Catherine.
142
..
Is it Small Nic or simply adequete? I've never personally liked either of the JLC or UG samples because of the ill proportioned cases....for my money the JLC with the fat case reminds me of an half used bar of soap (leaving aside the dial looks to belong to something free in a petrol station) and the UG arrives with better fitting depth which is thrown away because of the diameter that is increased for no good horological reason (other than the suppliers insisting that they must have a 42mm case). I think adequete is a better description for the Schaffhausen offering. 
This message has been edited by C.vallely5 on 2009-07-05 21:49:52
For Super Compressor Lovers
One pic which speaks better than a thousand words: These Longines, U.G Polerouter Sub, and JLC Polaris are certainly among the nicest Super Compressor Case Watches. Even if the case is very close on these 3 watches, they have their own personality, charac...
I somehow....
expected this picture from you.... I was just wondering what took you so long..... Cheers
Am I that predictible, Pink Panther?
I hesitated to add the 2 Tribute to Polaris, the Cali and the Re Edition of the Longines Diver... Best, Nicolas
Aaah, Scott, I wondered who will be the first to answer me
That the Cali is the only one to not be a Compressor Case... But this is a nice re edition of the Vintage, don't you think? As the Polaris, and the Longines are. Best, Nicolas
Also.....
the Cali is a nice vintage, true..... But in those three I could add the memovox..... don't you agree? Cheers
Which one, Pink Panther ?
The Vintage Memovox, E 855? The Compressor one? In both cases they don't belong to the same family. But YES, they are interesting, too! Best, Nicolas
the compressor...
Doesn't it belong to the same family????? I was under the impression that it derived from the Polaris Cheers
Yep, but not a Vintage, Pink Panther
Nor a Compressor Case, but Compressor Crowns. But yes, the Master Compressor Memo was inspired by the Pola. Best, Nicolas
I love a lot this idea, PInk Panther
A Vintage to become. I wonder how it will age in 25 years, I'm certain that it will have a great look. Best, Nicolas
Cool , that Polaris
Is it right that JLC is one of THE companies producing alarm watches? Over the years I mean and different models at the time. GEO
Hi, Geo
We can even say that JLC was the first to produce a Diving Alarm Watch, with the Deep Sea Alarm, in 1959. Then, came the Vulcain Nautical, a bit later ( 1961 ? ) Then, since 1962, the first works on the Polaris came, to give birth to the Proto in 1963. If...
Beauties all!
I think if I was forced to choose one type of watch to wear for the rest of my life, super compressor cased dive watches might very well be it. I love all three examples you've chosen to photograph. Thanks for this picture! Cheers, Daos
I think I would make the same choice, Daos
These Super Compressor have the elegance and the sweatness of the 60ies... And as they are quite a lot, the choice is very wide! Best, Sister. Nicolas
Nice post, Nicolas...
A really nice pleasure admire these three marvels side by side. And every one with it's particularities!. Thanks for sharing, hermano EMILIO
You're ready to get another Longines, Hermano
You shoudn't have let it go, my friend... Best, Nicolas
You are right, hermano
I remember this great watch.. But, sometimes, we have to take difficult choices... For hunt dreams... The best of all is I'll be able to hunt another one with some time...let's see Life is hard hermano Best my dear friend
I must concede that I am . . .
Generally speaking, those are not the types of watches I traditionally patronize. That being said, your recently posted photos, both here and on the JLC forum, have admittedly sparked my interest and elevated my appreciation. Craig
The Aquatimer is a nice story,since the mid Sixties, Jed
With a watch I'm hunting so badly... This one: The Ref 812. A great watch in a small case ( 37 mm ). Best, Nicolas...
..
Is it Small Nic or simply adequete? I've never personally liked either of the JLC or UG samples because of the ill proportioned cases....for my money the JLC with the fat case reminds me of an half used bar of soap (leaving aside the dial looks to belong ...
The IWC was more conform to the habits of this period,
Hi, Catherine, Yes, at this moment, 37 mm watches ware even considered too big! Using a 42 mm was a brave decision for U.G, JLC and Longines, but I'm preety sure I forgot some, here. Nowadays, 42 mm are more normal than 37 mm for Diving watches, and seem ...
...
