DSD
135
Hmmm.
While I like the analogy - does anyone buy an Apple product because of where it was made or even think it is made in the USA? I think the draw is just the appearance and technology. My Ipod is marked with the fact that it was made in China. Swiss watches, however, beg one to assume that they are primarily Swiss products when, in some cases, they are not. Further, you would have no way of knowing this as brands conceal it.
In terms of the car analogy - I agree. It only makes sense to use outsourced parts when they are of better quality than what you could make on your own. However, the sense I get from the outsourcing that is going on here is that it is purely for the cost savings. In other words, we buy dials and hands or have cases made in Asian factories for Swiss watches because the quality is about as good(?) but they can produce them much cheaper than a comparable Swiss parts manufacturer (who are rapidly going out of business as a result). So.... I wonder if this will eventually dilute the cache and sense of exclusivity / quality we look for that, at least in our minds, justifies the price. Would we still love the Ferrari if the body was made in China?
Authenticity?
By: DSD : March 13th, 2010-06:17
Forgive some ramblings on a Sat morning but am very curious to hear what Purist members think of the current trends / state of the Swiss watch industry. I have been enjoying some dialogue on this subject among a number of individuals who work in the indus...
Hmmm.
By: DSD : March 13th, 2010-14:19
While I like the analogy - does anyone buy an Apple product because of where it was made or even think it is made in the USA? I think the draw is just the appearance and technology. My Ipod is marked with the fact that it was made in China. Swiss watches,...
Poinçon de Genève
By: Bill : March 13th, 2010-17:25
The Geneva seal. The Geneva seal in horology (watches), is a certification reserved for wrist watch movements made in the City or Canton of Geneva. Although it is concerned mainly with the finishing and decoration of the watch movement, it is considered a...
Well said.
By: DSD : March 14th, 2010-05:47
Mo - I think you summed up my feelings to a tee. I personally think this practice and these trends, if they continue as they are currently, will significantly dilute the prestige (and hence the main selling draw) for Swiss makers. While it may sound melod...
Transparency and Analogy
By: BDLJ : March 15th, 2010-20:44
Well said, J. I like your three points. Particularly in regards to transparency. I doubt we'll ever know exactly how vertically integrated particular watch brands are unless they reveal it to us...which I doubt. (Seiko and Rolex would appear to be the mos...
you are correct.......
By: JMan : March 15th, 2010-21:30
We are willing to drive cars and fly planes with "outsourced" parts - some of which require greater precision than watch components. But we (and I) find it hard to accept outsourced parts in a watch. The feeble human psyche.... J.