Pretty Boy
6507
5270R - What's not to love about this beauty?
I attended a presentation of Patek's 2017 novelties last week organized by my AD. After I saw 5320G and 5170P in the metal, I wasn't entirely convinced by either of them, for different reasons of course (although I would prefer 5170P over 5320G). Yesterday, my AD came up with 5270R and even before I had it on my wrist, I fell in love with it. The proportions of its case are simply perfect, IMO, and it provides for a classic combination of classic complications. I like the RG case and the beautifully toned dial, too. Are there any cons (personal taste cons are also welcome)? Best, Volker
PS: Sorry for the bad quality of the photos (case was still wrapped and light conditions were challenging).
Available on the marketplace
New Release
Discover Patek Philippe's 2017 Baselworld novelties: 24 new references blending tradition with modern design, including the 5320G, 5168G, and 5372P.
124 replies80365 views
New Release
Explore Patek Philippe's 2022 collection, featuring the new 5326G, green-dialed 5270P, and limited Rare Handcrafts. Get insights and pricing.
143 replies43511 views
Complications
Explore the Patek Philippe 5320G vs. 5140P Perpetual Calendar debate. Collectors discuss design, wearability, and value in this in-depth WatchProSite article.
115 replies38083 views
Review
Mark in Paris reviews the Patek Philippe 5320G Perpetual Calendar from Baselworld 2017. Explore its new case design and stylistic evolution.
51 replies32903 views
Discussion
Explore the Patek Philippe 5320G perpetual calendar, blending vintage aesthetics with modern design. Discuss its dial, case, and collector appeal.
71 replies25308 views
Vintage
Explore the evolution of Patek Philippe moonphase displays from vintage enamel discs to modern frosted styles. Horology_Ancienne details key references like 2499, 3970, and 5970, revealing the brand's artistry.
69 replies24785 views
5270R - What's not to love about this beauty?
I attended a presentation of Patek's 2017 novelties last week organized by my AD. After I saw 5320G and 5170P in the metal, I wasn't entirely convinced by either of them, for different reasons of course (although I would prefer 5170P over 5320G). Yesterda...
Nothing
It is really a perfect watch in every way. The watch market is just not what it was a few years back. Otherwise, these would be very scarce and hard to get.
Cheers.
Your comment regarding the watch market is fair for sure, but there are also some particular circumstances here ;-)
I too agree...nothing
though I could be considered biased as I have one on order which I have been told should arrive end of August/early September having sold my 5170G and 5960/1A to partly fund it. I chose it because for me it represents one of the best watches PP currently ...
I love everything about that watch.
Buy it and cherish it forever (and post lots of pictures)
Absolutely nothing wrong with a 5270r however,
In my mind and I'm sure in many minds here it's more of a question of 5270 V 5970 If I had to choose between these 2 watches for me it's a No Brainer. 5970 for all the reasons I fell in love with Patek. This said I love the 5270r very much and will do my ...
Well for me I like the 5270R in preference to the 5970...
like I chose the 5170 over the 5070 but that's just me plus there's the appeal of buying one new with my name on the papers etc
I read the recent posts comparing 5970 and 5270, and also the article about 5970 in the current Patek magazine.
At that price level, however, I would only buy from my AD or a Patek Salon, unless I found 5970 way better than 5270 which clearly isn't the case.
Beautiful watch
And particularly in that metal. One drawback for me: portholes. Same reason I prefer 3448 to 3450. But classy watch for sure.
Ahhhhh it all becomes clear now
That why you dislike the 5960p(boxter) so much. It's the Am/pm portholes. That makes sense. 😉. M.
just a taste thing.....
......for me, the dial needs to be an aesthetic that is cohesive to me. The holes are disruptive to my aesthetic. How are you doing? How is the patent coming?
Thank you for asking
The patent examination report has arrived and according to my patent lawyer it is looking good to get the patent. The whole process will take at least three to four years before the patent document is in my hands. But I am hopeful and have already placed ...
That's a fantastic Chrono-QP reference
and I must say that it is my favorite today if we put aside the 1518 and 2499. I made a review here if you want: www.watchprosite.com This is in many ways and also in terms of aesthetics close to perfection as far as I'm concerned. It is very diff...
Many thanks for your comprehensive reply, Mark. Much appreciated.
Yes, I read your review of 5270, and I fully agree with your assessment above. The 5270 indeed represents a more modern approach, and I also really like the warmth of the YG and the case diameter of 41 mm.
5270 is a fantastic choice
But like Miles and Nicolas, I would (and did) go for the 5970 in preference. My recent post went through the analysis. Ultimately boils down to what rings your bell.
Cheers. Read your analysis and, like you did, would go for 5970P if 5970 was my choice.
Not only that I probably like 5270 better, I also wouldn't buy from anyone else than my AD or a Patek Salon at that price level. This takes 5970 out of the game.
Perfect watch
But the 5970R is more to my taste and the size would look better on my wrist. Best, Ahmed
Thanks, Ahmed.
Strangely (or not), Miles also mentioned the case size. I tend to prefer bigger case diameters (40 mm +), although I liked 5170P on my wrist which is 39,4 mm. Looking at the photos, 5270 indeed looks quite large on my wrist. When I personally looked at it...
It looks good on your wrist
Don't get me wrong,But I believe the 5970 will look even how I feel,But you are one who's going to wear it at the end. Best, Ahmed
If this watch
fits your wrist (and in the photo it clearly does), buy it as in my opinion, it is the best Patek for sale under £200k. For a start the patina on the dial is as close to perfection as a dial colour could be. The movement is what Patek are famous for - the...
Thanks a lot for your reply.
Have you tried 5230G? I know it is 40 mm but on my wrist it wore noticeably smaller than 5170P with its 39.4 mm.
I tried it last week and wasn't impressed either.
Liked 5170P better but none of these comes close to 5270 or 5970, IMO.
DNA wise its got all the qualities you look for in a complicated watch.
Just beautiful , i believe a joy to wind and wear. Best wishes. Wear in good health and while driving your Porsche. Geross.
Balance is what makes it so
I totally agree - just about perfect in every way. The complications are impressive, but not overbearing. The size and height are decent, but not bulky or flimsy. Even the symmetrical balance of the face is so even. I find the 3970 a bit too small but the...
I have a 5970R and I love the watch...
As others have noted, the layout, size and general appeal are great. I go back and forth on whether I prefer the WG version....certainly platinum would be top of list. Dave