shasavan7
36
Annual Calendar Choice
I recently purchased my first Patek (5712 1a), and love it. Now I'm looking at my next addition. I've boiled it down to either 5146g or 5396g. I like them both for different reasons--the 5146 is beautiful, sort of retro, has a power reserve and is a classic as far as I can tell. The 5396 has an austere, modern look which I find appealing. It also seems a little less common that the 5146 (I'm not sure that really matters, but it does have a bit of appeal to me). They're close enough in price to be a wash in that regard.
I would welcome any input, pro's and con's etc., from you'all. I'm sure there are a number of forum members that own or have owned both pieces. I appreciate your thoughts in advance.
Reference Guide
Explore the Patek Philippe Nautilus history, from the original 3700/1A to its 40th anniversary. Discover insights on its design, evolution, and collector appeal.
72 replies66546 views
Review
In-depth review of the Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712. Discover collector insights on its design, comfort, complications, and comparison to the 5711.
72 replies72036 views
Annual Calendar Choice
I recently purchased my first Patek (5712 1a), and love it. Now I'm looking at my next addition. I've boiled it down to either 5146g or 5396g. I like them both for different reasons--the 5146 is beautiful, sort of retro, has a power reserve and is a class...
One is a classic ...
and the grey dial would be my choice ... A very nice and classic watch with a nice complication. Sometimes I think she is just beautiful, sometimes I think the movement is too small for the size. The latter is obviously if you look at the dial. As I said,...
As Oliver said, the 5146G is a classic. IMO a pure classic.
The 5396G is a very nice piece, but no competitor to the gorgeous 5146. By the way, the perfect balance of the 5146G dial reminds me of my humble JLC RDM, including the power reserve indicator that I love. I wish you the best choice Marcelo
Hijack
Sorry to hijack the thread but I've been thinking about whether I should trade in my JLC Master Perpetual in wg and my G.O. Karree Perpetual in ss for a 5146G. I already have a 5712G so i'm not sure if it would feel like too much of an overlap. Thoughts??...
5146
Had both. Never wore 5396, so it had to go. Looking back, I don't understand why 5396 appealed to me. This message has been edited by Rainer B. on 2009-06-24 07:05:17...
5396 is akin to Patek's most beautiful calendar displays,
such as 3450 perpetual and 5125 annual with day/month in apertures, and date below in sub-dial. These two past watches are beautiful classics, but not 5396. IMHO, despite the classic lineage, the 5396 leaves me unispired. Not sure how that happened, but I...
5146 derivative
Despite the fact that I do not care for the subdials, I like 5146 so much that I got a second one, see pic. The white dials are gorgeous too, btw....
Hmm I am just the opposite, I own and love my 5396R
Never like the 5035, 5146 etc, dial stuffed with sub-dials. The use of luminous hands and markers just out of context with annual calendar as dress watch.
Out of your two choices...................
I would go with the 5146. I have owned this particular watch both in J which had the 315 movement and G that had the newer 324 movement fitted. The clarity of the 5146 is very good. Today I took a long hard look at the 5396G and I have to say that althoug...
If you can expand the candidate...
Why not look at the discontinued 5056P? I would love the size, roman numeral, more "colorful" power reserve meter, PT ..... Just my 2 cents. Ken
A couple of things to consider...
1) Apertures or sub dials? 2) Wrist test: Go to your AD and try them on your wrist. See how it fits, the weight, the size, the look, sub dials or apertures easier to read. That will surely help you decide which to acquire. Do post some pix when you've bro...
5146R - metal oxidise ? need advice..
Hi guys, I would like to seek your advice on the 5146. I have just ordered a 5146R from my AD. This is my first Patek, and I am very exciting about owning this Patek in 2 weeks time when I arrives. However, I have a bit of worry about the rose gold as I h...
Thanks to all
After much deliberation, and the insights provided by forum members, I've decided to go with the 5146g with the slate dial. It just seems to be softer, rounder, more classic and "approachable" than the 5396. Should have it next week. As you can imagine, I...
Congratulations David on your choice.............
You will not regret it. I fancy that through excitement you may have trouble in sleeping in the days before you collect your 5146G? LOL
Congrats.........
I think you made the right choice with the 5146g, the slate dial is beautiful. Wear it well! Tony
congrats,
good choice.My preference was the 5146 over the 5396 as well, although I picked the 5146J with slate dial.
Congratulations and well done!
A great choice! Dont forget to post photos when you get it.
Neither
I had a 5146j for about 48 hours, I much prefer the look, size, shape, and apertures of the 5135
5135
I was wondering why the 5135 hadnt been part of this decision. is the 5135 consider a "lesser" watch to the other 2 choices?
Well, I received the watch today....
and it is truly stunning. Pictures don't really come close. I wore it today and found myself staring at the face, realizing that I had no idea what time it said. I've seen and owned a number of high end watches, but to me these Pateks are truly in a class...
Classic 5146
About two weeks ago, I got my PP 5146 with cream dial and dark brown leather strap. After more than 1 year of searching and waiting, I got what I want. What makes it more classic is actually it's cream dial. Eye catcher, head turner, whatever you want to ...