WatchProSite
|
Market
|
Digest
WatchProSite
|
Market
|
Digest
Market
Digest
About us
Moderator Team
Terms of conduct
Privacy Policy
Contact us
Patron Circle
Sponsorship/Advertising
Patek Philippe
Search all forums
Only threads
With images
ImranLondon
[PuristSPro Moderator]
6312
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
The perfect combination would have been J dial in platinum on a leather strap
Oct 20, 2025,14:57 PM -
39 comments
-
X
The platinum bracelet was completely unnecessary. The north pole was only loved by Greta.
login to reply
39 Comments
view entire thread
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
For the pleasure of the eyes: Patek Philippe 5131J/G/R/P ( from left to right ).
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-14:16
My favorite dial would be the J, followed very closely by the G. My favorite metal? The P followed closely by the G. You? Best, Nicolas ...
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Very tough choice: I just can't decide which I prefer here...
By: quattro : October 20th, 2025-14:31
So much beauty in each of them.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I totally understand that!
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:51
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
The perfect combination would have been J dial in platinum on a leather strap
By: ImranLondon : October 20th, 2025-14:57
The platinum bracelet was completely unnecessary. The north pole was only loved by Greta.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I am totally with you!
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:51
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
+1
By: agyzace : October 20th, 2025-19:09
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J or R with these dials methinks.
By: bruckner4 : October 20th, 2025-15:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J is spectacular.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:51
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Yes, wonderful contrast.
By: bruckner4 : October 20th, 2025-16:05
J it is! Now, securing the funds…
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Not the easiest... ;)
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:24
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
The first one, J and dial, without the crown guard and without the brand inscribed on the bezel. I owned a 5110R but sold it. It didn’t keep time well and the lever button on the left was wobbly.
By: Besançon : October 20th, 2025-15:24
I had bought the watch new from an authorized dealer. I didn’t like the crown guard either. 🤷🏻♂️
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
One for J.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:53
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J in RG would be great!
By: penfriend : October 20th, 2025-15:43
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Thank you, my friend. That's crazy that we prefer our combinations rather than the watches offered. ;)
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:53
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I appreciate the cooler dial on the cooler metal
By: htinoco : October 20th, 2025-15:47
... but my choice would be J. A good excuse to aspire for both? Haha
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Hehehe! 2 for J.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-15:53
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Dial and case...J
By: mdg : October 20th, 2025-15:54
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
And a third vote for the J.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:15
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
According to Google, the 5131J debuted in 2008, the 5131G in 2009, the 5131R in 2014, and the 5131/1P in 2017. To my eye, it is striking how much the detail of the enamel work improved over that time.
By: frequentglobetrotter : October 20th, 2025-16:01
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
So your vote goes to the P?
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:15
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Good question: 1. 5131R; 2. 5131/1P; 3. 5131G; and 4. 5131J. I do like the 5131/1P, but ultimately the bracelet is quite prominent given its fully polished style. That might have the 5131R pip it to the post for me. But it is a very close call!
By: frequentglobetrotter : October 20th, 2025-16:22
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
But you can put a strap on the 5131P, no? ;) 2 for the J one for the R.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:30
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I concur. I would go by map first!
By: patrick_y : October 20th, 2025-16:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I understand that very well. The one of the J is so tempting.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-16:30
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Good post Nicolas ! I like best the
By: GLau : October 20th, 2025-17:15
all four of them ! Each has a special meaning to me. G & P were produced by Anita Porchet and her team. R has the most meaningful map to me, whereas J was my first love when it came out.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
All of them is the way to go. ;)
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-19:18
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Please count
By: GLau : October 22nd, 2025-09:42
1 vote for each metal !
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Ha! :))))
By: amanico : October 22nd, 2025-10:50
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
G dial and P metal, mon ami 😊
By: joenghenry : October 20th, 2025-17:18
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Yeees!
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-19:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
J in this case
By: agyzace : October 20th, 2025-19:10
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
3 for the J 1 for the R, then.
By: amanico : October 20th, 2025-19:19
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I’m with you. I prefer the dial of J, but I also prefer the white metal cases. There enamel world times are extremely tempting. It probably just a matter of the right timing for me.
By: emcquillan : October 21st, 2025-04:08
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I have the same issue than yours. ;)
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-05:54
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
This one...
By: Goh : October 21st, 2025-08:31
...
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Still with you? 3 for the J, 1 for the R and 1 for the G, now.
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-08:38
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
Yes.
By: Goh : October 21st, 2025-09:07
Still keeping this.
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
A keeper, for sure.
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-09:17
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
I would go for G
By: yming : October 21st, 2025-09:35
But am not a big fan of the logo on the bezel
login to reply
Show profile
Show other posts
Send PM
3 J / 2G and one for the R, now.
By: amanico : October 21st, 2025-15:10
login to reply
Cancel
Options
Watermark images
Black
White
Red
Green
Blue
Gray
Light Gray
Display images as:
large images
normal images
small images
thumbnail images
Place caption text:
after images
before images
Done
Search
Done
Upload
Image Uploader
Click to pick or
drag images here