amanico
[JLC Moderator]
402225
That is THE question!
And a tough one!
It would be more coherent to get the 5970 over the 5070, yes, I think.
But I used to dream about the 5070, while I just re discovered the 5970 when it was launched in 2008 / 2009, in its platinum version.
A strong long love versus a revelation...
Which one is better?
Best,
Nicolas.
2 quick pictures of a true Beauty: The 5970P.
I furtively saw this reference in the real before, but during our last London GTG, one of our friends had the good idea to bring it with him. What can I say? I stayed speechless... My favourite PC Chrono from PP, by far. Compared to the WG version, I find...
these are not just 2 'quick' pictures
They are too good to be taken in a few seconds Very nice watch btw !
It's a dangerous obsession Nicolas...
This one is also undoubtedly my favorite PC-Chrono Patek Philippe... You're right about the busy but balanced dial... And to add, the black dial gives a nice contrast.. Makes it better looking compared to the WG version... Now you're in big trouble, my fr...
I know, I know ...
I can resist, I can resist, I can resist, I can resist... Best, my friend. Nicolas.
Nicolas.......Better than my quick shots......This watch makes me go weak at the knees.:)
The 5970 is perfectly balanced and as a grand complication does it for me...........
Very nice indeed.
. Nice to see wristshots of it. Looking forward to seeing how it'll look on MY wrist next...
Of course she is a beauty; she's white metal.
Being Patek and a 5970 helps too ;-) Thanks, for the lovely photos Nicolas...Is this your latestest or next acquistion? Best, -- Richard.
Save well my friend...
I'll tell Thierry to give you a good price ;-) Best, -- Richard.
It always cracks me up
It always cracks me up when ever I see a watch with a moon phase that is not set correctly. Over the years of veiwing these pictures it is very common for this to occur; I would say maybe 75% of the time. Is it really that difficult to set the moon; they ...
No the moon phase is incorrect....
I've just checked and assuming the pic was taken this year the full moon in May is the 17th so this watch on the 8th should be approaching the full moon while in the pic it has just passed a full moon. Never noticed this in pics before. However what an ab...
That is the problem with moonphase watches...
Even if, on PC, the moonphase has to be synchronized with the perpetual calendar... Can you imagine when it is not linked with a perpetual calendar? Each time the watch is not wound, you have to check what is the exact moonphase, which is a bit fastidious...
Yes it can be a pain, and mine is just a moonphase...!!
I don't know how one would set a PC and whether you could just advance the moonphase without all the other parts coming into play. For Xmas my mum got me a moonphase calendar which is great and makes setting my reverso so much easier...but I have to admit...
AFAIK, you can't set the moonphase independantly to the Perpetual Calendar ...
And you need to send the watch to the Manufacture to set it properly... Best, Andy. Nicolas.
Your joking..!! Really..!!
I can understand why it's not set now.....but then again shouldn't they set it at the factory before sending it out..? Wow. Andy.
Isn't it coordinated and synchronized to the perpetual calendar?
Does the dedicated button allow such an independant setting? Interesting. Best, and thanks for the precision / correction. Nicolas.
the pusher which sets the month is coordinated with the leap year indicator,
while the pusher for the moonphase is independent. you can just keep pushing it and the moonphase disc will turn from full moon to none, over and over. I would add that unless the moon is full or zero at the time of setting, it becomes a guess where you s...
Thank you, Wilson, for this information.
And yes, you're right, setting in an absolute accurate way the moonphase is a bit approximative, except if you do it when the moon is totally full or empty, as you said. Agred on the fact that it is not a real big deal. Best, and thanks. Nicolas.
LOL..that's honesty for you..:o)
It's a beautiful piece Imran and if you want to set it the 17th May is a full moon. Hope to see this beauty one day at another London GTG. Yours, Andy.
I thoroughly agree...
It is spectacular, modern, and classic all at the same time. I'm afraid it may be the pinnacle of Patek Philippe design and manufacturing in the PP Chrono genre. Jeff.
Well said, Hommage.
Moderrn and Classic at the same time... Timeless? This one will be hard to beat! Best, Nicolas.
As far as I am aware
The moon phase can be sent independently, as previously mentioned by the use of the pushers. At least I could do with my 5140. Great photos, but could someone say how they find the legibility of the dial say over the W/G one. The reason for me asking, is ...
Well, I'm more used to PC which you can set by one pusher or by the crown.
But if you have several pushers, it seems lofgical that you can set indepedantly the date and the moonphase. As for the legibility of this 5970P, this is not the thing whioh would worry me the more. I don't find legibilty to be problematic, not ore than a...
You're right... I don't see that as a problem, but as a pleasure.
I have some good reasons to take more time to read the time... Which is a delicious reason, with such a watch. Best, my friend. Nicolas.
Love pics of the beauty Nicolas.
Wish that you'll have one on your wrist soon. Best, Goh
I have more than one issue, here, Goh...
First of all, finding the money to get this one is not an easy thing, even if not impossible, as I could sell a part of my collection. BUT I will have to face another issue, due to one of my silly personal rules: When it comes to PP, Lange or Vacheron, I ...
That is THE question!
And a tough one! It would be more coherent to get the 5970 over the 5070, yes, I think. But I used to dream about the 5070, while I just re discovered the 5970 when it was launched in 2008 / 2009, in its platinum version. A strong long love versus a revel...
Moonphase and Legibility
I am so pleased to read all he positive words on this watch. It is a joy. So, firstly, the moonphase is independently set, and simply requires you to know how many days after a Full Moon or a New Moon you are, and you push the setting push piece once for ...
From your pictures, this is not the PC I don't find legible, but the ...
Chrono. Definitely convinced by this 5970P. Lucky fellow! Best, Nicolas. This message has been edited by amanico on 2011-05-15 10:30:38
Hypothetical question
Nicholas Would you consider owning both the ALS dato in platinum/black dial and this 5970p? This question foregoes your owning the 5070. Thanks for your opinion. Joe