...all he said was it was a cool watch and that it was unusual in terms of dial and metal combo. And he’s right, it IS a cool watch in my opinion. And I’m certain there are plenty here that would likely express the same opinion.
I’m not sure I agree with the criticism; he seems like a passionate collector and he wants to share that. Good for him. He just happens to do so on a different medium.
This is also the same John Mayer that got royally shafted by a certain vintage Rolex dealer several years ago. I bet he learned some lessons from that. (It was public knowledge, there was a lawsuit which may have been dropped or settled or both).