Comments:
My perpetual dilemma 5140G or J
I recently made a very big decision in my watch life and put a deposit on a 5140G, my all time favorite Perpetual Calender (well, you can't get a new 3940 anymore...). I have never owned a Patek Phillipe, but next week I will be going home with one. I was quite surprised, perhaps somewhat dissapointed, when Patek Phillipe announced that the gold versions of the 5140 would retire and at least for 2016 only live in a new charcoal and the existing black platinum/diamond version. Both platinum versions are nice, but not the colours I want and being beyond my price range anyways they are not an option. Had they not discontinued the gold versions I probably wouldn't have panicked and started searching for dealers with final stock and actually do it. So thank you for that Patek Phillipe, I am now realizing a dream. I have always believed that the white gold version was the one for me, but after seing the J and G next to eachother in real life I now have my doubts. If I already had one watch in one of those precious metals it would be a lot easier, but I don't. I have a steel IWC Mark XVI as my only watch.
The white gold is more understated and the yellow appears too me to be more extravagant. I don't like the rose gold version as much as the white or yellow, so my luxury dilemma stands between these too and I must choose next week. in either case I will get it with a new strap as these have been used on display.
Which one would you go for? Why? I appreciate your comments.
Welcome here, first. As for your question, I would go for the G.
more understated, yes, but also more modern. While the J plays the retro card.
Just my point of view.
Best,
Nicolas
I would also go for G.
J is more dressy and yellow go seems to be sometimes fashionable, sometimes "out" and considered old fashioned. White gold, steel and platinum are the safest choises and with white metal you can always play with the strap. Ask the seller to order you two bespoke straps with a more exciting colour like blue or even burgundy red. Those go well with the G.
Best, Kari
White gold
I think the yellow looks great, and you can't go wrong with either. In saying that, you only have two watches. The white gold can be worn in more situations in my opinion, and as you're other watch is an IWC Mark, you're probably more of a white metal guy. I think you an I are probably a bit similar in terms of taste. Go the white gold, it's probably more you! I could go on and on about this. Just think about what you wear on a daily basis, you want to be able to enjoy this watch as much as you want to, not just when you wear your suit(s), for example.
yellow gold is eternity!
A perpetual calendar needs magnitude, grace and the big stage.
White gold is o.k ... but nothing else!
Watches were, are and will always be made in numbers in yellow gold as yellow gold is popular in the world.
Tell us your choice.
Best
Moritz
White gold is o.k ... but nothing else!
Watches were, are and will always be made in numbers in yellow gold as yellow gold is popular in the world.
Tell us your choice.
Best
Moritz
Forget fashion.
Forget everything. Just ask yourself "which one speaks to me?". Since you have taken the plunge to ask others (welcome!) you may be a little self-conscious (in a good way). If so, white gold. If a little more showy, yellow. If you are stealth showy, then platinum!
+1 IMHO buying a watch is a true personal choice. You have to let your heart talk first. It will be the best choice for sure
Best wishes
Alkiro
Alkiro
White Gold would be my choice
More versatile with the colour of the straps and shirts. I think this white gold is also Rhodium plated so will give the watch a harder surface to wear.
J
I emphatize with your dilemma. Sometime back I was asking myself the same question too. Somehow for the 5140, the J seems to attract me much more than the G. If I had to choose, it would be the J then.. and even now.
The G is nice and probably more versatile to dress up or down.... But the J, there's something magical. Just follow your heart.. Let us know your final decision. All the best....Cheers !
only if...
it was a 3940, then I'll go for the G. Although the J is a close second. Somehow the 5140, the J appeals much to me. As already mentioned by others here, just go with what your heart tells you. IMHO, can't go wrong with either metals. Cheers !
Players use yellow gold , gentlemen use white gold .. my 5 kruger rands [nt]
No message body
I prefer a WG moon and stars then my vote for the WG
Let us know your final choice.
Best,
patrickh
I'll go for the G
Thank you for your comments and thoughts. I will stick to my original decision and go for the G. It doesn't look better, it just appeals a little more to me somehow. I will share some pics next week.
What ! you are getting a perpetual.....
as a second watch. I would go for the J and jump up and down all day from happiness. Best regards Edward
"get both"
Now that I've gotten out of the way the most useless advice ever, I would go yellow for this piece.
Such a classic perpetual calendar requires an equally timeless color. Rose and white are currently the more popular metals, but this is not a mere mortal's watch to be subjected to today's standards. It's a purchase for a lifetime, or for generations as they so often point out. Yellow gold is most befitting such a timepiece.
The fact that you already have another watch in white metal (albeit stainless) should close the deal, and if still not convinced, then judge for yourself how the dial becomes washed out by the white gold case, while it's enhanced by the colored metal.
Despite the preponderance of dissenting views, the "correct" answer is still yellow gold...
Or just get both.
Would be nice but...
If I buy both I will certainly be divorced, which means my wife will leave with half and I will end up with only watch anyway
.
.
Yellow gold...I can only compare gold colors to wine...
...varietals. There are a lot of red wine grapes, but Cabernet is king.
I think this especially holds true for a case on an iconic, classic watch.
I think this especially holds true for a case on an iconic, classic watch.
White gold
But if you wanted a 3940, why not buy preowned? Alternatively why do you want to only buy new? Picture of White gold 3940 below
Well,
I really like the 5140, so happy with this choice. I looked at available 3940 (among a few other annual and perpetuals as well). Not that I mind buying preowned watches, but I would have to travel pretty far to see one in person. I actually did a few enquires, but never got response.To be honest buying pre-owned watches in that price range also makes me a little nervous if I get one in the right condition inside and out, with right history, original parts etc. But it is really nice one you go there and nice combo with the speedy cufflinks. I think I see a 911 there.
ThAnks
Yes they are 911 cufflinks.
I would just advise you, before you buy a 5140 try a 3940.... take the time to try on. I was dead set on buying a 5130g. Then just for kicks I came across a 5110g... guess which one I bought. Same thing happened with a 5170... dead set on it, loved it on. Then right before buying it, tried on a 5070g.... guess what came home with me
I would just advise you, before you buy a 5140 try a 3940.... take the time to try on. I was dead set on buying a 5130g. Then just for kicks I came across a 5110g... guess which one I bought
. Same thing happened with a 5170... dead set on it, loved it on. Then right before buying it, tried on a 5070g.... guess what came home with me
I have 3940j, 3940g and 5140g
and I kept the 3940G for its size and metal, just me. WG is almost 'invisible', J is 'mildly flirtatous' and RG is "screaming Please Take Me..!!!!" hahahahaha, just me.
Mech.
A fine perpetual
Just tried the platinum and rose gold versions and loved them both.
Best,
Ahmed
Best,
Ahmed