Horological Meandering

ShowTime
119

• Show profile
• Show other posts

WOW! That’s a magnificent question. Short answer is: 5101.

Of course both watches are beautiful. I myself had the similar dilemma and I strongly think 5101 is a more interesting option.

1) Shape. I suppose the rectangular shape is more interesting than a round one? Why? I suppose that you have at least several round watches so one more round watch doesn’t bring much to the collection. But a nice looking shaped watch always makes a collection more complete.
Winner: 5101

2. Desing. LF is a classical and very refined watch. That’s cool, but the are many alternatives. 5101 has a unique art deco design. You can’t find almost any art deco watches in the market regardless the price. That alone makes this watch super special.
Also I would like to add that the shape of 5101 is mesmerising. Truly beautiful.
Winner: 5101.

3. Dial and hands.
Hands.
LF hands are more exquisite. Very sleek and elegant. PP does a good job, but not smth special.

Dial.
LF has enamel dial and in my book that’s the best option that can be utilised for a dial.
PP has a less simple dial. I don’t adore the word « tourbillon » and a number on a dial. But it doesn’t spoil it.

Indices.
I love applied indices - so it’s a win for PP.
Winner: both are fine, maybe LF is bit better due to the enamel dial and sleek hands.

4.Movement
Technically they are both magnificent. LF has an interesting solution of double barrels. But 5101 was designed and adjusted to show exceptional chronometer results.
As far as power reserve is concerned - not sure that 10 days is better than 3 days. In 5101 the movement is under bigger stress due to the long powerful springs. So it may be less robust.
Winner: 5101

5.Finishing
5101 looks OK. The only thing that may have been improved - the plate that covers the movement seems to be too big.
I can’t understand why people praise the finishing of 5101 to be exceptional. PP has done a fantastic job but it doesn’t stand up to independents’ quality.

LF lacks internal angles. Its movement has a very nice architecture so it could have been a movement with a marvellous finishing. But in reality it is just appropriate.
Winner: 5101


Conclusion. 5101 is better.

PS if you want 5101 to fit your wrist perfectly - buy a soft leather strap that bends across your wrist easily. You will elevate the looks and the comfort of 5101.