Baron - Mr Red
14613
i appear to be very unclear...
....i never meant to suggest for a second that the 5070 had been in production for 40 years. What i said was that it was the first manual wind watch for 40 years.....
The Ref. 1463 stopped production in the 1960s. There was then no manual wind simple chrono production until the 5070, in 1998. Hence, for almost 40 years Patek Philippe never produced a manual wind chrono.
I hope that i am now clearer
PP 5170P: my Favorite by far from 2017 PP collection
I could not see in the heavy metal the PP 5131P, but from the 2017 PP collection I was very impressed by the first 5170P photos published on the net and on our beloved site ;-)). Then, I was waiting to could see this model in real. I have to admit I LOVE ...
Lume on the hour and minute hands
really helps. The black dial 5170g was hard to read in dim light as the silver hands literally blend into the black dial. Would have to see this watch in the metal to gauge the impact of the diamond markers. I am not a fan of diamond dials except for wome...
My view regarding diamonds on watches
Round diamonds are more adapted for women's watches. Diamonds on bezel are not for my cultural policy and taste. But, baguette diamonds ONLY on the dial (not on bezel) have a masculine elegant touch and could fit for a Male attire. I like the VC patrimony...
I think it is a real beauty. Would love to see it in the metal.
is it an application piece? retail price?
Not an application piece, but limited in time and numbers for sure
According to PP, the official retail price in CHF is 85,000 VAT included in Switzerland and price as of April 1st, 2017. Best, patrickh
Thank you Patrick!
Lovely photos of a truly beautiful watch. I was privileged to try it on at Basel and fell in love with the dial. Just before placing my order, I decided to be objective and cautious and try on a 5170G at a salon and I noticed immediately that the watch wa...
Hey Sham....
....i am not sure people are being critical of the diamonds. I think it is genuinely a cultural thing. Even if the diamonds were "totally" unobtrusive, I would have trouble going for it. Stuffy english background.....i can't do diamonds on a dial. My puri...
Hi Joe!
I promise you that I too am not keen on diamonds (maybe that explains why I have four ex wives! ) but the point I am trying to make is that the watch does not look like it has diamonds on them when you look at it. We are privileged to view the watch thank...
i wouldn't like it even if it was glass....
.....i think i see the watch dial as something that should not be "adorned" with any form of precious stone or gemstone.....it is this specific decorative angle that doesn't sit with me. Like a number of others, too, i see diamonds as something for my wif...
Understood Joe
We agree to disagree (again I understand that you like the watch to be as understated as possible. Nothing wrong with that.
You should consider to wear it tight and higher on your wrist ;-))
A real Winner. Thank you for your comments, Best, Patrickh
2 nice versions Karl.
The ranking is a matter of personal taste. The Pt version is awesome IMHO. Best, Patrickh
Thanks for posting 5170p Patrickh
Im very much in the 5170p corner, and your pictures only strengthen my resolve to acquire one. Blue and black dials have traditionally been colors associated with platinum Pateks, and it seems this reference enjoys both. Black in low lighting and blue in ...
Thank you for your nice detailed answers. I hope
you will enjoy like me this incredible piece on wrist. An icon, as 5070P still is. Best, Patrickh
+1 agreed Alex
42mm is too large on my wrist and Lemania too small in the 5070 case ;-)) even if it is nice on larger wrists.
Well, Joe, I think that Alex expressed
that it was his favorite and didn't talk about iconic or not. Btw, I think that iconic doesn't necessarily mean beautiful either but more the place it has in the brand's history. The 5170P has everything to become iconic (we'll see if it does), especially...
How I wished a diamond less dial !!
I would have pulled the trigger and counting the days till the delivery. The watch is superb in every single aspect,Except for the diamonds. Best, Ahmed
Agreed.
Without diamonds it could never challenge the 5070. With diamonds it has even less chance. But that's just my view. Time will tell.
Yes
I can see why people like the 5170p. I can see why people believe it is beautiful. But when talk is of a "future" icon, then it gets tricky. One thing for sure, people never talked of the 5070p as a future icon. It just happened.
