WatchProSite
|
Market
|
Digest
WatchProSite
|
Market
|
Digest
Market
Digest
About us
Moderator Team
Terms of conduct
Privacy Policy
Contact us
Patron Circle
Sponsorship/Advertising
Patek Philippe
Search all forums
Only threads
With images
amanico
[JLC Moderator]
401550
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
A keeper, for sure.
Oct 21, 2025,09:17 AM -
39 comments
-
X
login to reply
39 Comments
view entire thread
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
For the pleasure of the eyes: Patek Philippe 5131J/G/R/P ( from left to right ).
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-14:16
My favorite dial would be the J, followed very closely by the G. My favorite metal? The P followed closely by the G. You? Best, Nicolas ...
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Very tough choice: I just can't decide which I prefer here...
By: quattro : October 20th, 2025-14:31
So much beauty in each of them.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I totally understand that!
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:51
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
The perfect combination would have been J dial in platinum on a leather strap
By: ImranLondon : October 20th, 2025-14:57
The platinum bracelet was completely unnecessary. The north pole was only loved by Greta.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I am totally with you!
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:51
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
+1
By: agyzace : October 20th, 2025-19:09
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J or R with these dials methinks.
By: bruckner4 : October 20th, 2025-15:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J is spectacular.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:51
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Yes, wonderful contrast.
By: bruckner4 : October 20th, 2025-16:05
J it is! Now, securing the funds…
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Not the easiest... ;)
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:24
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
The first one, J and dial, without the crown guard and without the brand inscribed on the bezel. I owned a 5110R but sold it. It didn’t keep time well and the lever button on the left was wobbly.
By: Besançon : October 20th, 2025-15:24
I had bought the watch new from an authorized dealer. I didn’t like the crown guard either. 🤷🏻♂️
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
One for J.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:53
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J in RG would be great!
By: penfriend : October 20th, 2025-15:43
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Thank you, my friend. That's crazy that we prefer our combinations rather than the watches offered. ;)
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:53
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I appreciate the cooler dial on the cooler metal
By: htinoco : October 20th, 2025-15:47
... but my choice would be J. A good excuse to aspire for both? Haha
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Hehehe! 2 for J.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:53
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Dial and case...J
By: mdg : October 20th, 2025-15:54
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
And a third vote for the J.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:15
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
According to Google, the 5131J debuted in 2008, the 5131G in 2009, the 5131R in 2014, and the 5131/1P in 2017. To my eye, it is striking how much the detail of the enamel work improved over that time.
By: frequentglobetrotter : October 20th, 2025-16:01
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
So your vote goes to the P?
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:15
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Good question: 1. 5131R; 2. 5131/1P; 3. 5131G; and 4. 5131J. I do like the 5131/1P, but ultimately the bracelet is quite prominent given its fully polished style. That might have the 5131R pip it to the post for me. But it is a very close call!
By: frequentglobetrotter : October 20th, 2025-16:22
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
But you can put a strap on the 5131P, no? ;) 2 for the J one for the R.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:30
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I concur. I would go by map first!
By: patrick_y : October 20th, 2025-16:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I understand that very well. The one of the J is so tempting.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:30
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Good post Nicolas ! I like best the
By: GLau : October 20th, 2025-17:15
all four of them ! Each has a special meaning to me. G & P were produced by Anita Porchet and her team. R has the most meaningful map to me, whereas J was my first love when it came out.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
All of them is the way to go. ;)
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-19:18
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Please count
By: GLau : October 22nd, 2025-09:42
1 vote for each metal !
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Ha! :))))
By: amanico : October 22nd, 2025-10:50
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
G dial and P metal, mon ami 😊
By: joenghenry : October 20th, 2025-17:18
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Yeees!
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-19:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J in this case
By: agyzace : October 20th, 2025-19:10
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
3 for the J 1 for the R, then.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-19:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I’m with you. I prefer the dial of J, but I also prefer the white metal cases. There enamel world times are extremely tempting. It probably just a matter of the right timing for me.
By: emcquillan : October 21st, 2025-04:08
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I have the same issue than yours. ;)
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-05:54
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
This one...
By: Goh : October 21st, 2025-08:31
...
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Still with you? 3 for the J, 1 for the R and 1 for the G, now.
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-08:38
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Yes.
By: Goh : October 21st, 2025-09:07
Still keeping this.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
A keeper, for sure.
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-09:17
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I would go for G
By: yming : October 21st, 2025-09:35
But am not a big fan of the logo on the bezel
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
3 J / 2G and one for the R, now.
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-15:10
login to reply
Cancel
Options
Watermark images
Black
White
Red
Green
Blue
Gray
Light Gray
Display images as:
large images
normal images
small images
thumbnail images
Place caption text:
after images
before images
Done
Search
Done
Upload
Image Uploader
Click to pick or
drag images here