Baron - Mr Red
14613
The thing is Volker....
.....its a personal issue.....each of us will have a different ranking of our top dogs. It would be strange if we all had the same....so i can easily see why many would prefer the 5370P as the top dog......or the 5131P....... but for me, there is something that occurs when a watch is on my wrist that just cannot be equated to a paper analysis. On paper, maybe the 5650 shouldn't be up there....in reality it is. I have collected now for many years, so have come to recognise how watches make me feel when I start wearing them...the 5650 does something extra.
Viva la difference....but for me, this is a very interesting and quite special watch.
Patek Philippe 5650G - 3 weeks on the wrist
It arrived just over three weeks ago. Sometimes, when one takes delivery of a new watch, one gets a feeling immediately when one puts the watch on the wrist. That feeling can vary a lot. Sometimes it is intense and sometimes quite flat. Over the years, I ...
Quite interesting to see that you placed the 5650G that high up
and after 3 weeks, you cannot blame the "new factor" anymore, so there is something very special in this watch that makes you fall for it, despite all the other choices you have. CC
Great pics and I am happy you are enjoying your new toy.
But I think your top 5 might change once you break in the Dato.
OK.
But I think the 5070 may be in trouble, if you give the challenger a real chance. In any case, I have no problem losing (well, I usually do, but not this time).
Wow Such a strong affinity already
Great that the watch is such a massive hit with you Julian
Great feeling to have such a passion for a watch. Congratulations on the acquisition and its easily meeting your expectations!
The fact that it is your favorite modern Patek, above the exceptional: 5370P, 5131P, 5070P and 5970P is quite an endorsement of the 5650G. Extremely interesting and a bit surprising, at least to me. Perhaps had I succeeded in my efforts to acquire one, th...
Joe, I have to hire a professional photographer to much the quality of your pictures ;-)
Enjoy your piece Best G.
i was once told.....
.....that my pictures would make Claudia Schiffer look ugly. I decided to take some lessons!!
it does help....
..... but a monkey in front of a typewriter still produces gibberish.
Joe, great to see that you are so enthusiastic about 5650G.
Your order is a little bit surprising though. 1st place easily agreed. But then you loose me. I would rank 5131P and 5370P higher than 5650G, at least on the paper. Let's wait and see what your feelings are once you have 5131P on your wrist. This will be ...
The thing is Volker....
.....its a personal issue.....each of us will have a different ranking of our top dogs. It would be strange if we all had the same....so i can easily see why many would prefer the 5370P as the top dog......or the 5131P....... but for me, there is somethin...
Of course, it's a personal issue.
And I'm not saying that 5650G shouldn't be in that spot. It's a super watch I would love to own, no doubt. I was just a little bit surprised by your order (and still are 😳).
to be honest....
....i am also surprised. When I first decided to buy it, I knew it was a special watch but I didn't think it was Top 5 material. What has surprised me is how I have reacted to it on my wrist. Of course, I still haven't had the 5131P on my wrist so the ver...
Really interesting to read your feeling about this timepiece and how it grew with (few) time
Interesting too to know that your top five is a Patek straight flush. May be the Dato will disrupt your ranking soon 😉 Best wishes Alkiro
not so....
.....this is my Top 5 for Patek. Overall Top 5 would include vintage Rolex.....and am afraid that the Datograph would not make Top 10 overall. Its a lovely watch...iconic....beautiful movement, but it doesn't scale the heights of the Top 5 from Patek....a...
to be fair....
....i need to put mine on my wrist for a bit to get a better feeling for why. But it speaks volumes to me that I still haven't put it on....5650G effect
Glad to see that you've been enjoying it so much.
I'm sure this is not just the honeymoon period. It must be the beginning of a love affair.
if the watch gods.....
.....sent me a message today saying...OK, you lose the lot, but you can keep your dad's old watch and the 5650g..... i would be good with that...
So in fact his is a very elaborate way of telling us you won't need your Dato?
If you need someone to wear the Dato for you for a while I could be persuaded taking this burden off your shoulders... Joking aside; Very nice pics of the 5650! Your posts are starting to change my mind a little about Aquanaut series in general...
Arie.....
.....first......I have to give the Dato the benefit of the doubt. Its been pooled againt a watch that virtually all of mine would suffer in comparison. So, i do see that i need to allow some proper wrist time and genuinely look at the Datograph in its own...
From the day I saw it, I knew it was a "huge" watch
We discussed quickly about it back then and I expressed how it pleased me, on every levels. This is a true bargain for what it offers and I know this would have been my everyday wearer if I could have gotten one. I'm glad when such watches go to owners wh...
as an everyday watch....
......this is exactly how i see wearing it. Not so easy to wear formally of course....but casually its perfect...and actually fills a big hole in my collection on Patek sporty.
Time has gone by
and you still love it. In fact, you are having a hard time taking it off. While I am quite sure that that frantic desire to wear only this one watch will dissipate there is no question you have found a new piece that will be with you-joyfully-for a very l...