5070...as a reference is iconic in my view
I mentioned P as that is what the poster discussed. The reference is special. The first manual wind chrono from PP for how many years?? 40 years?
my bad....what i meant was....
.....5070 was the first manual wind chrono from Patek for over 40 years. It was a re-start of the manual chrono for them.
Lemania was the first manual wind chrono and used and reworked by PP. The ref 5070 does not produced 40 years ;-)). New manual in-house PP chronograph was created for 5170.....
I fully understand the logical answers posted here by happy owners of 5070s. I never said that 5070s and specially 5070P were not icons still now and for long .....
i appear to be very unclear...
....i never meant to suggest for a second that the 5070 had been in production for 40 years. What i said was that it was the first manual wind watch for 40 years..... The Ref. 1463 stopped production in the 1960s. There was then no manual wind simple chro...
It was the first manual chrono only
while the 3970 already used the movement from 1986. As a side note, to me, the first time we use a specific feature (movement, dial layout, lugs, hands etc...) isn't enough to make a watch iconic. If a watch is badly designed, you can have the 1st time mo...
Agree as well...
Was explaining to someone the other day about the 5070. It is such a unique piece, and the last of the older Pateks. I think it will be collectible in future, akin to 530. Just so unique - 5170 very mass produced IMO.
I was no position to buy the 5070P
When it was launched,Today I can buy this.I didn't want to challenge the 5070P,I am seeking a simple manual chronograph preferably in platinum. Best, Ahmed
Absolutely gorgeous
My favorite chronograph I think. This and he 5650G my standout favorites this year... Looks amazing in every way. Did you acquire one?
I would like, but my banker knows I have other
on going plans for my family. Watches are just a personal pleasure. Not so serious by comparison. Later on with great pleasure or if I win at some lottery ;-)) And yourself? Cheers, Patrickh
I wish....
But sadly no room for this wonderful piece in the box as it stands currently. Look forward to seeing one the real sometime soon!!!
First delivery end of 2017, I was told. So, time could help ;-))
Many collectors are already waiting for this one, so 2018 should be more realistic now.
I am definitely ambivalent about this piece
Obviously with out seeing IRL it is hard to make any real judgement but I still prefer 5070 The diamonds are a small issue but look unobtrusive in the pics I love the simple case and the black dial It is a bit large for me but not a deal breaker My hope i...
Julian, I was told the number and timing for delivering this model will be short,
maybe like for the 5070P in its time. Will see..... I do not have cristal ball. Cheers, Patrickh
Gentlemen
I disagree with the notion that the 5170p and the 5070p must, for some reason, compete against each other. They are quite different in their philosophies. The 5070p is a highly respected reference, and nothing will change that. The 5170p was not created t...
Like your sentences. Agree +++++
I note myself, 5170 (39,4mm) fits better on my small wrist than 5070 (42mm) did. Best regards, Patrickh
You are right .. They are different but everything is a copy of something
The 5070 is a copy of the split second model and the 5170 is really similar (although larger and much better movement) than the classic 130 or even the 530 So would you spend 100k + for a new piece or would you try and find a ref 1463 or similar model for...
Copy or heritage?
Copy to me would be if it was inspired by another manufacturers historical designs, but in this case I would not call it copy. I fully understand what you mean and do not disagree but to call both these references copies is perhaps a stretch. The choice t...
Very well said H
They should not be in competition. Furthermore, "iconic" doesn't mean beautiful or nice, it just means that it is an important thing in the history of the brand and stands out for different reasons, not only beauty. Btw, many 5070 owners said the watch is...
Thank you Mark,
As always for your positive comments and support. I agree with you that the 5170p is a more classic interpretation of a pure chronograph. Im also looking forward to your write up concerning this reference. Almost as much as the actual watch. All the best ...
Great reading your feedback
That's a great looking version and the decoration choices used for the dial bring a lot in terms of charm. Before the Nautilus 40th Anniversary pieces were unveiled I wouldn't have thought about diamonds for a watch today but I tend to think now that this...