I had the opportunity to get 1 via Mr Porter but I prefer the HODINKEE edition due to the size and the different case/look but the rake one is really nice too. I have a wallet made of the old leather and I didn't find the smell to be so negative but...it is still pretty strong also after years ! still you got a very cool piece and a nice complement to the HODINKEE one. I love the idea of collecting only the Mark collection because is very pure and special. Wear it in good health !