Robert65
1054
You are corresponding with an understanding audience
If I may compliment you - please accept my respect and admiration for sharing your thoughts with us on this decision process. In my opinion, your research and openness only demonstrates your intelligence. I believe this decision is in fact important. Please take your time and continue to enjoy the process.
Best,
Robert
advice needed - 5960 vs 5172G-010 or 5170G-001
Good evening all, I need some help with a relatively unimportant problem. I recently acquired a JLC duometre chronograph in the original yellow gold and am absolutely loving the finishing on it. That, and just maturing as a collector, has caused me to thi...
This is an interesting one. I have owned the 5960G, currently own the 5172G-01 and have tried on the 5170G and the Lange 1815 Boutique Chrono extensively. Here are my thoughts:
1. 5960 - loved the pushers, dial layout and colour scheme, but over time two things bothered me: thickness and the fact that it was doing too many things at the same time. Do one thing and do it really well. Manual chrono > auto. 2. 5170 - lovely breguet...
thickness isn't horrible for me
I do agree with the sentiment to do one thing and do it well. Not that the 5960 does anything poorly, and actually combines a bunch of things well, just thought that movement finishing on the others is def superior. In fact, the 5960 technically, is prob ...
Unimportant problems are our favorite hobby. :))))
The one I would sell is the 116509. The 5960 is such a cool and interesting modern Patek! Which version do you have?
That was the plan
Until the recent application of the film. Let me see how it feels in a month or so. But, this was my original thought too. I'm sure the least "interesting" homologically speaking
I would choose the 1815 chronograph
or a VC Cornes de Vache. I own the rose gold Cornes de Vache and it is my personal favorite modern hand-wound chronograph, with the 1815 as a strong contender. But I’m probably in the minority. Just my personal preference. Wishing you the best for your ch...
Some nice choices...
you are considering. I really like the 5170G-001, it'll look less dressy with a more casual strap. I'll look for the first series in WG if I go for the 1815 Chrono. The VC Malte Chrono PT CEP is a great alternative too. I owned those three but sold them t...
I’ll check those out
Also love the VC and think the cornes de vache are the nicest lugs out there but it looked a little dressier than I wanted.
Breguet numerals sold me on the 5170
Case is under 11mm and pleasantly wears larger than the 39.4mm diameter. Although you're asking about the G (and I have the R) you should be able appreciate the applied Breguet numerals from this macro shot. Best, Robert ...
You are corresponding with an understanding audience
If I may compliment you - please accept my respect and admiration for sharing your thoughts with us on this decision process. In my opinion, your research and openness only demonstrates your intelligence. I believe this decision is in fact important. Plea...
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and asking the forum members for their suggestions ! As a Patek moderator, I am naturally biased toward this brand🤣
Hence I would weigh in on 5170 or 5172. Alternatives are 5131, 5110 or 5130 if you like Patek's iconic WT pieces.
Great pics
Thanks for those and the ones above. What a tough decision. Those Breguet numbers are beautiful.
Vouching for the 5170 with Breguet (don't forget the intoxicating movement with lateral clutch)
Wearing it today under a long sleeve and love sneaking peeks at the dial throughout the day just to see those applied numerals. Feels like I'm getting away with something naughty because it's such a hidden treat to possess. Classic architecture. Best, Rob...
My pleasure!
There's more to life than beautiful applied Breguet numerals (in the world of dress complications) but that is my personal priority.