quattro
[Moderator]
20491
Indeed. None of the two is for me, but I probably like the design of the JLC a little better.
The new Calatrava Minute Repeater
Thanks to Julien Dubois aka @chefs_d_oeuvre_horlogers, we finally have real photos of the latest Minute Repeater from Patek Philippe : the reference 7047G-001 . The modern design features a 38 x 10.24 mm white gold case and a navy blue dial distinguished ...
My pleasure, Henry.
This style doesn't speak to me, but the execution seems well done. Best, Emmanuel
What a beautiful watch.
I can do without the orange though. Would prefer something a little more muted in color. Not sure what color to replace the orange with right now though😁
I'm sure the orange looks more subdued in real life.
Photos tend to accentuate colors and renders even more. Best, Emmanuel
I do not necessarily like movements where the balance wheel is obstructed
So it would be an absolute no from me. But I agree that the watch in his whole is coherent in style (for the ones that like this sporty style) Dirk
I'm with you concerning the obstructed balance wheel, Dirk.
That said, the rotor moves and does not obstruct it always. Best, Emmanuel ...
Interesting, quattro...
But not the PP repeater I'd choose if I had the means. I'm sure it sounds fantastic. Actually been wearing one of its silent forebears lately.. ...
10.24 thickness is quite amazing...
...as my 'beef' with Patek is that they seem to not care about slim watches these days. My friend has the regular Calatrava version and it is a joy to wear. But at this price (more than half a million), the dial should not be stamped (if this one is)...
I think it is, and very explicitly so, "embossed" standing for stamped.
And there isn't any mention of guillochage, afaik.
I'm not saying they are hiding anything...
...I just think at $500,000+ they might have used real guilloche...
When PP takes it inspiration from JLC! 😁
They had to find a master in modern automotive design!
Hi Emmanuel, This "spiced" up MR was totally unexpected for many collectors. I have heard
polarizing comments which can be understood and appreciated. I see both sides of the coin. For me, this design is consistent with Patek's strategy of drawing in younger collectors and this piece has accomplished the objective because it is unlike any othe...
Yes...great comments. They are going for younger and sportier...
...also this is a very stealthy watch...
What you say makes a lot of sense, Gordon.
And I agree with you, except for the fact that this aesthetic doesn't appeal to me personally. But I know it's just me! ☺️ Best, Emmanuel
Not a big fan of the aesthetic. Not to criticize. Amazing movement though.
Not a big fan of this dial design. I'm not criticizing the design. But this design and the Patek 6007 have never been great designs in my eyes... I've always said regarding the 6007, "if they took the Patek Philippe logo off the dial of the 6007, would pe...
The brand name and "aura" probably plays an important role, yes.
What I personally don't respond to at all is the carbon fibre motif. But I know others like it and like the automotive inspiration. It just doesn't resonate with me. Best, Emmanuel
I concur. Carbon Fiber is supposed to be about function not form.
But all these car companies have turned it into automotive jewelry - and the jewelry and watch companies have capitalized upon it. Not a great concept in my eyes. Ferrari puts carbon fiber interior trim all over the inside of the car and charges a fortune...
I think that's exactly what they've tried to make.
And quite successfully, it seems. Best, Emmanuel
Fascinating!
A truly fascinating reference. A modern Calatrava masterpiece, if there ever was one. R
Modern indeed. And well done.
One just needs to find the required funds! ;-) Best, Emmanuel
I actually like this
It is more sporty and more likely to be worn. I’d probably use different colors, but it’s fun for sure.
I actually like it a lot!
It does give off a sporty vibe while featuring a truly impressive and classical movement. I think the combination works well. That said, for a tenth of the price, I like this more subtle version with a far simpler movement . . . ...
I agree that your version is more subtle, Bob. Thanks for sharing, great pic!
I covered the whole 500/600 line here: www.watchprosite.com Best, Emmanuel
Conceptually I like the idea of a stealthy complication.
But as often with modern PP execution is really lacking. They had to introduce a lot of refinements for it to make sense. Obviously not a stamped dial, a real embarrassment at this price point. Hands are basic and also simply stamped, more suited to a $50...
I really had a flash on it at first glance,
unfortunately my bank account is not big enough 😂…
Well, few bank accounts are big enough, unfortunately! 🤪
So, at least you're not alone! 🤩 Best, Emmanuel
The best repeater since 5078: it is a triumph.
Best 6007 design, too at the same time. Never liked the 6007 A, the 6007 G a lot, but this one is the perfect design. This repeater demonstrates great life style, celebrates lightness and beauty of life. A dream piece on par with a 5078 R.
I like your enthusiasm, Count!
I personally feel more attracted to the 5078, but I understand the appeal of this new 7047G. And because of the absence of a date window, it is indeed a wonderful variant of the 6007 design. Best, Emmanuel
I am not a fan of this case
I find the lugs to be too wide, making the watch look squarish But I do think it’s a good idea to make sportier min repeaters, but it needs to be somewhat water resistant