WatchProSite|Market|Digest
WatchProSite|Market|Digest

Patek Philippe

I've been offered a 5980 from my AD

 

He is asking a MAJOR premium, but it is still a LOT less than the asking prices of the gray market. On the one hand, it is exciting to be offered the watch. It's a weird and unique Patek, which will IMHO, go only up in value, etc, etc. But in the final analysis, is it 'right' for an AD to ask 20K or more over list??? I mean, if the gray market is asking 35K-plus! over list...? It's all pretty outrageous. Yet, try to find a 5980. Try to find a 5980 for even 30K over list ANYWHERE. I am stimulated by the thought of owning one, but I would like to try to 'keep my marbles' and be somewhat sane... what would you do? Let's say, for argument, its 20K above list--while the gray market, as noted, is 35 plus above.... your insights and opinions welcomed.

  login to reply
Related Content
expand_more
5980NautilusNautilus ChronographPatek Philippe
💰1729 Marketplace Listings for Patek Philippe›
From the Digest
Patek Philippe 5980 Chronograph Collection
Collection
Patek Philippe 5980 Chronograph Collection
David Allen · Jul 18, 2023
David Allen shares his journey to acquiring the Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5980/1A-001. Explore its unique blue dial, historical quirks, and community insights.
25 replies6017 views
Patek Philippe 5905A Flyback Chronograph Annual Calendar
Reference Guide
Patek Philippe 5905A Flyback Chronograph Annual Calendar
socal to az · Jul 22, 2022
Explore the Patek Philippe 5905A Annual Calendar Chronograph in steel with a green dial. Read a collector's review comparing it to the 5905P and community insights on its bracelet and presence.
25 replies10307 views
27 Comments view entire thread 

No No No

 
By: MTF : September 18th, 2007-09:45
Patek Philippe would be appaled that profiteering is being suggested by an authorised dealer. That premium will NOT be seen by Patek Philippe because they already received his 'appropriate' low cost of goods through the normal distributor channels. Patek ... 

AD

 
By: roberto : September 18th, 2007-10:44
You know, PP may well be appalled but I have seen a 5980 recently with August 07 papers from one of the PP boutiques and in December I saw a 5004P with November 06 papers from another PP boutique. If their own boutiques which they own and in theory can sc... 

NOT RIGHT !!!!!

 
By: David-S-W : September 19th, 2007-06:56
Mostel, I do not think it is right for an AD to charge a premium . ARE THEY CRAZY. Keep in mind that the AD pays the cost and clears a good margin of profit. Making double profit is uncalled for. I know a couple AD that will make you buy a PP of equal val... 

This is eye opening

 
By: Mostel : September 19th, 2007-07:44
Thanks to everyone who responded. You know, not long ago, a different AD asked me for above list on a 5970, which I thought was totally outrageous. He then asked me to BUY A 2nd watch if I did not want to pay above list for the 5970. Repeat: this is a dif... 

Who is it?

 
By: M. : September 19th, 2007-08:55
actually quite interested in were the AD is from....

I meant

 
By: David-S-W : September 19th, 2007-10:19
"offer" to sell you a 5980 if you buy a PP of equal value.......

A minor dissent

 
By: vitalsigns : September 20th, 2007-10:05
If you are a big enough and loyal enough customer (in your mind), certainly I can understand your frustration and disappointment. If you are not a big enough or loyal enough customer (in the AD's mind), then I can partly understand the high price since ra... 

My Experience

 
By: M Segal : September 21st, 2007-05:52
I posted a similar situation on another Patek board. I was quickly shot down by other posters for not having finalized the details before ordering. Now the AD I purchased from has seen my business for the past ten years and I have purchased MANY watches f... 

Agreed

 
By: Mostel : September 21st, 2007-08:19
It's a racket in some ways... but the AD's side is not fully understood either. In my conversation with him, I continued to learn his side of it, which was not entirely BS, IMHO. At this time in Patek history, the price is more important than the watch. H...