patrick_y
[PuristSPro Moderator]
33546
Gokarting with a repeater! I can't comment on the repeater architecture similarity...
Where did you hear that there's "similar architecture" to the VC Cal 2755? I'm not sure I would consider that to be very similar architecture; for instance, one minute repeater is entirely user powered (user powers the MR by sliding the slide, MR operates when watch is wound or not wound), and another is spring powered (MR operates only when watch is wound since the MR mechanism uses spring power). You may need to ask for more clarification from whom you heard this from. I'm dubious.
As for Gokarting with a repeater, yours truly was wearing the watch while go-karting. Another moderator at the time even suggested that this was "abusive" to the watch. But nobody had a good suggestion of where to store the watch where it wouldn't be lost. So on the wrist it went!
Which Octo Finissimo would you choose?
I currently have been wearing the lovely Octo Finissimo Automatic Tourbillon titanium 6 days out of the week. It’s fantastic as a daily wearer, but I’m confronted with a new opportunity to purchase the Octo Finissimo Minute Repeater titanium as a very fai...
At our last IGOTT 2 Meeting back in Las Vegas, we had a minute repeater that was daily worn, daily driven, and even worn on a go-kart rally (lots of vibrations).
It's not a question of the minute repeater itself, it's dependent on the architecture of the movement. Generally extra-thin movements are riskier in high vibration environments.
That sounds amazing! Gokarting with a repeater
I heard that the Bulgari movement is actually quite traditional and has similar architecture to the VC cal 2755 and Cartier 9406 movements that have been robust. Hoping that it would be the same too
Gokarting with a repeater! I can't comment on the repeater architecture similarity...
Where did you hear that there's "similar architecture" to the VC Cal 2755? I'm not sure I would consider that to be very similar architecture; for instance, one minute repeater is entirely user powered (user powers the MR by sliding the slide, MR operates...
Good question
That’s a big consideration for me too. From my understanding of the watch in general, the low density titanium is quite loud. Has good resonance and harmonics, but not as rich in tone compared to gold. Definitely not a Reverso Repeater which isn’t too gre...
It varies so much from a watch to watch ...
I suggest testing the exact one you are considering buying.
Yes! +1. Lots of variance within the same brand and even same model...
I heard two of the same model. One had better tone but had more governor whirring noise. Among the two, I wouldn't buy neither of them.
But don't forget that most owners only play with the sound of their Minute repeater
during the first ten days. Therefore I think that the overall design and wearing comfort of such a watch is much more important than the actual sound.
That makes sense. Very practical advice
It’s my first repeater so I don’t know how much I’ll be using it in the long run. The smaller diameter and better legibility are big pluses for a daily wear type watch. And the extra thickness is not even a problem going from 3.95 to 6.85mm.
I wish I had such a doubt
Did you listen to the repeater? Anyway I'd go for it, I love the complication as well as the dial's symmetry.
Thanks for everyone’s input so far!
I just want to add I am impressed by the tonality of this watch, especially with its ultra thin movement, unlike the Reverso. The volume seems impressive (even with background noise). Here’s a video link: imgur.com
In the recording the tone of the hours seems to be off...
Hours seem to "thunk" to my ears.
Get an expert... You wouldn't buy property without a realtor, why buy a watch that costs as much as a small house without an expert?
If you're serious about acquiring a piece like this; I would suggest that you get an expert to go with you to make an assessment. I'm consistently amazed at the number of wealthy people who hire consultants in their work all the time and assign an employe...
Thats a tough choice.
I do like the dial layout and overall look of the Tourbillon but to own a minute repeater is a dream come true imho.