Gary G
3734
Photo comparo -- 5070, 5270, and 5970
All that I can say is that it is good to have friends! Especially good friends who put up with one's quirks during watch-related trips, and then to top it off provide great watches for photo shoots.
A Gentleman Purist handed off these three watches to me yesterday, with the following instructions:
1. Photograph them, and in particular try to get some comparisons of the 5970 and 5270
2. Wear them a bit, but not in the hot tub!
I was pleased to comply on both fronts, and with gratitude to my good pal, here are some photos of these three great pieces. Let's start with the 5070P. Not an easy watch to photograph, especially if you are trying to get a good rendering of that fantastic dial color, but I think this first shot is quite close:
From a different angle, with slightly different light...
And now on to the movement side
Having warmed up with the 5070, I tried my luck with the 5970. For me, this one is the most "classic" of the three, and lent itself quite easily to having its portrait taken:
On to the back. Maybe it's just the more sophisticated finishing of the case back, or not, but the effect of the back of this watch was much more appealing to me than on the otherwise similar 5070. Suffice it to say I'm not complaining about either!
Now on the the newest joiner, the 5270. Really clean looking (and as a result, a bit less classic looking to me), but beautiful in its own right. The brighter dial (relative to the 5970) made this one a bit more difficult to capture -- dozens of "reject" photos in this batch!
I wouldn't swear to it, but to my eye at least this movement looked to be better finished than the other two. There are also the technological advancements in this movement to admire (instantaneously jumping chrono minutes, etc.) but the best thing for photography is that this movement hacks
Time for some face-to-face comparisons! At the end of the day I think it just comes down to what looks good to your eye and on your wrist -- both of these pieces are beautifully executed, in my opinion
In person, the difference in dial color and finish is pretty much as it appears in the photos...
Movement side! Again, no complaints
And to wrap up, a quick shot of all three together. What a treat for me!
Over the next few hours, I did (carefully) wear each of these pieces. The 5070 got the most wrist time -- the heft of the PT case makes it feel great on the wrist, and I love the dial color. The 5970 was a privilege to have on my wrist, but I felt I was under-dressed (it would be an absolute killer business watch for me, to be sure). From a wearability standpoint, I can see why someone would move from the 5970 to the more "modern/casual" look of the 5270, but I think if the PP fairy were to leave one under my pillow, I'd be wishing for the 5970.
Hope you enjoyed! I did take some wrist shots, which I will append in a second post.
Best,
Gary G
Photo comparo -- 5070, 5270, and 5970
All that I can say is that it is good to have friends! Especially good friends who put up with one's quirks during watch-related trips, and then to top it off provide great watches for photo shoots. A Gentleman Purist handed off these three watches to me ...
Second try on one photo
The uploader seems to have flipped one of the shots in the original post -- let's try again... Hope that's better! Best, Gary G...
to me, the 5070 is the clear winner in terms of coolness.
And the 5970 G is terms of elegance. There is something in between the 5070 P and the 5970 G: The 5970 P. I would have hard time to decide which of the two " P " I prefer. If only the 5270 didn't have these 2 small portholes... Best, and thanks for the ph...
Agree
The 5270 just does not have the balance of classical Patek.... you want to love it, but... you have to be a Patek diehard I think to love it. Thank you Gary for stunning, incredible photos. And that photo of you, stunned from receiving your Dufour, really...
No doubt it will find its fans... But I am more attracted to the 5970P.
A matter of taste... Best, Mostel. Nicolas
Pleased to give you an opportunity
...to share your impressions -- they are, as always, edifying! Best, Gary G
And now a few wrist shots
As some of you may know, wrist shots are not really my thing -- but I gave it the old college try with these 3 pieces! I hope these give some impression of what the watches look like in actual use... Best, Gary G...
Beautiful shots !
Makes me appreciate the Patek 5970 and 5270 even more. Thanks for sharing !
Splendid pics ! A great pleasure...
Stop shooting these Patek, you're making me crazy ;-)
But happy craziness, no?
The treat for me is that even though I won't own these watches, I had the chance to handle and wear them through the generosity of my friend. Great fun! Best, Gary
Lovely photographs and exquisite watches are such a nice combination.
I must be getting older because lately PPs are more and more luscious to me, particularly when someone as talented as you photographs them, Gary. In terms of preference, I have to agree with my esteemed colleague of the French persuasion. 5070, 5970 then ...
You are very kind, Jed
Sorry for the delay in responding -- my day job is getting in the way of my hobby I don't want to set off a firestorm, but the word "sterile" is one that comes to mind for me with regard to a lot of PP watches. Cleanly executed and of high quality, but pe...
