Hi Ping,
I think your advice is worth much more than 2 cents and at the very least a quarter 
You summed it up so well, there's not much I can add. Except that when picking shoes I must have comfort. It is a bit harder to find sexy shoes that feel good, but it's possible. Too many times in the past I purchased a pair of shoes thinking they look great but knowing theyy doesn't feel good on my foot. Inevitably, I never wear those shoes, despite their good looks, b/c they end up being foot eaters. Across all brands in all price ranges there are those sneaky foot eaters. Beware look over comfort, I say.
But, given the choice of the above shoes, I think the top Choo is the prettiest 
m