements, distinguishing it from its larger contemporary, the Sea-Dweller 4000. It was produced for a relatively short period, making it a notable transitional model within the brand's professional tool watch offerings.

This reference features a stainless steel case measuring 40mm in diameter and 15.3mm in thickness. It is equipped with a unidirectional rotating bezel made of black ceramic with a 60-minute graduation. The watch is powered by the automatic caliber 3135, offering a power reserve of approximately 48 hours. A sapphire crystal protects the black dial, which includes a date complication without the cyclops lens, a characteristic feature of the Sea-Dweller line.

Appealing to collectors who appreciate traditional proportions and the technical capabilities of a professional dive watch, the 116600 is recognized for its blend of heritage design and modern materials. Its limited production run contributes to its appeal among enthusiasts seeking a Sea-Dweller with a more classic case size and specific aesthetic details, such as the matte-like black dial and the absence of the cyclops over the date.

Specifications

Caliber: 3135

Case: Stainless steel

Diameter: 40 mm

Dial: Black

Water Resist.: 1220m

Crystal: Sapphire crystal

Key Points from the Discussion

The 11 series Submariner, despite its bulkier and chunkier profile, is celebrated by some collectors as the truest expression of what the Submariner always aimed to be, offering substantial wrist presence.
A well-maintained, approximately 20-year-old Submariner, post-overhaul, can offer excellent wearability and value, demonstrating that age does not diminish its appeal or performance.
The 'Kermit' Submariner (Ref. 16610LV) is a popular choice for its distinctive green bezel, historical significance, and unique aesthetic that sets it apart from other Submariner models.
For those seeking a Submariner alternative with similar characteristics but potentially better value, the Rolex Sea-Dweller Ref. 16600 is suggested as it often trades for less than most Submariner references while offering superior specifications.
The classic, timeless design of the Rolex Submariner is a fundamental aspect that resonates deeply with collectors, often making it a 'case closed' argument for its enduring appeal.
Several contributors shared images of their Rolex Submariner and Sea-Dweller watches, showcasing various references and how they wear on different wrist sizes, emphasizing the visual and tactile experience.

The Discussion

ImranLondon

Oct 7, 2023

Easy.

On 6.5 inch Wrist that is

amanico

Oct 7, 2023

We are on the same boat.

oyster case

Oct 7, 2023

That’s not a Rolex Submariner 🙃

To be more precise, that is neither a Rolex nor a Submariner 🙃