ArthurSG
3278
Vince Horo and Heartbreaker... Great stuff
I ain;t a ROO fan as the former will know but if this came out, I must say, it will be of high temptation. (still won;t pay over list though as there is no watch with that level of intrinsic value for me 
) I will hope AP however addresses the issue (for me at least) of flatness of the starwheel. They turn out great in pics but in the metal, on the 4 occasions I have seen them (millenary and barleycorn, fleurier versions), the wheels are underwhelming. If somehow more depth and dimension can be given to the wheels, I think it will be something else as its an interesting complication. Very good stuff hearbreaker.
A Wet Dream 40th Anniversary Royal Oak - Star Wheel RO
Howdy folks, Two weeks back, Jeffreysaul started a thread on what could be 40th anniversary AP RO. It has always been a desire of mine to see the star wheel warehoused in a RO case(NOT ROO). I want something from AP to celebrate this anniversary with some...
Is something missing?
The way I read the message was that you had mocked up a prototype of the 40th anniversary Royal Oak with star wheel. Maybe, I am just missing something obvious or the link is missing. Thank you very much in advance as I was drawn to your headline and woul...
AP Starwheel RO rendering 1
Please await Heartbreaker, who is probably busy currently, for more renderings. please start commenting AFTER Heartbreaker post the rest of his creations. and the whole excercise would be to listen to, and cater to some desired features and design philoso...
Who said "salmon dial"???
This is a modified version of the modified version of the modified version of proposal #7 (my head starts spinning): - salmon dial and outer ring; - luminous indexes removed; - black minutes and scale; - black, non-luminous, hours. Not bad, do you think s...
Thank you Horo!
Dear Horo, dear Purists, here are my proposals. Proposal #1. I've simply cutted and pasted the dial of a Star Wheel with blued guillochage. Proposal #2. As you know, Audemars Piguet has used the Star Wheel movement also with the Millenary's case, but choo...
Its all your efforts mate. my fav is No.6
to me, its the most "modern" interpretation of the starwheel interface whilst retaining the core RO DNA. i normally do not like excessive wordings on dials, but your rendition is very tastefully done. best, Horo
Me too!
Me too I prefer the last version. Besides, the idea came after the practice you've seen.
5 or 6 for me...
The dial is the best hommage to the original jumbo AND to the Starwheel. A kind of best if both worlds. Small tapisserie would be even nicer, IMO, and AP Logo at 6, for the Clin d'oeil Best, Nicolas
Proposal #7 and a close-up
Smaller tapisserie (85%: it's enough?) and AP Logo at 6 (but I prefer it a 12). I nearly forgot to write that I've used the Jumbo case, that measures 39*49 mm. Here's a close-up of the Star Wheel movement, entirely designed with a vector graphics software...
Can you remove " Starwheel " and " automatic ", which are useless writings, please? [nt]
No message body This message has been edited by amanico on 2011-10-11 22:26:05
Here it is
I've decided to place those writings in reference to the classic RO look, where we can find both the logo, the name and the "Automatic" writings. On the other hand, AP has put "Star Wheel" only on the Millenary....
Yes, but after all these years, we know what is a Royal Oak,
What is an AP, and what is a Millenary. A Connoisseur doesn't need all these writings which ruin the beauty , the purity of the dial, IMO. Now that is beautiful. This is my choice! Best, and thabnks for your efforts. Nicolas.
I would like 40th anniversary written somewhere though, as per AP tradition
Perhaps on the case back....but maybe on the dial? Best, Horo
No, if the Starwheel has a see through case back.
As this RO should be a kind of best of both worlds... IMO. Best, Nicolas.
I didn't know, as when I saw one in the flesh, I didn't think about
Looking at the case back, as I was hypnotized. And the other Starwheel, does it have a see through case back? Best, Nicolas.
Brilliant work!
My own personal favorite is your Proposal #5, with slightly smaller tapisserie to match the elegant and finer nature of the star wheel, and an AP logo instead of "Audemars Piguet" at 6... but that's just my own dream haha... C
No. 7 ...
maybe without "Automatic" and "Starwheel", but for sure in the slim case of the 15202 and not in the case of 15300. Nice projekt! Oliver
propsal no. 1
because its original starwheel design, i also agree on no need for automatic or starwheel writings
I totally dig
#6. The luminous indices are ingenius. Fantastic work! Now if only we could see that in production! Thanks.
Proposal #8
Here's another proposal, for those who have appreciated the #5: smaller tapisserie (85% than the standard 15202) and AP logo at 6. I have to correct a wrong reference: the rounded luminous indexes and the angled outer ring take inspiration from the Royal ...
Artistically, #7 works best for me. However...
...looks aren't all that matter. The issue I have with any of the redesigns are legibility. It's obvious that AP put some thought into being able to quickly read the time, even with just a fast glance at the dial. The white band on the original Star Wheel...
Wonderful designs...
I have never been a fan of the "star wheel" myself, I can appreciate the design for what it is, but simply does not appeal to me. I feel it is overly complicated for a more sport oriented watch, beautiful in it's own right. Possibly another branch for the...
Proposal #9
Dear Emil, Thank you very much for your interesting thoughts. They were the sparkle that has driven me to realize another proposal. This time, my inspiration was the Star Wheel Repeater. Watch out, Royal Oak-lovers! It's a drastic proposal, you have to be...
sorry mate, this version is scaring me!!!! :)-
almost a Hannibal Lecter quality about it!!! jokes aside, i agree with Nicholas, we need to see the starwheel. best, Horo
Agreed, #9 is too much of a departure...
