image

A quick Review on the Benrus Type I and II

amanico
Avatar

Here's a pair of watches I own for several months, now, and that I appreciate a lot, the Benrus Type I and II

The Benrus Type I was chosen by the US Navy, just after the TR 900, at the end of the 60ies, very beginning of the 70ies, and then was replaced by the Benrus Type II.

Here, the Type I and the Type II together: ( Type I is on your left )

none

Some of the Type I have been called " Stérile ", while the others are not.

Why is the Type I sometimes called " Stérile " ?

As you will see, there is no marking at all on the dial, which is normal for all the Type I, but also on the case back - other than the serial number - not even the name of the luminous material ( promethium 247 ? ) used for the hands and indexes - which is exclusive to the so called stérile version.

The Stérile Case Back:

none

The Non Stérile Case Back:

none

Some say that the total lack of marking was due to the fact that the watch was in dotation for some secret services, like the CIA, or some Special Forces, which will, in case they were made prisonners, make any identification to a Country impossible.

Some others say, which is more probable, that these " Stérile " versions were some kind of prototypes or pre production watches, tested before the final " non stérile " Type I.

Anyway, let's go back to Reality and to the Watch...

The Type I, stérile or not, is an eye catching watch.

The dimensions are unusally generous for a watch of this era, as the case is around 42 mm big, and 14 mm thick, with 20 mm fixed lug bars which are very close to the case, so be careful when you choose your strap, as it won't pass under the lugs and the case if it is too thick.

The assymetrical stainless steel case is sandblasted and offers a light grey look, very propice to the use it was destined for.

none

none

It has to be precised that the construction of the case is monobloc, which means that if you want to have an access to the movement, you first have to remove the bezel, then the plexy, which is fixed to the case with a " Baionnette " system ( Once again, sorry but I don't know who to credit for this superb picture ) :

none

The screw in crown ( male / female construction ) is almost integrated in the assymetrical case:

none

The plexy is superdomed, with a nice integration to the case via the bezel, as shown here:

none

The dial is another very interesting part on this watch, a kind of " signature ".

none

Credit pic: Zaf.

none

Don't know who to credit for this last picture, so if you know, please tell me.

It has no writing at all, as previously said, hence a great purity and strength.

Its layout is very close to its Sister, the TR 900, showing triangular( at 12 ), rectangular ( at 3, 6 and 9 ) and round indexes, and similar hands.

Here, the Benrus in great company ( Benrus / Rolex Submariner 5508 / Tornek Rayville ) :

none

It simple look greatly deserves the legibility of the watch.

As for the luminous material used on the hands and indexes, I'd say it is Promethium 247, the same than on the TR 900, but I saw one coming with a with a T- Swiss - T dial, as shown below, with a big flaw: The case has been polished...

none

none

Note that this is the only one I saw with such a dial, so I'm not sure about its authenticity...

The bezel is bi directional, non ratchet, with the triangular index which is the only one ot be luminous.

The funny thing, when you look at the bezel and at the dial, is that the bezel looks much more charged, busy than the dial, but the graduation till 20 may be more useful for Military in action, than without graduation other than each 5 minutes, like on the TR 900.

The movement was provided by ETA, a Cal 2620, which is a 17 jewels automatic winding, made and modified under military specifications ( as well as the dial ), with an hacking second, 42 hours power reserve, and signed "GS1D2 " ( I don't know what it means ) :

none

On the wrist, its simple and brutal look does it all:

none

none

The Benrus Type II shares all these characteristics, less the dial, which is the only different thing.

Indeed, the dial is much more charged, as, instead of the round and rectangular indexes , you have minutes indexes which are separated, each five minutes, by triangular indexes, then you have a 12 hours indication, and, if it wasn't enough, another indication of the 24 hours, just above the 12 hour numbers:

none

none

Charged and different, yes, actually it is not charmless.

The military look is still here, as well as the brutal look of this watch.

none

none

One thing I didn't say about this Benrus is that you have 2 kind of Type 2:

The Class A, with some luminous material on the dial, and the Class B, which has no luminous material at all.

But Type I or II, you will have a nice watch, and as an extra, History behind!

Hoping that you will enjoy this post,

Best to All.

Nicolas

 



Comments:
Avatar
Chris Meisenzahl November 7th, 2010-04:04
Very nice Classics, thanks for the pics, enjoy!
Avatar
amanico November 7th, 2010-06:54
My pleasure, Chris. Thanks for reading. 
Avatar
E.J. November 7th, 2010-07:10
Great post, Nicolas I love a lot these watches... true tool watches with lot of charm, indeed. And your two watches are awesome, my friend. Thanks for this gret job, hermano emilio
Avatar
amanico November 7th, 2010-07:23
You know them very well, Emilio. These 2 are great Military Diving watches. Not very known, but not less interresting. Thanks for the nice words! Un abrazo. Nicolas.
Avatar
MattS November 7th, 2010-07:43
Not really the watch to wear with a formal suit! But I like it very much! Here is my Type II. Matt... 
Avatar
amanico November 7th, 2010-07:56
Crispy shot, Matt... I know, it is not very conventional to wear it with a suit, but it is the fun of it. You definitely have a stunning collection, my friend. All the best, Nicolas;
Avatar
aldossari_faisal November 7th, 2010-08:26
one exciting and interesting post i really had a nice read Nicolas , personally believe that you have a bigger love and appreciation for the Type 1 , both got the same case size?! Best wishes . Faisal
Avatar
amanico November 7th, 2010-08:35
The dial is the only thing which changes, Faisal. Yes, I have a light preferrence for the Type I, but I'm very happy to won the Type II, too. Thanks for your nice words, my friend. Best, Nicolas
Avatar
aldossari_faisal November 7th, 2010-10:04
Dear Nicolas allow me to thank you again after getting me to admire the beauty of vintage watches ... i do have wish list for vintage watches now ... add to that im admiring the beauty of Tornek Rayville ... Best my friend. Faisal
Avatar
amanico November 7th, 2010-10:08
Welcome to the Club of Vintage and Modern watches, Faisal. It is quite rare to love both Vintage and Modern watches... Isn't it a delicious nightmare? Best, and thanks for your nice words. Nicolas.
0-10-10

Load More Comments




 Next Article
image
SJX
Avatar

A look at the revamped Zenith collection

SJX
Avatar
As I mentioned in an earlier post on the Zenith Christoph Colomb Tourbillon ( click here to see it), CEO Jean-Frederic Dufour has remade the aesthetics of the brand for the better. There are still a handful of ugly watches in the collection, which are mostly holdovers from previous collections, but no more ghastly ones. The new collection still retains an emphasis on the El Primero (what else?) but the watches are more classical, with a frequent use of a retro 1970s style case. The subsequent follow ups will detail the El Primero Captain, El Primero Rattrapante, Retrotimer, Striking 10th, Elite Ultra-Thin and El Primero Ladies Vintage.


Go to top.

About US | Contact

© 2017 - WatchProZine