Jay (Eire)
12503
Jimmy, welcome to the forum.
Most important I think is that you get as much hands on exposure to both of these pieces, and as many others, as possible. If the Boutique or AD can't facilitate this with stock then I suggest asking the people at either place to arrange for another collector to come to the Boutique or AD and show you their own pieces. I have done this before for pieces which were never in stock. Any good sales rep should be able to arrange this for you and if they can't then go somewhere that will.
Would I buy my first watch (at this level) sight unseen? No way.
Re size, we can't answer that question for you as I do think it all needs to be in the context of your wrist. Objectively, the 42mm has a fat bezel. Do you think that looks better or worse than than the thinner bezel 40mm? From my own experience I can tell you that in the past the 40mm also had a fat bezel, this has been thinned it out in recent years. With the old fat bezel on the 40mm I never thought it looked right on my wrist. However with the slimmer bezel it looks better. That was my personal experience with fat bezels, so I do think you need to see it on your own wrist to make this call.
AD verus Boutique. Highly subjective, based on your current relationships and your future expectations.
Considering my first FP Journe
Hi guys, newbie here and looking to buy my first FPJ! As this is my first foray into the brand, I am most interested in pieces towards the more simplistic end. The pieces that appeal to me the most visually are the CS red gold with gold dials and Lune pla...
The most important thing is you have to look at it and try it on. Don’t trust the photographs. You know which one would suit you once you try them on. Follow your heart.
I would prefer CS. However my first FPJ is Octa Automatique Reserve 38 mm because I needed a date watch. Later on I acquired a CS for my collection. But the followings are my PERSONAL principles: 1) Sport vs Dress 2) any complications you want 3) Dial: in...
Should be all questions you can answer yourself...
Welcome newbie! If you're in a position to consider acquiring an FP Journe, you are probably a fairly successful guy. I could be wrong and maybe you just won big at a casino, but chances are this is not the first big decision you had to make. For question...
Patrick - not constructive IMO
Your words come off more as a rebuke than helpful. Something tells me you have given this type of reply before. This is a new FPJ enthusiast and probably needs encouragement more than a lecture.
I know where you're coming from. I've received countless lectures in my life...
I've received countless lectures in my life. Some were a little painful. But all were filled with truth. Frankly, I wouldn't have learned as much as I have over the years without some of these painful lectures. I recall our conversation very clearly and i...
Thanks
Cheers Patrick I understand your viewpoint. I am usually decisive enough to not ask strangers for advice but I have heard good things about this forum being open to newbies like me. I can actually see many answers here that are super helpful. My biggest m...
Good luck Mate!
It is totally difficult to get good advice, so I understand the need for someone new to watches to want a guiding hand. The salesperson at an AD might not know enough about the product to provide sound advice (although they generally will give advice on s...
Personal insight I was hoping for!
I am from Australia and international travel is explicitly not allowed right now. Our border lockdown has kept us in better shape than most of the world so can hardly complain. Once restrictions lift it will be first flight to Tokyo boutique. a) Thank you...
I also do not have a F.P. Journe
Where i buy it doesn’t matter if the watch is honestly and ok. My choice for the first would be an Octa S in 42mm.
Jimmy, welcome to the forum.
Most important I think is that you get as much hands on exposure to both of these pieces, and as many others, as possible. If the Boutique or AD can't facilitate this with stock then I suggest asking the people at either place to arrange for another colle...
Cheers
I was not aware that is even possible. Will give it a go! Here is my wrist on my biggest watch, VC 42.5m OS Gen2: . I was not aware of the 40mm proportions changing over the time so thank you for that info! Yeah with travel restrictions a physical visit ...
I would ask the AD for sure. Failing that, are there any collector groups in your area?
I hope this could be the route to get hands on with some pieces. What else is in your collection today? The Overseas as you shared, and you mentioned Rolex too?
Collectors group
Not that I am aware of... I am in Sydney, Australia. I also have a Rolex Explorer I and a JLC Master Control Date, amongst some earlier mistakes like Tag and Baume et Mercier.
RedBar Sydney must exist surely. I know RedBar Melbourne exists and is active, so perhaps ping those folks.
Also, check out The Fifth Wrist. I think those folks are local to you (same country) and may be able to help you connect with other collectors down under,
Redbar Sydney is inactive I believe
Will reach out to Melbourne and see what’s happening. Thanks!
boutiques and import
If becoming a collector and eventually owning many FPJs is a possibility, establishing a relationship with a boutique can be very beneficial. But I also wouldn't bother unless I planned to visit the boutique personally. You didn't mention your location bu...
re: import
Yeah so where I am from, as long as you can prove ownership for over 12 months, you don't have to pay duties. My family can hang onto the watch for a while for me to eventually pick it up Will not dare to try actual importing... Don't have the stomach for...
Welcome and good luck!
I never buy a watch without handling it first. When I see a watch in a picture, I have a reasonable idea of how it will wear on my wrist, but I’ve been surprised enough times to know that there’s simply no substitute for trying a watch (any watch) on befo...
thank you for the welcome
Appreciate that. I think many members feel it is silly to purchase without seeing and I think I will follow that advice sincerely. This will actually be my first dress watch. I have been a Rolex fan since beginning of the hobby and it feels pretty liberat...
+1 viewing timepiece in person before making the purchase.
I was fortunate to acquire an FPJ CB prior to the piece becoming extremely difficult to source. In terms of how I decided on the specific FPJ, I feel this is specific to each individual in terms of what type of timepiece, complication, metal, etc. he/she ...
thanks!
Point taken with handling the piece before purchasing. I think there is wide consensus here that anything else is bit foolish. Yeah buying either piece at my AD will elevate me to "VIP" status, which will help me get access to other brands too. Since gett...
Hi Jimmy welcome to WPS
I think you got some good feedback from some of our members. I see you are located in Australia. FPJ are represented by a retailer in Sydney. You can find the info on the FPJ website.
Thank you Christian!
I have just made my first FPJ purchase without seeing it, basically against everyone’s advice there. Will post photo when the watch is with me.
Contrarian...
I would actually be one of the few to say that trying on an FPJ is probably less important than almost al other brands. For one, Journe is known for being eminently wearable and it’s not like trying on a royal oak or a datograph. If the CB was 38 or 40 in...
Thank you for the response
This was the way I was leaning, I was so impressed by the aesthetics of the CS and willing to pay for it without seeing one. Luckily, hourglass couldn’t order for me (still newish relationship) so either way I have to wait until March for first peek. Yes ...
Cs in Sydney
Not sure if they still have it but time keeper in the strand had a CS last year - could ask and try it on if they do. They just sold a CB recently for 80 odd.
Cheers
Just called them, they changed ownership recently and the rep has never heard of the brand. I pointed out there is a CS on their website and uhhhhh, she says the website belongs to the old owner and has nothing to do with them... Thanks though
Oops
My bad was circle red that sold the CB recently; but you’d think they’d still have heard of Journe! Lol yeah time keeper now specialize in selling Rolex sports well above market price
Change in taste.
This is a very valid consideration. I think for all of us taste evolves, but I do think in the early days taste can change very quickly so you are right to be aware of this. I would not have been interested in Journe in my first several years of collectin...
Thanks Jay
I hope this will be the first of many. The FPJ universe is just intoxicating!
Lots of good advice here
Make sure to take your time and try on the pieces in person if possible. See which one “speaks to you.” You’ll know when the *right* Journe is on your wrist. Tastes change. I’m still evolving as a Journe collector and have let go of some pieces I thought ...