Mike7137
14
The magic of Patek Philippe...I like that!
In the Italian culture we love to make names smaller/younger to signify friendship, and in English that’s best achieved with the “y”. So, Shammy you made me think about what it is about PP compared to other great companies (non boutique) that evokes such passion. It brings to mind another great passion of mine, the opera. Puccini and Verdi, two absolute great composers of Italian opera. Puccini’s brilliance is very easily understood...I have never brought a date to La Boheme who hasn’t left moved at the very least. Now bringing the same date with zero opera exposure to Rigoletto, or La Traviata....far less of a response. Now I’m by no way saying that Puccini’s operas don’t have serious music substance because I’ve studied some of them from my classical musician upbringing and they have jaw dropping musical complexity. And not to say that Verdi doesn’t appeal to the uneducated masses because everybody and their mother knows two of the arias from both of the aforementioned operas. If you pressed me for the greatest of the two, I would say Verdi but for years I would’ve said Puccini because the genius of Verdi needs to be understood. This reminds me of say Breguet and Patek Philippe. The guilloche dial of a Breguet appeals to everyone. The craftsmanship is easy for the casual watch lover to understand. Now the basic Calatrava is a different story. 5196, for example....to the uninitiated, it looks like like a timex circa 1985. Stick dial, dauphine hands....could you get more boring? Ahh but go down to your local AD and compare it to a timex....well it’s like comparing a watch to something that has successfully captured a part of the sun in a 37mm case. And that’s just the basic Calatrava....the London Limited that you own...Christ!! And we need not mention the movements themselves. I was going to ask your opinion on something, even though I probably know the answer but I got carried away as usual so I’ll make a separate post.
Apologies to the Timex folks!
Available on the marketplace
2,850 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1721 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
Dear Mike
By: sham1 : June 11th, 2018-00:49
As you correctly say, they are two different watches and you need to ask yourself which watch appeals to you more on emotional grounds. For me, it does not really matter that the 5396 is in current production and the more complex offering because I would ...
Very Impressive
By: Mike7137 : June 13th, 2018-13:40
Shammy, those really are some exquisite timepieces and not exactly the sort that one just strolls down to the local AD to purchase! As I mentioned, I love Breguet numerals....and I think they look keenest on PP actually. But this Limited London edition ta...
Hi Mike!
By: sham1 : June 13th, 2018-21:30
I was tickled that you called me Shammy!!! Only one other person has ever called me that and she was an ex lover who I just spoke to last night coincidentally! You are being too modest in your analogy of my 7200R against your 5010. Yes, admittedly gondolo...
I can tell
By: sham1 : June 15th, 2018-12:25
that unlike me you are an exponent of all things relating to the opera, I salute you Mike! Current Breguet watches excel with their guilloche and enamel dials and I only wish their movements were less industrial and the lugs were not so straight making th...
Comparison
By: Mike7137 : June 15th, 2018-15:51
I was actually looking at the different 5010 models and I actually payed attention to this one. You were 100% correct in saying that the Roman numeral variety is very rare which would also make it hard to find, even harder to find in pink gold which would...
I too prefer
By: sham1 : June 15th, 2018-18:02
rose to yellow gold but I believe the 5010 with roman numerals is pretty difficult to find in rose gold. As you noticed, there is one in the market in yellow gold. The 5010 with baton markers is a handsome watch, it is all down to personal preference and ...
Great Point
By: Mike7137 : June 11th, 2018-22:31
I hadn't even thought to see if I could try it on now that so many years have passed. I understand about gauging the emotional response but since it is small and unfortunately I currently about 20 lbs heavier it may look like a ladies watch now!!!! Thank ...
Counterintuitive
By: Mike7137 : June 12th, 2018-16:11
Sounds funny but I never actually thought about that. 5396 has significantly more complications but it is not as dressy as the gondolo. I always associate Breguet numerals on PPs with uber dressy timepieces so I guess I might not have ever noticed. Thank ...