Thanks a lot
Hi Gary, What an experience you had! Thanks a lot for sharing with us. I definitely have to spend some time with a 5270 on my wrist to make an opinion on this one. Best Dje ps: I love them all but I'm still a fan of the 5170! This message has been edited ...
My pleasure, Jerome
This was great fun for me! As I said, it was the 5070 that found its way onto my wrist -- and I could imagine that one getting a lot of wrist time if I were ever so fortunate to own it. Best, Gary
Gary, you have struck again!
What a pleasure to open your post this Sunday morning. This is the best comparison I have seen of these modern Patek chronos. Your photos capture their essence. Perhaps the 5970 with more old-school charm and imperfection, and the 5270 with more new-schoo...
I have learned a lot from your post!
Clearly there is a lot for me to learn about these watches -- you have pointed out many of the fine points that my casual inspection (and lack of deep knowledge of PP) missed. Very interesting to learn about the absence of an "advance all" pusher on the n...
Incredible comparison shots Gary!
Thank you for sharing these three stunners. The 5270 is really growing on me. It's like the new 458 vs. 430 or the Aventador vs. Murcielago etc... I'm so familiar with the 5970 and have been enjoying it's beauty for so long that it's had to take time to w...
458 vs 430
I agree with you that it sometimes takes a bit of time for the "shock of the new" to die down and for us to appreciate fresh new styling. It will be interesting to see how time judges the 5270 as an update! Thanks very much for your kind words on my photo...
Wow thanks a lot Gary !
Especially for the wristshots, they give the best impression you can have of a watch imho. I didn't have the luck to try the 5270 but I remeber quite well the 5970G and the 5070P. At first for me the 5070 even with all his "mistakes" is the best of three....
Great pics
5070p wins for me in terms of overall wearability. 5970 in terms of classic look. 5270 face is still a tad off centered for me but that movement is spectacular.
Exquisite pictures Gary....
I wish I have your skills....better yet...all those timepieces Best Sam
Sam, we both wish...
...that we had those watches! Who needs photos when you can look at your wrist? Best, Gary
Well if the day job becomes tiresome
..you can photograph some of my watches gladly! Awesome job? On the positive side I would echo all the comments made, and not repeat them. The 29mm new movement is a winner visually over the 27mm, no doubt in my mind. The case-back view gives better balan...
I will happily photograph your great pieces anytime!
...and you know that I mean it! Very interested to read your impressions on these pieces -- and I agree that we should return to this comparison in a few years to see if we are all saying by that time that the 5970 seems quaint... Best, Gary G
Thanks Gary for your report.........
I do believe that this must be the 3rd or 4th time that I have said thank you Gary Your reports have been outstanding and this one is no exception. I honestly don't know which out of the 5970G or 5720G I would have..............If the option ever arose LO...
I will ask my friend to buy one right away!
More seriously, I'd be more than pleased to do some photo work with one if there are any volunteers -- or would love to see a comparo from someone else that includes this watch... Best, Gary G
no losers here....
The 5970 has such great balance....it is such an elegant watch. If i was at a crucial business meeting (which I never am), and wanted a classy watch to wear with my suit, then I'd choose a vintage Rolex (LoL)....but in the absence of the Rolly, I'd choose...
ROFL! Excellent and very true description of the 5070!
I think you perfectly put in words all the reasons which make me love it. Bravo! Nicolas
Pizza Express
...indeed! The 5070 is absolutely a Silicon Valley jeans and blazer sort of watch... Best, Gary
As usual, amazing pitcures Gary
It is quite impossible to capture the real sheen of a watch, but you came perfectly through this here. I must say I have quite clear druthers for the 5070. You have spent a day like a kid in a candy shop ! Thanks for sharing. Best, Mark
Thanks, Mark
Every time I have a chance to work with my friends' watches, I am deeply grateful, for sure! Best, Gary
Garry.....WOW, WOW and WOW...your Camera work is Exquisite......
So is your taste in Wristwatches my friend.......Only one clear winner for me though????? Regards Miles.
Thank you very much, Miles! But...
...which is the clear winner for you? Best, Gary G
WOW!!!
what an awesome collection!!! thanks for the excellent pictures of these magnificent watches!!
I was very grateful
...for the loan of these pieces from my friend, who has a stunning collection of Patek, Lange, independents, and other brands as well. The great news for me is that some of my good friends allow me to photograph their watches to chronicle their collection...