sidneyc
2009
5146 for me... by a bit
The 5205 is a modern direction for Patek... the new dial looks very nice and reminds me of it's much more expensive tourbillon/minute-repeating cousin - the 5207 
The 5146 have a much stronger Patek DNA, the dial and case is very much classic Patek that will last forever into the future.
5205 or 5146
I am planning to place an order for my next patek, 5205 or 5146. I like both of them, however inclined to settle on the new 5205. Looking for other opinions. There are obvious differences, look, price. May be something else I need to know about. Thank you...
My vote
Is the 5146g. I own the gray dial version it is a great wearing watch. Really like a QP at a much lower price point. I love the race track and since I love the chrono look this analog dial is great. I have lodged for several years at the digital window bu...
I am quite happy ..
with my 5146G but the 5205 has another look in addition to some special features. It's very subjective and for an anuual calender they both work extremely well (same caliber) and are both desirable IMO. Go with your heart & disregard the small differe...
Thank you everybody,
my thinking towards 5207 is that for me the calendar is more readable, 5146 I have to bring closer to my eyes to read the dials.
5205 for me, without any doubt.
I find the dial easier to read... and more important: the case is stunning. Fx...
I'll tell you what.........
I've wanted a 5146g with slate dial for the longest time and have seen the watch many times but after having my father-in-laws 5205 on this weekend I'd have to say that aesthetically, it may be Patek's nicest looking watch. Therefore, I would go with the ...
Alex, I have been fortunate to have own both pieces...
In fact my current Patek is the same colour combination 5205G that is in Ton's lovely photo I tend to agree with your thoughts, but the 5146 is of course a classic looking Patek compared to the more, but still very beautiful & trendy looking 5205. I n...
thank you everybody, again
just made my mind and placed a deposit with AD today for 5205. hopefully will get it soon.
5146
I had a similar choice about a year ago; 5146 or 5396. As i would be wearing the watch as a daily, i decided on the 5146. No regrets at all, stunning watch, both with a suit or with jeans.
Alex congratulations upon your choice.................
I trust that you will be very happy and not have to wait too long for it
5146 for me
I have a 5135, for me the 5146 with it's luminous hands and dots wins for me. It is easier to read the time first and foremost because of that, the dates and days should be a draw. I'm not particularly fond of the white second hand either.
5146 for me... by a bit
The 5205 is a modern direction for Patek... the new dial looks very nice and reminds me of it's much more expensive tourbillon/minute-repeating cousin - the 5207 The 5146 have a much stronger Patek DNA, the dial and case is very much classic Patek that wi...
