NoQuartz
19
try both of them out...
I was faced with the same dilemma recently and after looking at the pictures I was dead set on getting the grey dial. I found an AD who had both in stock and went in to try them out. The folks here have already commented on this - you have to try them out in person and it also depends upon your style preference. I tried both of them on my wrist - even walked out in the daylight to see how they looked outside the artificial lighting in the showroom - I ended up picking the 001 (cream dial). There was no question in my mind about the choice - the grey dial was just too hard to read and was too shiny for my liking. The cream dial was classic, easy to read, and fit my style and skin color best.
Patek 5146g Need help?
Hello everyone. Good day to all 8). Like to find out what's everyone picks and why? Patek 5146g in dial cream or black??? Can't decide? Thanks in advance. Kind regards, DD...
Grey
Grey looks more elegant and sophisticated for me. I will pick the grey dial between these two.
Grey
Grey looks good in the photo. Suggest you go & put it on your wrist for comparison... Got a feeling that the cream dial may looks better in person. Good luck & Happy Pateking Best wishes, KK
My choice is very easy ...
but I don´t know your lifestyle, your colour of skin, your collection, your ... and that makes it really difficult to offer some serious help. Oliver
it depends on how and where you will wear it most...
IMO the black dial looks more stylish than the cream color one but based on my experience with a black dial watch, it is very difficult to read the time in darker places such as restaurants with dim lighting, bars, etc. good luck with your ultimate decisi...
GLau, for me hit the nail right on the head.....
That is why I chose the cream coloured dial :) Though I would be sorely tempted with the grey dial on a Y/G 5146.
It's only you who know which one you like more.
If somebody would put a pistol against my head and say: "five seconds time to decide", I would answer without hesitation: "darker". But both are nice. If somebody would ask me which is the nicest version of 5146, I would say "P". And it's very close to th...
Good point Kari!
When buying a watch of this cost and calibre, you should not have uncertainty or indecision. This is how post-sales regret happens. Any of us who have purchased many watches in our lives have made a decision we regretted (and it usually started with not b...
I don't have regrets...
People who have regrets are those who don't really know what they like and have wavering tastes and act emotionally in the moment and not based on their true selves. I've never had regrets about the major accessories that I've purchased. And those who do,...
IMO...
I have second thoughts from time to time about not having bought the one with a grey dial but cream works for me... :) ...
J for me...
Is that the original strap? Looks a bit light? I've owned the 5146J for 3 years now; a stunningly beautiful watch; the dial in some light fall will even color a bit pinkish! ...
My basic rule of thumb when in doubt is to be more
conservative than edgy. So, if I faced this dilemma, I would opt for the cream dial. Personally, I like some of the different dials but I have also found I tire of them quickly. At this price point and coupled with the fact that changing dials is not nece...
The case and dial design are already very classic style
A cream dial gives the 5146 an even more classic look, while the grey dial is more contemporary to my opinion. It's just a matter of taste which one you prefer. Good luck with the better dilemmas in life. :-)
In terms of versatility...
the 5146G slate dial wins, but in terms of classic & conservative look as mentioned by others then the cream dial all the way...though i'd pick a rose gold case for that one, just my opinion! Mine... ...
try both of them out...
I was faced with the same dilemma recently and after looking at the pictures I was dead set on getting the grey dial. I found an AD who had both in stock and went in to try them out. The folks here have already commented on this - you have to try them out...
Grey dial legibility
While the white gold hands can be difficult to see against the grey dial (depending on the lighting), the lume in the hands is always visible against that background. I was concerned about the same sort of thing with my 5056P, but found that the lume fill...
Neither, you don't love either one enough. Or Both, you love them both equally.
Not a personal attack on you, but my understanding is Patek Philippe watches are for strong-minded people who can make decisions of their own. I'm getting surprised that we're getting more and more of these posts. I'd do some soul searching and really lea...
Gray
The cream dial looks pretty nice on other PP AC watches, but for the 5146, I like the gray dial.