...although it's now easy to see the time. But covering the Star Wheel is too extreme and takes away what makes the Star Wheel so special. I think Ap must have gone through quite a bit of different dial designs during the original development. At some poi...
Buuuuuuuuu!!!! Proposal #9 will be your niiiiiiightmaaaare!!! :-)
Joking aside, I only wanted to try a different way. Well... we can consider this chapter fully closed, ok? ;-)
Chapter closed for me, but strangely in a perverted way....
I am using it as wallpaper for my Ipad!! Best, Horo
put a hinge on that cover and we have a half-hunter starwheel RO
Personally, I like this design, and with a flip-open cover the Purist can gaze contentedly at the starwheels Cazala
AP RO Star Wheel renderings
Very nicely done and clever variations. I like version #8. Regards, ED-209
Vince Horo and Heartbreaker... Great stuff
I ain;t a ROO fan as the former will know but if this came out, I must say, it will be of high temptation. (still won;t pay over list though as there is no watch with that level of intrinsic value for me ) I will hope AP however addresses the issue (for m...
Thks Art, and perhaps you are right...
We need to address the "flatness" of the wheels....perhaps the indices can be raised. Or instead of a transparent wheel disc, we can make it translucent or non see thru, and perhaps even a more "sculptural" wheel disc, maybe even 3 dimensional ala Urwerk?...
Love ya work Heartbreaker....
I would love to see more of a 'Concept' Star Wheel Royal Oak as I do not feel it sits comfortably within the Royal Oak DNA.... it is quite a different movement and I feel either has to sit in a round case (Jules Audemar) or a royal oak conceptual piece. J...
Perhaps? Excuse me? :-)
I think let's not go the urwerk route, why copy? It will diulte and I do know your live for urwerk as well.....
I do LOVE URWERK!
But I did not mean to go as far as that... they are in a league of their own... What I mean't was maybe a more conceptual dial/materials etc.
First of all: many, many thanks for your appreciation!!!
The next step of our Royal Oak Star Wheel is already in preparation. I'm looking for a design solution that might aesthetically avoid the risk of a Star Wheel forcedly falling down from the lost space; something that may look more "harmonic", "natural" an...
Proposal #10
The disks are slightly "smoked" and the outer ring is made the same way and positioned the same height. The AP logo at minute 0 attract one's view, trying to increase the legibility. The blue dial is slightly clearer. Ciao!...
I like something about #10...
...I think it's that I like that at first glance it almost looks like the wheels are chrono registers, which gives it a classic look...but you quickly notice that they're not registers at all, which immediately makes it look more modern. Would it be possi...
What's really missing here?
I noticed there has not been any response from the owner, Dr Mao! Does he know something and does not want to give anything away? I am suspicious by nature and find his lack of comment telling, but I am just a concerned AP citizen. It's a great way to kee...
I like this version a lot. How about a precious metal case?
How about warehousing in a YG and RG case? Perhaps with white dial? AP would then to make say x in Plat, y in gold and z in steel...so maybe we can go for that Best, Horo This message has been edited by Hororgasm on 2011-10-14 10:27:29
Great idea, Horo! So, we have...proposal #11
I do not know about you, but I find it particularly sexy! The strong contrast between the coloured case and the pale, black&white dial attracts me a lot. Ciao!...
Wow! Looks great in gold...
I like the gold with white & charcoal grey dial a lot. And thanks for posting a photo with them at actual size. I think it makes a big difference when trying to determine readability. I really like #10 and it's gold counterpart, #11. Nice work. Emil
And one more comment...
I think having the outer ring raised level with the disks is all that was required to solve the readability issue, so great idea! I'm not sure if you were thinking that "Audemars Piguet" would be at the same raised level as the numbers, but it would proba...
Now the position of the numbers is clearly visible, as...
...I had forgot the shadows. Following your suggestion: here I've put the "Audemars Piguet - Swiss Made" writing on the dial, rather than on the smoked ring; of course, now it's painted black instead of white. You find it nice?...
I think having the AP name in black on the dial works well...
...to isolate the time function even more than before, making it easier to focus on the time. Nice work! Emil This message has been edited by Emil Wojcik on 2011-10-14 17:29:33
Dial markers
Wonderfully creative thinking going on here. I would just note that a key factor in the original design of the 5402 was the elongated and narrow hands and dial markers. The star wheel numerals capture this quite well, but I think that a scale of the dial ...
Thank you for your contribution Conor
We will see what we can do. Watch out for Part 2 of the posts, with the final 2-3 design so far chosen by the majority. Best, Horo
I can propose 2 solutions
Hi Conor, thank you for your interest! I can propose 2 solutions, both of them based on the last published design. 1. Numbers on the minute sector elongated at the maximum. 2. Smaller hour discs (95% than the standard), deeper outer ring, with minutes elo...
Deus ex machina?
Very smooth adjustment. To my eye, but it's a purely subjective assessment, no 2 seems closer in proportion to the original 5402. Others may well feel differently. A quick thought - would lume in the zeros of the 10 minute markers work on the dial and in ...
I'm sorry, Conor, I didn't understood your suggestion
Could you please explain it dfferently? Thanks! This message has been edited by heartbreaker on 2011-10-17 05:35:06
apologies for the phrasing
Some of the earlier designs you also portrayed with luminous material. By elongating the numbers in the most recent design, the zeros had developed a something approximating a resemblance to the dial markers on the 5402 dial. In the original 5402, the cen...
Well, we need to completely change the color scheme
You're sure it could work? Please, judge for yourself. Ciao!...
Overkill...
It might work on a white background but the markers just stand out way too much. It may help with readability but at what cost? Emil
IMHO it's better let the indices to live their life onto the classic ROs
After all, the Star Wheel is a digital watch, no?