m2
3481
How acceptable are quality issues to you?
I thought this would be a fun topic. For me, it depends on the price range of the watch and what reasons I’m buying for.
If you are buying a small production vintage patek or rolex, you aren’t expecting some magical jump in quality. You’re paying for rarity/low production.
But where I do expect perfection is expensive independents or modern watches.
I think for example the difference between the Handmade 1 by Greubel and Roger Smith is pretty crazy. I’d throw haldimann into that mix too and RS is nowhere close to either.
Some will bring up the handmade thing re: RA but RS isn’t even handmade anymore and has been using cnc for a long time but has very low quality standards; contrast vs Greubel’s handmade 1 or Haldimann who seem flawless and are handmade.
The watch listed at Christie’s up for auction this month is a good example and Quill and Pad did a good write up too…
So where do you draw the line? What’s unacceptable! What is?
This message has been edited by India Whiskey Charlie on 2024-11-08 01:19:15
Vintage
Explore the legacy of English watchmaking masters Thomas Tompion and George Graham, their innovations, and enduring influence on modern horology. Discover the historical significance of their work and the finishing techniques that continue to inspire.
37 replies14150 views
Collection
Explore the Greubel Forsey Signature 1 in stainless steel through a collector's lens. mrds shares his acquisition, detailing its unique appeal and community insights.
57 replies9215 views
Collection
Bernard Cheong shares his emotional journey with Greubel Forsey, detailing how their watches redefined his standards for finishing, technology, and craft.
48 replies25796 views
Collection
Explore GreatPilot@me.com's incredible acquisition of a Roger Smith Series 2, Vianney Halter Classic, and Greubel Forsey Double Balancier. Insights into the independent watch market and collection strategy.
82 replies11275 views
Community
The Prix Gaïa 2014 honored Kari Voutilainen, Pierre Thomann, and Henri Dubois at the MIH. Discover their contributions to watchmaking craftsmanship, research, and entrepreneurship.
4 replies1960 views
Independents
BjoernM21 reviews essential books on independent master watchmakers, offering a guide to building a horological library and preserving knowledge.
11 replies13042 views
How acceptable are quality issues to you?
I thought this would be a fun topic. For me, it depends on the price range of the watch and what reasons I’m buying for. If you are buying a small production vintage patek or rolex, you aren’t expecting some magical jump in quality. You’re paying for rari...
I also kept debating about these mechanical parts and hand polishing…
They do wear and tear. I don’t believe some deep beveling or nice sharp angles cannot be achieved by another watchmaker who’s assigned one job just to polish. Hence I won’t buy too high end expensive Indies…but who do I know? Does the brush strokes of tho...
This particular watch is from many years ago, yet people are still using it to bash Roger Smith
I don't think that's fair at all. Either one should provide a recent example, or I would say that the argument doesn't have a leg to stand on in this. Now, I don't mean to be unnecessarily harsh to you, my apologies, but I've seen this exact argument on a...
Well… Make a watch from scratch, then total the amount of time and money spent. Add the lost value of your time pursuing a more lucrative opportunity. Pull out a 10x optic and compare results. Go through a hundred iterations.
Personally, I am in awe of anyone who is willing to step onto the stage and subject themselves to public scrutiny. 🧐
Put me in the approval camp …
Of loving evidence of the “Hand of the Maker”! I have no problem with signs that a human being was involved, especially where magnification of this order is required. I think the beauty lies in the wonderful dial design, the history behind this extraordin...
Quality of execution is something I think is overlooked quite a bit, especially in the current indy hype
Being "handmade" doesn't make it good... or even actually handmade. Having 50 interior angles doesn't mean any of them were executed well. Innovative complications doesn't equate to well tested, performant, and reliable. In the current indy craze I think ...
RS watches are 95% handmade
He uses CNC for the cutting of components, and he doesn't make jewels, springs, and gaskets. He has openly shared such info with watch publications, social media, speeches, gatherings, and watch fairs. It's not a secret. His workshop is opened for any of ...
Not all components,
but only the raw pieces for some movement components if I heard him correctly. A watch is not just movements.. He made the case, lugs, dial, crown and bezel using traditional methods, hand-guilloche and engraved the dial, plus finishing of the movement (m...
According to this esquire interview, 80% of the man hours are spent on finishing cnc'd parts.
"We’ve always used CNC machines,” explains Smith. “I’ve never shied away from showing that. If you want to make more than one watch a year you need to use CNC, there’s no question. Making pocket watches by hand is one thing but the reduced tolerances requ...
Price commensurate of the quality and service.
Pick any two: Low Price High Quality Excellent Customer Service Robots are 'perfect', get a Swatch 51. Yes some names / houses / brands do seem overly hyped in price versus actual quality and watchmaker hours, herd mentality and all that. Best value/quali...
Debatable, but unreasonable...
Roger Smith might pump out 15 - 20 watches in a banger year, while Greubel Forsey is producing 200+ watches pear year. In comparison, Roger Smith's watches rely on the human hand to a greater degree. Of course if you want to fly close to the sun of perfec...
The stats are telling
260 annually for GF and 18 per year for Roger Smith - that's more GF in 1 year than the total Roger Smith ever made (150 up to Oct 2023)...
That's misformation
White gold S2 now retails at £357,200. The retail for this particular S2 would have been much lower then.
No box and papers
I don't have a Series 2 and tempted to join the bidding, but decided against as a i prefer a complete set
No box and paper for a Roger Smith
The results for any Greubel Forsey are telling on the other hand
Price = what buyers
are willing to pay for handwork. That's it. Roger is not forcing his watches on us adults spending our own money freely.
You keep implying price is telling or production is telling. This is a thread about quality of finish and execution, neither auction results nor production numbers tell anything about quality.
This is exactly the point I made above, people use what they are told to make inferences or even excuses for quality when in fact price, rarity, marketing, media, etc are not real indicators of quality. RM tourbillon secondary prices way stronger than RWS...
I have replied on "quality"
I posted above Roger's style of finishing is not the style of French/Swiss. George Daniels has a dim view on finishing and it shows in his own watches. Roger is an apprentice of GD so why are you judging him based on your own view of finishing? What exact...
I really don’t know where you are getting your information from.
RWS uses CNC machines for everything, including cases. That Youtube video you cite is years old. Even there, he makes the final cuts on the case with a CNC. For the record, I have no problem with CNC machines and in fact prefer it if my watches are made u...
At this point especially after I pointed you to actual videos
I'm convinced you are either (1) trolling (2) watched the video of Rolex manufacturing since you love Rolex (3) hate handmade watches with a passion (4) enjoy misinformation and/or (5) hate Roger Smith. I'm at a loss for words for someone who refuses to a...
Maybe you didn't watch all of the youtube videos.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KWtblU8-emY&t=0s Roger: "We use CNC quite a bit, especially with the case work" Like you, I am averse to misinformation. Perhaps your definition of handmade is different from my own. You have every right to enjoy your incom...
If you heard what he said in that same video
The CNC was used to punch holes for the gasket (to improve water resistance) and screws. At that point the case was already completed. You conveniently missed all 6 of 7 videos of how he handmade his case. Do yourself a favour - watch how the GF HM1 was m...
Exactly
I feel like the point of the thread is being missed. These are clear flaws and objectively bad quality.
What exactly is quality?
Chronometry? Movement infrastructure? Service interval? Robustness? Tolerance between parts? Can you please define because your thread is all about "quality" which you have not defined to this date. Do you have real ownership experience to derive such a c...
Phillips has one of these coming up for auction too, more photos to check out 😀
Crazy 2 out of 5 coming up for auction at the same time