I'm not even too sure they were being brave Nic. Could it not have been 'have what your given or go elsewhere' (from the case manafacturers). Best Regards Catherine. This message has been edited by C.vallely5 on 2009-07-06 05:32:56
Well, Catherine, JLC also made in the late 60ies
A smaller Diving Wathc, the Master Mariner Deep Sea ( 37 mm ), and 2 years later, the Polaris II ( 43 mm ). So, I don' t know if they were obliged to release such big watches. Best, Nicolas
Yes, Nicolas...
you are correct when you say: "Happily, we're not all in love with the same lady!" But most people, even if they happen not to be in love with a particular lady, wouldn't publicly say "She's as fat as a cow, and has the nose of a pig!" And most people und...
Your nearly on the money TonyC....
But alas where you lost it was consistancy, i remember you telling me how you or anybody else cannot possiblly spot a re-dial from a internet pic....which is fair enough i suppose...your opinions, your opinion. And then you go and mess the job up by not b...
Tony and Catherine, I hope I offended no one
It wasn't my intention, just an image... Best, and ...Peace! Nicolas This message has been edited by amanico on 2009-07-06 10:25:06
Thanks for taking the time to post the pieces Nic...
....you might find Northern Englanders tend to call Fat Ladys..'Fat Ladys'...on account of them not being thin Ladys. I guess someone dreamt up the word Fat for a specific reason. Do you think the case sizes were a brave new move from these brands Nic or ...
Well, the first researches on the Polaris began in 1962, Catherine.
The Longines Diver was born the same year, and the UG Polerouter too, or maybe a year before, for this last one. It will be interesting to know when the other Big Super Compressor Case Watches were released, but let's assume that these 3 were among the ve...
Yeah....
I guess we'll never actually know which way it went...i've always felt the Polaris looks to be gagging to have an external chronograph bezel dropped on it (along with a movement installed)....especially given it was the manual chrono period and maybe the ...
The Queen of red herrings...
Catherine, What I said months ago about identifying re-dials from (often poor quality) images on the internet has nothing whatsoever to do with our contributions to this thread. And if you had happened to have been a man, I would have characterized you as...
Thats your opinion TonyC....
I make a comment on a dial ....you comment that i cannot possibly telly you accurately if the dial is authentic. Suitbert makes a comment on a dial... you button it...stum....not a sausage. I've already pointed out to you once that your line of chat is di...
Catherine...
If you are intent on discussing irrelevant, very old, arcane threads, rather than addressing the topic at hand, feel free to e-mail me so that we might spare the other forum members. I would suggest, though, that in the future, if you prefer not to respon...
The boarder is very thin between Vintage and Modern, Jed
Look at your Aquatimer, for example... A lot of Vintage have this timeless look that the boarder with modern and Vintage is really thin... Best, Nicolas
Aesthetically speaking, the bug is in me!
Maybe more accurately put, I don't have an interest in collecting vintage pieces. Though I love to see them and read about them. I can appreciate them on someone else's wrist as easily as my own...for now! Best, Jed
If need to choose one of them...is very hard...
But u have all the three great watch :o) Congrats... Best Chung
a great Trio of Super Compressors Mon Ami
they are not personally the kind of watch i want to collect, but i fully appreciate your desire to own them. we might have different tastes, but understand each others thought processes. i have my eyes on a single crown Polerouter, not quite the same, but...
You're absolutely true, Graham
All the different tastes are the richness of this forum. As for your Polerouter, I think I'm able to guess the year... Well done, my friend! Best, Nicolas
Polaris is my fave alarm!
Hi Nicolas, Polaris is always my fave alarm as the classic simple look never bore me out! Always like to look at it from different angles.. And when the alarm is on, it rings a thousand words ! Lol On the other hand, the Longines is quite attractive. The ...
It rings a thousand words
Excellent, Linda! This is not a scoop, I'm a big Fan of the Polaris, fascinated by its volume, the thick domed plexy, the imperfect indexes, the finish of the dial, the special crowns, and this alarm which sounds like a big frog in Love ( On the Vintage, ...
Oh deeeaaar....
Thanks for your spirited reply, Nicolas! My gut feeling tells me I definitely won't be able to get my hands on the beautiful Longines as it looks vintage and sure indeed it was out in 1962!!! I was not even born yet! Sigh.. You are a lucky man ! It is bea...
Do you mean the sound of the Vintage Pola compared to
The Re Edition? It is indeed very different, but I love both of them. What I regret on the Re Edition is to not feel the " Clong Clong " of the bumper when the watch moves on your wrist ( a cahracteristic of the Cal 815 / 825 ) The new piece sounds like a...
Goodness...
You have the Vintage Polaris ? Or both together with the Tribute to Polaris? I only have the Tribute to Polaris and I get what you mean by "school bell" sound!! Now I wish I can hear the "clonk clonk" version! Sigh.. Do you by any chance have the picture ...