Mark in Paris[Purist]
10488
Thanks for the deep insight,
You know Nicolas what was my feeling about this watch already.
It's not a question of "is it so different that we will need some time to like it". It's a style that is comparable, from my own eyes, to big shunky watches that are litterally spreading on the market nowadays: big, no elegance at all, bad ceramic bezel look and not well matching with the case (imho still). It's like what became the ROO today.
Furthermore, I don't like the bi-color YG or RG and steel/Pt/WG combination but this is a question of market and is not an objective issue at all.
Technically speaking, it's still a great caliber (being able to move everything in every direction without mechanical damage is yet a smashing detail).
Thus for me it's not an evolution.
But still, everyone has its own taste and I respect that.
Cheers,
Mark
I can understand you.
By: amanico : December 9th, 2012-14:25
I owned both the Sonata and the Platinum QP GMT... They were too close, and sold the QP GMT. I have the intuition that I will get much less tired of the first Sonata than of the new one, too. But there are many intresting elements, on the new one, such a ...
Nice review Nicolas!
By: andrewluff : December 9th, 2012-13:06
I was lucky enough to have a chance to play with one again last week after being a little underwelmed by it on previous occasions. I must say it had the ceramic bezel and I really liked the combo, the gold is very in your face. I actually like them both f...
yes I do.
By: cisco : December 10th, 2012-01:23
There is no watch which can be compared to the old sonata, only the Winston Z6 technically, but from the style and what it gives on the wrist, it is really special and one of a kind. For a streamline "No gold" version maybe in the future. I think it will ...
well done Nicolas...
By: SS#27 : December 10th, 2012-11:42
the only thing I would add is to note that both of these watches are substantially cheaper than the Sonata Silicium. Something which also should be considered in their review. I would not part with my Sonata Silicium version for either of these.