You must really love this watch Joe!
For you to place it above the 5370P says it all. I actually tried Kamal Rostov's 5164A a few nights ago and was surprised how well it fitted on my wrist. I had tried the same model years ago and it was too large (and my wrist has definitely not grown! ) I...
The box is a nice touch
I think there are four on the forum with this watch and, interestingly, the response is similar from each. Kari and Keks
6 on here out of an issue of 500.
Almost a common watch on this forum! Its quite funny how this forum can so often create an illusion of "common". In the wild, I rarely ever see a standard Nautilus....maybe once or twice ever. Yet, on this forum, its like everyone and their dog owns one!
Hehe, absolutely true, Joe.
Another good example is 5131R. So many around here. Best, Volker
So very happy to read this post....
and sense I am not the only one to enjoy this piece to this extent. So far at the moment m I am considering not keeping much of what is otherwise in my humble collection.... but will wait a bit and see if the honeymoon wears off in due time. It has certai...
Would either of you have predicted this sort of unanimous, exceeds-expectations reaction when the 5650 was first unveiled? Personally, I distinctly recall my own luke-warm, rather muted response.
Adding it to my collection required some serious consideration. And yet, while the marriage is still quite fresh, the watch elicits an emotional reaction from me far more powerful than that of some other pieces which were meaningfully easier purchase deci...
Completely.
In fact it took me two weeks after Basel before I spoke to my AD requesting one. At Basel, I was obsessed with the 5131p. It was all I could see. After Basel, I slowly started to see other watches and “woke up” to the 5650g. Once I paid attention, I reali...
Personally....
the moment it was revealed in a press release I immediately contacted my AD expressing my interest in acquiring one. It must have been within the hour of the release. To me the idea of an AR release cased in a sporty watch from Patek was a homerun. Especi...
Amazing post Joe ! I knew 5650 was quite high in your ranking and...
...your last post about it explaining the reasons why was crystal clear. But to that extent I would not have expected ! That says it all about your feeling about it. Your pics are top cool and I agree that must be a great daily wearer ! But like many othe...
it was one of your grails that you waited long enough, so I am not astonished that you enjoy it this much, maybe it will be your daily wearer for a year if not more
Anyway congrats on the ownership and wear it in best of health Best regards Georges
Fantastic lighting on the dial
Shows the shades of watch itself I believe it stupendous it ticks a lot of boxes for me,Sporty,light,movement,Water resistance,Cool being limited is sprinkle on the cake as well Enjoy it yo the max Joe in the best of health. Best, Ahmed
Hi Joe, glad that you determined the "terminator" as one of your top 3 watches !
It is funny to know that you were quite hesitant and might not have ordered it! You must have had a horological angel (wearing a Patek advanced research reference) watching over you ! LOL ! Would love to hear your comments regarding the terminator vs 5131...
That will need to wait until next year for delivery....
......but I am looking forward to that too!
If you do not mind, I predict that between 5650G and 5131P, your higher ranking would go to ...
5650 ! Although you would adore the enamel dial and love the heft of the 5131P, you would still prefer the Terminator because of its innovative technologies. Shall we have another bet on my prediction ?
Yeah.....
.....i am going to bet that you will be right. So i guess I will win this bet. That makes us 1 on 1. I have some experience with the 5131s, so I have some idea what to expect. HAGWE!!!
Glad you will win which means you will need to...
come to Asia so that I will buy you McDonald's and KFC but unfortunately no milk shake !
You can have any the shake you want if you can help me get a...
Terminator at retail price !
Uhmmm
I can navigate but cannot perform miracles. Take a look at the regular Aquanaut... the novelty with blue dial. It’s superb. Also, I think it’s a good bet that 2018 will see something quite special with the new movement. I think I was very very lucky to ge...
You made your own luck on the 5650 ! I do really like the ...
new aquanaut with the blue dial ! The big issue I have with this reference is that it only comes in white gold instead of steel which IMO is more suitable for a sporty watch.
i hear you Joe...
... the feeling of being caught by surprise as you did is fantastic, this is when the real magic happens. After years of collecting and loving watches, we think we are starting to master our taste, knowing what we like and what we don't, where we are head...
Joe, I understand you 100%.
Just landed this morning from Singapore wearing my 5650G. A great travel watch, a great watch with business clothing and it also felt well in the pool. Tomorrow at 04:30 taxi will take me to the airport and I'll fly to London. For sure I will wear 5650G. ...
Kari....
.....for sure there are finer watches, but you said it well....5650 is SO easy to wear....and ticks so many boxes. regarding your last comment....evolution.
actually....
.....the catalyst was when i did some research on the radiation used on the vintage Rolex dials...so 3-4 years ago.....that prompted me to sell 80% of my Rolex. I had started on Patek in 2009....so it pre-dated my bigger exodus. But the selling of the Rol...