whit
558
5015 or 5054?
The two pieces you are considering are similar but at the same time, entirely different. If a date is important, then the obvious choice is the 5014. If not, then the 5015 has some features which should also be considered.
The 5054 has very clean lines and was the forerunner to many pieces currently in the Patek collection, the 3712, 5712, etc. The 5015 has two features which I feel are quite important to consider though. Remember, prior to the 5015, the only Pateks with the moonphase display were perpetuals, the 5015 was the first non-perpetual piece introduced. The other is the moonphase itself which can be set precisely, more so than the 5014. These two elements, in my opinion make the 5015 an important piece in Patek's history and certainly one not to be overlooked regardless of cosmetics.
If given the choice, I would choose the 5015 due to its historical importance.
Best of luck with your decision, it's a tough one but either would be a great watch to own.
Whit
💰1729 Marketplace Listings for Patek Philippe›Patek Philippe Calatrava · 2 for sale · 8309 discussions›
Need your opinion: buying Patek Philippe 5015 or 5054?
Dear Patek Philippe lovers, I am about to purchase my first PP watch (second hand of course) and I don't know which one to choose among 5015 and 5054 models. I am considering only those 2 ones because I want both moon phase and power reserve indicator. Co...
5054
I would personally go with the 5054 between those two. It\'s a bit more of a classic look, and I\'ve never been convinced by the quasi hobnail bezel of the 5015. Also, the moon phase of the 5054 is more traditional. Finally, I believe the 5054 had a hunte...
complication
Actually they both have the hunter caseback. To be honest, I prefer the 5015 but absolutely everyone around me prefers the 5054 so I try to convince myself through this post to take the 5054 Also one good point for this point is the date: it's one more co...
I would not hesitate a single second: 5054
it is more classic, more Patek-like. The watch is also much easier to sell if you would like to do that one day. Good luck! Kari
Both are good watches.
Depends if you are more a casual guy. The 5015r with hobnail bezel would be more for formal wear. But both have a good movement in the 240 Cal. So chose prudently. If you can afford , get both you won't go wrong. Cheers. Geross.
5015 R is my vote
And it is purely based on the design. The 5054 has no exuberance, is not big theatre compared to the 5015. The 5054 is watch but the 5015 is something different than just a watch. I very much like the period and baroque look of it! Best Moritz
agree
To be honest I agree with you. I like the baroque style of number font, compare to 5054 which has something like "Arial-style" numbers.. But for such a purchase I have to consider also the resell, years later, and a few people like the Clous de Paris case...
I woulld not look too much on the finacial aspects of it
I have also bought a Patek for myself that is known to be a "acquired taste" model, a model that is not main stream . And I bought it new from an AD. To me it is still "the most beautiful Patek" and whether any other Patek is better in after market value ...
Another key point to consider
I have to precise that the 5015R goes with a completely destroyed box and only a certificate of origin, without original date of purchase neither original shop stamp. The 5054J goes with a pretty new PP long box (not the big square wooden box) and an "Ext...
Make it simple!
Like many members of the forum, I would also go for the 5054 due to all the reasons already mentioned but ultimately, if your heart is set of on 5015, do not buy the 5054 because you will always be thinking about the 5015. I am a bit more sentimental with...
Between thos 2, I would pick 5054.
And that is purely based on subjective looks. But why limit to those 2? There are other PPs with both power reserve and moonphase (5712, 5146 for example, and others that are not current like my 5056).
limitations
my limits are 1. the availabilities in HK second hand market (I live here as expat), 2. I really don't like Nautilus/Aquanaute models and 3. I LOVE the 5146 and 5056 but they are just twice the price of 5015/5054 !
5015 or 5054?
The two pieces you are considering are similar but at the same time, entirely different. If a date is important, then the obvious choice is the 5014. If not, then the 5015 has some features which should also be considered. The 5054 has very clean lines an...
5054 or 5015
First, welcome on our Patek forum, I hope you'll find interesting reading This is a nice project you have here and you're considering watches we don't have the opportunity to discuss often about. I must say I totally understand your appeal for these tradi...
Story
Dear Whit and Mark, Thank you for your feedback. Let me explain the story of this decision: after spending time in second-hand reseller in HK two weeks ago (Mongkok, TST, Central..) I found the 5015R timepiece and I immediately liked it: even if I don't l...
IMO, the hobnail is a...
winner because it brings more elegance to 5015 than the other reference Patek is about elegance for me. Good luck with your decision. Cheers Gordon
And the winner is...
I chose the 5054J ! Despite the small design differences, the overall condition is better and it comes with many accessories (a brand new wooden box, a long travel box, Archives paper). I will post full pictures in the next days to let you see this wonder...
I'm glad you could make your choice
Now we are eagerly waiting for your pictures when you can, it is so rare to see! I wish you to wear it in the best of health For an old reference it is always reassuring and a nice feeling to have it stop by PP for a checkup. It will ensure many years of ...
Well
5054 is cool, especially in RG/WG. The other one...I would believe that the spaces between the tiny hobnails would gather dirt quickly. I would polish it every day and curse the (&"%$"$ hobbnails soon.