WatchProSite|Market|Digest

Automotive

Hmmm... I'm mostly familiar with the 996/997 generation. Sports cars need double wishbone suspension.

 

I realized I'm not a Porsche 911 driver...  I used to track 911s and I was just terrible.  I could never hit the gas early just before the apex.  As this is very counter-intuitive (why am I going to hit the accelerator while still turning deeper into the turn).  The car would also be so prone to spinning due to not having enough weight in the back.  So I was complaining to my technician, and then I started to try to align the car in different ways, and I was still not getting the performance I needed.  Then, one day, I drove a Lamborghini Huracan.  The car was so easy to drive!  The contact of the tires was so good!  And then I realized!  MacPherson Strut really is inferior!  One really needs to have a double wishbone suspension to be able to articulate the tire in on camber and off camber corners.  Furthermore, the mid engine also meant I wouldn't spin out anymore.  And the Lamborghini also drove more intuitively.  


I then realized...  Porsches are generally bought by people who really don't know what they're doing (like I was totally not knowing what I was doing at the time) and it really an illogical car (rear engine is totally illogical) and in terms of suspension set up, the lack of a double wishbone suspension really meant a Porsche had no grip on any off-camber corners.  Sure.  Porsche 911s have a HUGE AMOUNT of camber baked into the alignment so the tires really dig into the ground.  Porsche 911s also have very wide tires so even though only a small percentage of the tire is in contact with the ground, considering it's so big of a tire, your still having some tire touching the ground at all times.  

I've spun over a dozen times in a 911.  It's embarrassing.  And fortunately, the yellow and sometimes red flags always promptly started to wave for me and nobody ever hit the side of the car with me still in it.  But it's definitely not a good feeling.  A little down in the pride, some danger, and you're wondering what you did wrong...

I know you're a Porsche lover.  And I used to be a Porsche lover.  My most prized possession when I was in grade school was a Porsche 911 brochure (993 generation) that my teacher gave me (she liked Porsches and drove a Mazda RX7).  I grew up thinking Porsches were the best.  Determined to drive a Porsche!  But driving the 996 and 997 generation cars that were really prone to spinning was an eye opener.  I realized that I just wasn't a Porsche guy.  Then after talking to the alignment guy and he explained to me why I wasn't getting grip in certain corners on a specific track, that's when I realized the Porsche 911 really has a very basic MacPherson Strut suspension that can't articulate the wheel to maximize the tire contact patch.  

My Porsche love started to wane.  Then I drove the Lamborghini Aventador in 2012.  Wow.  So much poise.  Balance.  Grip.  Power.  And SO EASY TO DRIVE.  And supposedly they were reliable too!  Too bad it was so showy.  And a little wide.  And then I drove the 991 generation 911 in 2012.  The car was so big.  So comfortable.  And so easy to drive!  The car wouldn't spin.  I would later drive the car on the track and boy, the computers caught me every time before I could spin the car.  Even if I did something silly, the car wouldn't spin.  My biggest complaint was alleviated!  The car was safer and so much easier to drive...  But...  The lack of a double wishbone suspension still bothered me.  I would never get enough mechanical grip in off camber corners.  

www.watchprosite.com


Today...  The GT3 now has a double wishbone suspension.  And it also has the computers to prevent me from spinning.  I'd feel good in it, it's safe, reliable, comfortable, and quiet.  But I also drove the Lamborghini Huracan in 2014, thanks to another member on WPS.  And while the Huracan isn't perfect...  Steering isn't perfect.  Visibility is horrible.  It's quiet, but not as quiet as a Porsche GT3 Touring...  But the Lamborghini is so emotional.  It's even easier to drive than the Porsche too!  Much more grip in on-camber and off-camber corners too thanks to the double wishbone suspension.  And the Huracan is very reliable!  I realized I was buying a Porsche for the name.  For the brand reputation.  And I didn't really understand the product.  And I didn't really understand the mechanics.  I learned so much talking to the mechs and techs in the pits.  And I realize I was a total plebeian.  So that's why I research and analyze everything I buy now.  Watches.  Cars.  Clothes!  Even wine!  

  login to reply