w220
449
One more variation
I believe there is one more variation of the 5127G. The early runs, like mine, had the case rhodium plated. If I recall correctly, the very latest runs of the 5127G were unplated, and hence had a case with a slightly more grayish appearance.
To illustrate the difference, here is my 5127G plated on the left, and my 5140G unplated on the right. It may be difficult to see, but there is a difference in the "whiteness" of the case.
So to summarize the variations:
- 315 vs 324 movement
- Geneva Seal vs PP Seal
- 57 vs 60 dots dial
- Plated vs unplated case
If anyone has one with 315 movement, PP seal, 57 dots and unplated case, that would surely be a very rare variation!
💰1730 Marketplace Listings for Patek Philippe›Patek Philippe Calatrava · 2 for sale · 8377 discussions›
Impressions of Patek Philippe Calatrava 5127
Introduction My first “real” watch was an Omega which my father gave to me when I turned 16 years, and I was an Omega guy for many years thereafter. Then I got busy with life and was mostly away from watches for several years, but back in 2006 I started l...
A lovely story you have shared
thanks for sharing ! Also a nicely written owner’s review of your 5127G. I love the case , dial and movement of this watch too. Enjoy your Calatrava. I’m sure it will continue to bring you lots of joy for years and decades to come Cheers Robin
Wonderful post with fantastic photos
thanks for sharing your story and your watch! CC
Things that make you go, "Ooer!"
w220, Thank you "much-ly" for the story. I did not realise the minute markers were partially "drilled" indentations. Looking at Before/After photos, I can understand why they added the 3 dots by the date window. In the unlikely event anyone wanted to adju...
Thank you for this detailed review.
It’s funny, for a long time I wasn’t really feeling the pull of the Calatrava line like I had for other PP lines. Now, I feel like I’m certainly missing something by not having one. I really love the simplicity, elegance, and history of the line. Thank yo...
Great point
Great point, and that's exactly why I choose to write about the 5127. I feel the Calatrava line often get lost among grand complications, chronographs and steel sports watches, but they do in many ways represent the archetypal Patek.
Congratulations
and thanks for sharing your story. Personally, I am hoping to be able to get my hand on a 5196 someday
Thanks for reminding me of my favorite watch ...
... along with the 5296. I don't own either (yet) but maybe some day! Thanks for the great story and pictures. John
Beautiful watch!
Your post was very interesting to read. I owned the original 5107G and loved it due to the crown guards. Without the guards, the watch just wouldn't have the cool factor. Your dial didn't look bad enough to replace. Did you think it needed a new dial when...
Dial replacement
Great observation, and I should have been clearer. The picture of the old dial is perhaps around 8 years old. I could actually see the slight discoloration with the naked eye. Not sure why Patek recommended a full dial replacement instead of a refurbishme...
Thank you for sharing your experience! 👏👏👏
The 5127G is my all time favourite Calatrava. If it were still in production, I would seriously consider adding one to my collection. The size, the case shape, the dial... close to perfection IMO. I also love the crown guards. Enjoy it! In my book, it is ...
Great review, thanks for writing.
The 5127 is a wonderful Calatrava. Classic in styling, yet at 37mm, a bridge between classic and modern sizing. The curves of the case, and yes even the crown guards, are so sensual. It really is striking on the wrist, and oh so comfortable to wear. I rea...
Lettering color
Good eye there! I think it's just that the white balance is slightly off on the 60-dots picture, so it appears that the coloring is fainter and more beige than black. The font is a little thinner though.
Thanks w220 for this thorough and detailed review...
I'm slow to catch up tonight but I wanted to thank you for a great deal of valuable information about a truly fine watch! Best wishes.
One more variation
I believe there is one more variation of the 5127G. The early runs, like mine, had the case rhodium plated. If I recall correctly, the very latest runs of the 5127G were unplated, and hence had a case with a slightly more grayish appearance. To illustrate...
Thanks for the review
Hi I discovered the PP 5127G in Baselwolrd in 2005 or 2006, and I immediately felt in love. I have been reading and reading your review since 2 years. I finaly purchased one second hand from 2010 yesterday I'm looking forward to receiving it in the coming...
One of my favorite Calatravas!
Beautiful review of the 5127G! I knew about the 57/60 dot dial, but I didn't know that the dots were holes in the dial. I always liked the dots on the dial! The signature by both Sterns is even more amazing!
Thanks for the review of the 5127..
I actually had the 5107G.. but found it too small and I gave it to my wife.. I preferred the thicker bezel of the 5107G as I felt the date window lined up perfectly with the min dots (as the dial is a little abit smaller).. but with hindsight perhaps a th...
The 5107 and 5127 are both standard Calatravas perfect for everyday use. The bracelet types have different clasp mechanisms and bracelet link shapes.
The one on the left with the thicker bezel is the 5107 ...
I cannot see any discoloration
on the original dial. It is nice to know that they say the discoloration is caused by humidly. I have a 3796 with some discoloration around some minute markers and PP service said just leave as it is. Interesting they changed your dial out.